Skip navigation
CLN bookstore

Aclu v Dod Doj Questionnaire Regarding Detainees 00000834

Download original document:
Brief thumbnail
This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. Check the original document to verify accuracy.
Department-of J,us,tic.e Inspector .Gener,al 'Questi,onnaire Re9,ar.Qln·9 D~t~·in.ec~·s
O:OJ.-:OI(3 INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONNAIRE
E:=O~..R:~V+EW

AN[j' USE o,N,Ly B,YIND'i,y.IDyAL F!31 ItFSPQND'ENTS
DQNOT .FORWARD' OR, DI,~EMI~ATE

QUESTIONNAIRE ID: teSt-O,O.OO.O$34

,As of 1:he last timl!'thjs,q~~tfonnair~w~s ~a~~~i' $ome r~quire_dlieids:haV~)19~ peen cC?mplefed.
PJeas~,re:View your' responses.

:A.

P~r~on~

Please

I:Infprmation

pr.ovide' thef611owiJi~l

1,FIr,SJ: name.
'2..,MiQ9te ·Inlt.lfil:

iriformation:

6 &, 7e PER A.~REEIVIENt
6 & Ie PER AGREEMENT

,.

3~ last name:,

6 &-lC PER AGREEMENT

4. Erite~d, btl nuty Date (EOD);

6 &,7e

'5: CurJent Dl'1isfqnlF.ield' 6ffi~e:
6~, Cu,rrel)t 10b titl~:
.7. Direct.dial office;telephone nl.iniber:
8•.FBI cell phOtie' numoer:
,9.,fBI p:ager l,1urnber~
10., ,B~st q~ntact nUlJ1ber fOf YO!l~

.6 ~ 7e
SUPerVisory. SpedC:lI.Ag:el;lt
6'& 7C,PE:RAGREEMENT
6 ~. 76 P'E~AGREElV1ENT
6~.7CPE.RJJ.GREEMENT
61& 7,C PER,A'GREEMElVt

11.· At anV time att,et--::Septeitiber HI 20,01" aid Y0U ~fve.a·~ d member ofthe u.s, Military, or' as an.
'employee or contractor of the· FB1.or 'any other-government agency/ at :Guantana'mo Bay, Cuba; Iraq i
Afg'hal,1{stan'; 'or'ih ~reqs cqntrol{¢d !:!y"trye I).!:l~ rVfilitqry Qra U\5. InteIHg~nce·servi~e irrq:u:JfJe,qtjo!1,;with ~he
:gl~bal V\{qr on' serroT'?
'
@,Yes 0 No,

of

·~,2. !=nter tHe nu.mber ~6f tim~,syoo. w.¢r.e.,depkw~,d o.F:~sstgn~d to eaCh t,he,fQiloW\rig IQtatrorj~.
,(Guahtanaina BaYi: Cuba} lra(t~:·Afghatlistan;,or in :any areas' controlled by theLU.S. 'Milit~lrY ,Of. a U.S.
i,!1teIU~renc~ serVf~'¢l ;2'· ,
. '
For,each deployment or assi~;i1ment .complete the followrn.~ section.
Location (select. one) ,
, Deployment or a~,signmeri1;'qeg1inoiJ,~1'
Dep!p.Ym.eilto,r i1S5!!im:mlnt,e,n,ded on.
.

." . . . . . '

iG,lJa'nta'ricitric{i3'a-o/,
>

~

•

""" .,.... ~ ':t~

...: _" ...... _.

abo,~t

or. about,

07!16J2003.

09[02(2.003:

l~a. v.lht;ff wa~ the :g,el):e(al natu r'~ "'riP p:l:Irp'q~e

•

qf YQu'rassig nhiel)~' a.h~ :ap:iviti~s]

lnterview detairiees'reQa'rding terrorist financiriq' iTUitters
t2b. Please provide the'names of the.specificcamps, bases!, or facilities where you worked.

C~mP.'Pti!lt~ C'"
• •
. •
,
•
"
.'
.....
~ ",
12c. No.t~: If infu'rmi'itlon: :about ~ ;specific camp, base,. Qr'faCjlitY i~·c1a:~sjfie.d :ab:oy~ s~eRET,
t)lea;:;e ch:ee;:k h¢re' Dr 'iriclud.e jnyo~n:inswer that-yollhav.erlladditional·information ctpss,illecI a.Qove
'SECRET,,'~' and, if .you know, 'id,entify 'the:c1assification level, 'tiCket, ,i::6mpaifrrient, prog ram, ,01' .other
desig n;~tI0rT that-applies ,o,the InformatIon, Do !19t Include,the-add It!onar 'classified fnform'atron In 'Y0tl r
,

.

OIGQ-005058

ql.,fe-s.tipnnal.re re.sponse$. bIG personnel w'ith the nece$Sary clearance Will qmtact you to rec~jve it.

Name

I

Position
Acting'
. . . . .S~peNisorv'Special
.. .~
. Agent

l

"'I"":"'::--'=""':"":--~~-:-:-' _ - - - ~-- -,-.- --.-.:~uy~ryJ~!Y~~~.!-ale.g~nJ
i1'2e.. Djq youjoint!Y' interview or !r:i~~!Tqg,a.t~ any Qe~i.nee wIth n'Qn-FBI p~rsQnl)el1
O~

I

-~ -.- -- __ -.--

~~

b6
b7C

~
I

-1- -~ - - - -- '- ~- - - - - - -- - - - - - - .....- - - - '- - -"- - - - - - - - -'_ . . . ~ - - -- - _ ....... --- - - -- _ . . . :.- - .... - - - - - - -!
.;12f. Did 'Iou jointly: jjlan 'any 'detainee iritervleW.or int~[(ogatioll :strategy, objectiv~~ 'pr ta~cj:(cs with ilQn- "
.:FBI person:nel7.
.
.
~ Ye~
'0 No
~:Wjth':Wh~t' ki~d~~ ;fnQ~:F6I ~~r~d,~n;i~i&

YQU W~~.kjQirii·IY?- -..... -,' ~--- ,.. - ~ .. ~ -~,' ".'->

~

-

...

P.,- -

•

; D·GITF'

: 0,·O.therV..s. Millta,ry

~ tI u.s, ihtelligence a,genqr
.: 0 Foreig n military' or inteiligence agency

': 0 Ot~er
~
-

-

-

; - -:. _

-

-

-

.... -

-

-

--<

-.- -.-

-

~

~'-'

-

-

-

'-

'I- -

--

-

-

-

...

-

-

.....

_ _ ._ -

·~12g;, We(e'y~r; e,Ve'r:p.therw..ise

-

_

-

-

-

.. -

-

-

_,_

-

-

~

~

-

...

-

-

-

_ _ . - __ ..... -

inY<;J!vej;! in

-

-

-

-

-

-::-- _

-

-

-

-

_ _ .-

.~~~~t:a.~·a~'<L~~.Y

-

-

~

-

-

-

_;" -

-

~

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

_ ..... _

-

-

-

-

-

- . -: '":" ......

~.

_~

'.
-.--0 -

_

..... , : -

•
-:,:

~etqir.ree int~rvie1J{~:or'jnterrpga,tions wi~1)

o Yes

'0

L.~;a.-ti;n~.(:.~e,~,- :.n.:'- - - -- -- - - - - i);p~~:;tit;;r:;;slirll~;;nt
about

J.

...

NQ

b;g;;

no!);-FBI ~r$Onnel? .;
.
;ri~o; - - Q~ploy.;~-nt:;r-;';si'g-;;;;rJ ;n~;lo~ - ~
or·about·'

10/28j20'Os

11[18/200'3'

t2a. What was the geheral natu re and p'utpose of your,assignment and aCtivltie's7

Interview d.et~r(lee~ regC!rd.i~g terrqrrs~ financin,g !1JC)tter::s
t2:p·,. Please proyi~e. th~.nam~ qf fh.e:sp¢~ifi~:9~rfiP'~, ba~e?i 9J ~iliti~$ w.l)er~ YQu vtor~e~,

:Ca'rrip Delta

n.t·, Note: If iriformati6nabdlit a ;sp.ecificccamp, b'as'~" or facility' is ;dassifiedabpve SECRET,
pleaSe Gheck: here 0, inClude. in your !afiswer tnat .you. have. "additional in{ormation·dassifieo iabove
'~ECR!=T/" andr: if yoy kl:1Qw,'lde.titify th~ c1ps~m¢aiiqJi tev~l; :ticket! 'cgrnpattrrrent, p'rogr~m, on:>ther
designation 'that applies to the informatio'n. DQ not include the aAditiQnalclassified informatibn: in 'your
qll~~ionnaire-:r~spoiises.;.QIG. p:erSonn~1 With the. ne<;essary ~!~arah~e will c,ont.aet you to ree;eive it.
n
'
~';'''--

-- --- -- --- --- -,--- -----'---'-,--

--~-,--~ - - - , -

-

- - - -,-'- - - - - -

-

-,_,,:,- - - - - . - , - - - - - - - - 7 .

~:n<!·_PlE:.~~ ld~!)ti.(y t.Jr{ n<!rn~ ~ nq,.r:i<2.sl~lo.!(al!.l}~ t!w§ ,:-tli~ f[31 Q~~n.:.nilL't..o;.:~tl6 nLyq,uJ1't~!I~ !:~prt§Q.:

~~~~=iojJr ~~~.Q~~~rfr=O!~·~~~n=nl~n!.~
Name.'

L__ ~ __ ~

I

~

,Position

__ ~

.

~l!P~D"Js2P{~e~<Qalb9~n.L

b6

:.

.b7C

.~.2e.. Did YOIl jointlY ilit~rvi~W 91" int~rro,gqte AJw'9~tai.nee witH n9n-F~t p~ts~nn~l?
(!) '(e.s
0 No·

"";

• _

..,.

"

_

.. "" _

.... _

_

.... _

_

~

_

•.

,. '.

_ .

,. ..

~

"" _

;.. _. _

,....

,~

...

.! ... _

,.,. _

... ,

_

_

.. _ _

¥

_

._

•

_....

.....

w

_

....

_,

.,

~

_

_

~,

....

__

~

...

_

...

. With what kinds of noh-FBI personnel did 'you Work jointly?"
: [j CITF
.

: 0' Other.U.S. Military
: 0 lp;;, int!?lI)gerrc~ ag:~I1GY.
;- 0- "":'F- e!_relg
h Ii1I!it:cjry 9r Iht~lIlg~ric~.F1gE;!hcy
.... - 7' - - - - - ----.•- - _ .... - - ' - - ... -- -¥-.- - - -.-- -:":""'-":"'"-- -

.'
•

~

I

~:

- - -:- "":- -:- .... - -:-"',-':;' - - - - :-:-::- - - --,---:- - -:- -.

OIGQ-005059

1~-:~~~:~~~~~~~~~~r~~~=~~~~=~~~=~~~~-~~~~7==~~~=~~~~=~~~~~~'~~~~~~~~~~'~I

10
'Other
I
,.

1
"

I

,

1

I
, ••

~

•

.,

......

~

.-

•

_

•

,..

_

,

.'

•

•

__

1

_

~

•

_

"'

•

__

-

:-

•

_ _,

__ .•.•

•

-

•••

_

•••••

.

-

-

-

-

_

-

-

••

_

• •'

1

.:12[ Did VpUjdirjtl~lp'lah .ahY'd~taifi~ intervIeW or Interrogation ~rategy" obj~JV~/, or t;actics iivith non- :
:FBI personnel?
.
_
0· Yes
0 No.
•.

=-W~h what-ki~ds ~rnoh.:fBi'p·~r~;nei:dld

: 0 ,CITF>
~, IiI o.tner I).S. Miiitary·
~ 0 U.S. intelliQence agel1ciy

': q

y'bu:W6;kj~riltiy? ---- --'- --- --,- - -<. -.'- ------- --,- -'i
"

.l:

.'

P-qrgig,n:m.i.litary or tflt~l1ige(lJ;e agency

,: OOlher
...- -- - -:

)

..:..

- - --- -.... - -

':"

~

-- - -,.. _. - - --....
";"

..,. .........

-.... - - - ~

- _.....

.....

:izg:.;we-t~ y7>u'~v;r-q1he~,is~ ir\\!9l\(~' i~,d~t~ih'¢,e-:int~rVi~w$,

.:

' .

0' Yes

- -- .... - -_............- ~ - -- - - ...... ...... - - - -.. ;
dr int'it-rog~ffQ;~ Wifh-n6rt=FBtp'~r~Q~';~i, - ~:
_'"

,@ No,

,m-'- --,- - - - - - - -- --- --- -,-- - - - -""--<'- - - - - - ' - -

':"

.."

,

' :

-,<-- - , - - - ' - - - - - - , - - ' - ' - - , - - - - --...,-.- - - , -

'0..:.'

.

A~

I~'

.

'.

•

~

.,

Trairiii)g ~ri6r -to'OverseC)$; Deployment .Qr Ass,ignmenf
13: Dld.you .re<:eM~ any t(alnI09', ,llls.tructlon, 'ot :guldance .Spe-clffcali'l iii prep-aratl6n for ;:my:of yoUr
,overseas'd'epJCiy.ments o't,assignments?'
.

0No

ODo NotJ{ecall

14.. In' PJep'a!iltipn fQr atif~.fYQ,ur: Qv¢rseas·depI6y.mehts.pr~a$sjgnni¢nts, dId 'lou r.e.ceiv,e.any t@itiin9,
itlsfruetion, ,or .gUldance ,t6ncemin9 the sta'ridards,of co rlquct a,pp.licable' t6 the,tre.atm~rit,
interview;.. or interrogation of:detainees by, FBI personnel?

,Q'bo 'Not Recall

15, In, preparation f.6.r any: 6f:your overseas. deployments or ,assignments,-did you r,eceive:anY training, ,
instn.idi6ri, 'or ;~rurd.a'n<::e roncemiiig th'e',sta' naard S' of G0nd att' app Iica ole to the 'treathient~
fnterview t or interrogation'of'detainees by non-FBI personnel?

,

16', In- prej:mration for iinyof your "oVerseas deployments 'or assignmerit5 r".did, you receive anY".training,

itlstitiCtion, ·orguidaiice concerning what :y6u were supposed'to, db 'if yon observed of heard "aboUt
t~e' (reatf)1ent; "<i'1t~rv ie\'-{, qr' !nter[oga,tion, oT ,deta..ihees I:Jy f~l ,persot'!n~ f )Nh!c,l')' Y9~ ,beli~ved 'to
b,~ inappror>riateJ, u'l}lm~fe!?si6r:1al, cQ~rGiv,e; ,aQLt$i\r¢; or ,unlawfu.l?

OIGQ-005060

OYes

eNo

.000 r:4ot rtecaH

17', In, preparation for any of your overseas; deploymentS or asslgnmehtsrd Id .you receive any tralnlhg,
instruction, or guidance concerning what 'you were: supposecf'to: do if you obser:ved ,or heard about"
~~e t"1atm!-'lnt, 'i'1tervlew, or interrogC)tion~ofdetainees by n.on-FBI ~rsonne.l, Wh1c,h you pelieved.
to b¢. inappropriate~ unprofessipual7 toerGive, aQusiye,. PI' unlaWful?

0N.o

ODd

Not Ret.all

B•. Training, DiJring Overseas D'epl6ymel1ts or-AsSignments
18. Q\.!r.ing~ny -or yoqr oyer~eas'g~plQyrn~nts0.1' assJg nment!!; I:I j~ YQ!-I: ret~iV~ any'~r:qjning~ in~nfc~iqni'
QY,g!JIQ~nCe ,c.Qn~~rnin'g the s.tand~rds, qf cond'uq: pppflqable tP. the'tr$tment, l~~ervi~, (;if
ihterrogatkin 'of detainees by FBI personnel?

byes

:00'0 Not Recall

ON6

l~t Dudng any .of YQLlr Qverseas:deplpsments PI' assignment?i pid YP.u re~eive ant't@iriing, instru:ction,
6r-.guidantEr~on¢erhiogthe·.s,taIid·a(ds bn:qndllct .ap'j>Ii~able t.o. the.·trea'trilent, ii1terv'~ewi. 0:(
interrogation ·of deta"inees by: non-FBI personnel?

aDo NotREkall

·~.N'0

:ayes

b.t assig rimentS~ :d.iil you rec!=iv~ any t!iining" i'nstr(1ctidri,
wliat;you.wer:e su.pposed to do jf you6J)SetVed or'heard .aboiJt th.e.
treaimentr interview,. or Interrogation 'of detainees by FBI personnelj which you belie.v.ed t8 be'
inpPP'r9pri~te,·unprof~~ign~~<;oerciye" ·~.i?49iJ~i, or urilC!wfu!7

20.. Dwririg "pny .pfyour ov,ersea's, ti¢Plp.YIi1~rits

·or g'uidance concernfr'rg

:21. During any 'ofyoUr 0v.erseas,deployments o'r assignments, did Vou receive a·hy,·t~amiilg, 'instruction,
orguldanc.e'concemIDg \'V,hat you wers sU"p.p'osed to
You :9fJServ,ed 91' hearQ '9I;Jout:the:
treaf)11~nti intervrew~ QrintC?rrg:gqti'on'Qf d.~tail1ee~
09,n+FBI,personnel, v.(hlfh YP\l Qelieyedto
Q:~ in;:lpproj>rlate, unpn:l.feSSlonaJ,coerclve/ ab.\Jslve, or IJnfaWful?

ol)'Jr

by

':23'1' woo PrOvided

'tbr

Q No, 0 ' 0 6 NQr R¢·¢aii.

'0:y¢s

training" instruCtion!.' ot',gU'i,dan,ce?

b6
'b7C

2ib. Briefly describe the substam;:e'of'the trairiing, instruction, or Quidance. provided to: you.
D'urjii!'i 1:1 weekly, m.eetingof FBI. per-sarine', we were told front that :dcite for,wa'r;d to.
document in writing anything we witnessed regarding, detainees, interviews which we:
qeemed npt.to be,tn a:cC;:9rdpn~e'wiJ:h FBI prqcedqres;
2:ic. Was:any 'Of the·trainin"9t instruction".or .Qui~ance provid'ed in' writing?'
aYe's,

01'!Q

:Q

DO

Not 'Re~afi

lc:~ Adequacy. of Training

OIGQ-OOS061

"

,

22. In your opinion,.did you receive adequate training, instr'uction, or gUidance relating to' standards
'Of ionduct by FBI ang nOI1-FBI per>s:onnei relating jo treatm~,ni:,'intervie\A(ror Inteuog ation 'of
.detainees pribr to your gepl9yment\:>t assig.nment?

o Yes
"

•

_

~

~

_

<.

~

_

.'

__

.~

_ '_.

.......

p

•

_

...

__

•

__ :.

_

-,

........

_

0,No
••

~

__

-.

_

,;.

_

"

_'> _

...

•

......

; .........

'4

''-

..

""

....

,..

1-

_

~

..

_

..

_

~

.22a. Please describe the'ways in whiGh you believe the trainin,g; instruction ar,guidanlZe was
'.
,
inadequate:
I wOl.,flc! hav~ Iik~ to hElve more informa~1911 regC!rd ing t,he star:tdar9 of C9nQuct,of militpry
~ J~~~IJ~1!a~ip~~,

~

_,

'_ ~

'

,

~

.

,_,_ ,,

.

;2:$.. 1n yqur Qpinl{;m, d)d Y9U r~e)ve ,ac;!~gU~te ~r~irll)gf i;nsl:rl!¢ti9n,.-orguiqil'nce r~la~lng to:st?nd~Mi>,
of ~pn'du~ by FBI ,Cind' ndn"":FB~ ,per$.{:mn-el rei 9:t'fn,g /:.q ~rea'~rnent, irit\=r:view, '()J int;E!rro\;J,~tJon of
,det'airiees-,ddring ybur deploynienbor'assl.9,m:rie'nt?

9

'-

-

(!{ 1':19
2~~: RI~is~d~ri~~,the-:~iij;; 'W'bich -y~o -b~iiex~ }h; 'tr~hling: j~;~~~~ion ~(:~,~i~~;c;:~ -Wq~ --- -- ~ ~ - .
1·1}a-,d~q.uate:

Yes

,above

Same

a's.nel,
._. __...... _-.answer
._-_",
_'
._'_ - """ __';.";:"_ .... ,.. -..'"_,_:., __ ....

.,..

';.~"",,

,

...t-._-_ _ --_',__

.~

"""._

- _,... __

.~

2,4.10 YOlJr 6piriiQri, did: Y9.lJ l'ec:eIY¢ ·ad¢.qlJa.te, trairiifi9r i'nstructiQrlr, or.g.uldante!:Qncern,ing wh 91 V.P\1. :
were sii'pPQsed to:,do ifYo,u observed of tfeard' about·the treatrileirit;. iriteEVie.W,,6r jnteitogati6n Of :
detaineesi by 'FBI :or non-'FBI personneli.' that y.ou 'believed was inappropriat~; unprofessional,
:
'co~rcrv~, :ctl;ll;l.~rV~{, ()f unl,axvfuI?

€I'Yes

() No

;2~.(Option~l),If! wh~tt ways ,qm the F~~ ;imp'rove:~raining on'thls subje¢t 'for flJt~:r.~ p~p,fQyment:s"o('
?as~lgnrneti.t!>~

,

2.6. Please 'provide any additional'informafioh'coricerriing -training for ,ovetseas d,~pJo¥meritsor
a$!iign[Tlents
FBI. R~rsl?nnel Y04 ~eli~ve j.~ r~~~'1?fl!'

of

Introduction to Part,III: In' this'section~we'are,seeklng,i nformation regarding" -a wide range,of
,in,ter:v[eV'J pr interrqgati,on'lec::!Jniques and otlJer types of detainee t[eatm.,ent all~g~ to, have occurred,
Y'qu ~l:idJJlQ n.Q~ 9~S(Jrn~, JIJ§tb~(Jse
al~:a?~irig a.J:!'Ql!t q P~r11c,uli;)r .tegl:lI:dql!~,br: Rl'?lqi.t:~, tjli;l~·W~:h.crl(,e
'<;o.n~"ud etI, that Jr in fa,c~ 9:c.t:Ur(e,f, W.e rec;6,gniz~ ~har ~me: !:if th~s,e 'technJqu~$.or pra'ctlt,!=S may' ell tllTles
be necessary for' safety and s~ur.ity in a .detention settTng'. In -addition,: we recog,njze ,that some of these
technIques 'or ,practices. may have been au'thor[zed for USB by military' or qther government personnel,

we.

With re~p:eo: t9' ~f;h 'id~n~in~d, tethliJqu,e, 'pr:ac:tite, ,o't·tYR.~-Rf c.Qhd.ucJ'd~ciip~d b'e1oW" we 'are seeking
iJito'miation 'aobut its ,occurrence durinG oJ-'in ,connectie:m' with"the interView' or iriter,to9.'ation (jf'a

OIGQ-005062

~etaineei or.during, th~ dete'.l.tiQfI.of a

·In :tha~cpnt~xtt
1.

w.~

Will

q~k you tq t~I.1

detain'ee ,beyond what .is

ne~de~

.for safety and sec;:urity.

us wh~ther ·()n~ qr m~re ofthe. f9lfo\l'!ing $.tatelT1eht.s ;C!r~ true:

I;.'p~r.S~hally .QB~r.v.M this :c;oll.du.c~,

2, !.observed :detciinee(s) ih a .condition thcitlea me to believe that ·ftiisconduct. had .occurred.

3. D~tain~(s) told rne'that thiS. conduq: had 'oc~urred.
4. Others whp' J:il:!~e:rv~cj '!his conqy!=t d~cri~e~ 1t ~ci' rn~.
5. I..have releyan~ inf6i-m'atlQn !=.I~5.sified a'Qoye·":.SE8Rcro ·,
6; I neve....bbsetved this:conduet nor heard abd.ut.lt ffo'in.someone.. WhO did.

0 l' perS;i5n:ally oA~lYed this'co.nduct.
11. 0 I ob~~ed·.detaii1ee(s)~ in. ,a :cohd'itibn that ied ,me to

.a:.

C~

d.
e.

o petairie~ts.) told .me th:at this'ccinduCt had :od::urrea.
0

beli~ve tbat this cbh~litt hati ·,occutt~tl.

Others: who ob.served this cond uet d:e'scribed ·it.to me.

Cr II naVe relevant information dassified i:lboVe I£SECREr' .

f. ~ l' neveh:)bserved this :conduct np('heariLabtllif It from someone'who did.

:2'8.
a~

b,.
c:
d.
e~

Deprivh')g a detainee, of'clothjll9
\...

"-

0 'I per.soIi~:dly'dDseht~9this..cdn,dW!=t.
0 I'o.b$¢t:Y.ed.:detail)~e(sJ in..:a:c.9ridjJ:ibn that !~d ,m~ tp b~lieve that.thi~ <;6'n:dupt h~d .OJ::Clrrr.~.
0 D~tainee(-5) told me tl'iat this cohduct had ~6tcurr~.
0 Others' who obserVed lbis' tond Qct described it tb me.
0 l have relevant Information .c1assified al).oVe '!SECRET"'.

f. ~

r ilevero.b5erved this-conduct hor:heard 'a be lit it ·from someone who did.

. 29. D"epriving·a
detainee; ofsleel?r
.
. , or int;errupting Sleep' bY,. freq.uellt
a.

b,.

c.
d.
e.

f.

cell.

r~[ocations Qroth~r m~thods

0' !I p'e;r~ndHy Qhserve.d' this ¢on~lf.ct.

o !rob-served tfetcii'nee(s) ih ;a'cond iUan that led me, to believe. that this conduct 1ia~ occurred.
o !Defaihee(s) told me that this: c(md.lict had :ocGurred.

o [Others., who bbser.ved this tonciuct,deS9rlb.ed It to: rt'1¢..
o '11 have .relevant Informatioo Classified aDolle, "SEeREf."·.

011 never-obserVed'thls conduct'nor heard 'aboUt it from soineone"who did.

OIGQ-005063

'30. Beating a detiHnee

a, 0 L per,senally observe(j tbis 'cqnduct.

0
c. D

b;

q.

r'obs~{'?ed d.~tqin'eet$)
D~tainee(s) tol~

in oa'CQh.d ~jQn. thqt leel me to

b~ney~ thqt. this <;:orrduQ: b~d ,o'Gcurre~.,

me that this cQndu~t hap o'ccarred.

o lothers' who bbsefY:eP this, !=:on~uctd~~crjb'ed

it to' me"

e. 0 l' ha\l'e relevant, ltiformatib h' tlas~ifi~ above, uS~CRET·'.
f.

0'

I n'ever ob~~rv,e9 tli1s:co,nduGt ripr :h~ r~ ~abol!,t it fr:.6m ~me9ne, Who did.

31. ,UsingWatet'to pjevent breathing by- a

detajj'r~e>,o(to

create .the sen satiQii of'tlrowning

,a. 0 I p~~~rqlly' o~bserv~d' V~IS ·conciuct.
~'; 0 I~~~erv~q detg'ilJ~e~s} it::! ,(:rC'ph~jjti(Jtnhat I~, me i9 ~~lieve th?tthis conpuc~ hac! 'C:!6I;urrep.,
'Getp.inet=(s) tQJ~ '[D,e thCjt this, cph<ju,c~ had -oe;:.curr~.
G·,
(f. 0 OthefS' Wbp 9bse!y~d -thi!:? G.ona u<;~ dJ~s'crib~d jt t<;> rn¢.
~', D. ': h?tye relevant il).fbrm!3.ticm :classified ;;il;Joye: l~s:'Ec,R.E1n,.

o

~ 0 r ii~y.¢r'QfjserYed, this:;'co.nauc.t.J'for heard ~abp.ut it fr<im 'wrrreone'Whq dJQ.

32. ,U,sln'g
a,.

'ropel ,or;anythll1gelse ,to' choke or strangle a ;detalii.~e

.

r perS('jnal{y' observed' (his 'c<?nduc;t~
o II obse.rved, 'detqrnee(s) In·a "cond'lll<;ln' that led me to' bel!eve ~hat ',~his conduct had 'occllrred.
0

b;
c 0
d. 0
e'.

h~lt:'ldS'r

q

Eh;t~i.n~(s' tQJd ,rn~ t,h?t .tl:lis: cond ucr f:1ac) 'OCl;:4rre<;!;
Qt~ers. w,ho oQ$er;veq ,tills c,onguGhd,~$~rjl,1eg

tt to' m~:

[haVe r~levant informatlpil ~lassifleQ' 'a.bP~e ·\S.'i:CgET"'.

f. 0 i never op,served' this conduct'npr h~r:.d a bbOt: it from sQrtlepne.

'33. Thr:e~t~jiin9 oth,er. a:dibri to ~ause phXSitai pain,. injUry,. d isli9ur<em~

FJoIr per.sonally observed this,condud.

-

OIGQ-005064

..
·,
.. .'
0 I observed detalnee(s) In acond Itlon that led me to, believe that this conduct
c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occurred.
d. 0 q~her5 who observed this conduct descril~ed it to m~
,e;. 0 I hcWt= relevant Information tlassified pbove.ll,SECREf".
b,

f.

0

~ad

'occurred.

I n,~v,er'o,bs~rve,d this conduct J:lor hear,d 'abQut it from sgmeol1e:whp d.ld,.

3fI.o~h'er treatm~nt

l)t

,death

aqibn G3Using,s,ignifiGant physical pain or ilJjury" pr ca~rsiiig disfigurement or

0 r p'ersonal.ly observed this conduct.
,b; 0 riol;Jse.rye~ qetqil)~~(s) II) a ~lZQ,nd ition thi;lt led rt)e, to' bel ieV'~ tha.U~js
~. 0 Detain~(s') lqJd rn~ ~\1at this (;:c;)lJc!ljC,t bad Qc,c,(frr~ ..
d,: 0 t;)ther$' who observeq 'this to'lJQLiCt'd~scrib.e,9 I~ to me',
e; 0 r h!3~@ releyant information' !=lds~lfi€!.d ~b9ve: l~s.!:tREr'·.
a:

can.duet' had occurred~,

t: 0' I n:ever Qbs.erved th!s:.conduct nor he?lJ:d :i;1p:oul it frQm'sQme~n~,whp, dJct.

a;

p

[ personallY' observed this conduct.

~.

0

r;'observed 'detaine~( s) 1I:1.a..~~md ition that '~d me' to' believe thi;lt t"tJis c:;oOd4Gt /;l,ad 'oGcurrec;i.

c. 0 betainee(s) told /TIe t~Cjt :this C;;ODpuc,t had 'Q,l::curr.ed.
~, 0 Other$' \!Vh'b ob~rv~c! 'this rrqnduct Q.~$.~ri.bed it to, m~:

e.
f.

o .1 ha\!e r~le~an~ InformqFlpn"j:;I~ssifl~~ al?'o~e "~,EC~ET".
0' II' never o.bserved' ttib tbndu¢t nor heard '~bbuf ft frpln,$o.rrieone ·woo. qid.

36. Using sh~ckle's ot'6.ther·restr~lil'its ina ~r'0[o'ng",",·~_d..;.m..;.a...;"n..;.;.n.;.,.e
....j'

0
b', 0
~. 0
d, 0
·e.. 0
..

L personally observed this,conduct.

a.

_.".

~¥

_

~ o!J~~rve<;l'd~ta'l.ne~(sJ In:<,l.c9I)djtion t~at·I~~

m,e t9 believe tr~t:this' cOl1du~t· h,qd '9Q';,I,med:

thatthis
conduct
Detalnee(s) ~~Id me
, '" .'
'". '" '"
.... had
". ,occurred..
•Ot.hern. whp ol:>~erved :this condl1c,t;described i~ to me.
"

I havEi! -relevant inf<;>rm<:ltIQ'n c1assifi,ed !=lpoVe, "$ECREf'I.
•

"

...

....

..

... ...

.""

... , -.

..

~

'"

".v.

•

W~

' ••

_ ••

., ..

...

."

'"

.,

~"

...

,

.

.. .......

OIGQ-005065

[I Itl' II never Ob~rv~d this conduct ~or heard abo~t It f~m '~~~eone who did.
:3t. .R~tJl!iri,ng',a det~ineet9mainta:in~ or restrpining

detainee in, a ,stre~?fl)1 or p,alnful P9sition

<;l

a. 0 I personally bbse'riletl this condu'cr.
b. 0 I <>bs'¢T\t:¢d, detainee(s), in a cond ition th~t led me'to belie.ve tbat this conduct' had ,oc¢urred.
d.

0
0

e.

0- r haVe relevant information classified abo:ve "SECREf'l.

f:

Itt

G.

D~tai neg{s)tord

m.e that this cohd uct had ,o,ccurred.

Others' whb .ohsehled thiS conduct described iUo me.

'.

I, never observed' this ~Gond uct nor heard ab,Qut it from someone who did.

:3ft Ford,ng a det9inee to'perform de,rna,nd fng physicql'ex~rcise

a. 0 I' p:e:rS0nally':O:b~rved~his,:c,Qnclu~t.
Q. 0 II obS¢rv.ed, tletaine.e(sJ in ~a~condition that led me: to. bel k~ve thatthi~ cd'n'duct had ,o'c,curre'cL
D'etainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.
<:~ 0
d. 0 OtherS' Wh:P observed tbls' tOnd'uct deSCribed It to' me.
,e. 0 r have 'releyarit inmri'natiOn c1assifiea ~60Y.e "SECREf".
'f. 0 I 'i1evefo.bserved" this 'conduct nor heardatiout it ftom,some6ne wh6 did,

0
'b. 0
c'. 0
d. 0
a.

Detaib~e(s) told me th~t thiS: c,ondLict had 'o,ccurted.
pther's' who ;obseWel::llhis c6i1d'Li.ct,d'esCtiD~ it to'me.

.
Information tlasslfied 'aboye ':SECRET:'.
a I ha\le relev.ant
,

4(t Th.reatening to

_

........ _ _

~

_

..............................

~

............................. _ _ . . . . . _ _ . _ ; _ _ _ _ _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . _

_

_

.

-

-

,

,

"

~

.,

.

I neVer observed' this:l3Ondikt nor heard 'about it from someone:iivho did,
~

0"

-"".

.

~

f.
"-.-'

I' observ:edd~talnee.('g)' In 'a 'CO rid itl'on that I.e'd me' to b~Uev.e that,thls ton:duct had occurred,

_

~

t p~r:sPnaliy' 6bserve:ci' ~f1is t:6r'io,uct,

.... _

.....

_ " ' ....

44._

•• "' ................ _ ._ _ _ _ _ _

.... __...

""' ..... "' ..............

use;eJe~rical shock-Pll a detainee,

OIGQ-005066

,

.. -

...

,.,.

"

..

.

,

..

,.

a'. 0 I personally observed this.,conduct.
b.

0

I.observed detainee(s} in a'concl ition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred'.

,c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that t~i~ condl,lct

~ad '9q::urr~L

d.

q

e.

,0 IL have reievant iOTormation dassifi~d ,apave. "SECJ~ETI/·.

bthel? who 'ob$erv~d thi~ c9ndQ<;:t.«;I'~sqibed It to me:

r: 10 lrn~yer ~b.served

thi~ ,tqnpq~t nor heard ·ab.Qut· it from 'some~>ne whp ~id.

41, Intentlonally',delaYIn.g ,or denying detainee: medl~al care

c::..

0
0
0

e..

0 I. h~ve;relr;va:rit

't,

~ I n!=ver Qb~.erv.e:~ this l~o.nd uGt ,n~r hea rd pbQut it from-:$'qrn~9n~'Whb did.

a'.

0

~ perSonaHy.observed tHis eotidud.

b,

0

!·observed detainee(s) in a'condi[ion.that led me to believe thatthis Gonduct had'Dccurred.

a;
b,

L personally observed thiS ·conduct.
I 'observed 'detalnee(s): Ina C0nditton that led me to belle-ve that this oonduct. had :ocl::urred.

'Det~i!1ee(sj.~qld

ll1e that t/1is conduct hpd :(jc~urJed)
<1: o ,a\her:p wh!> opse[v~~ t,nlS c0nduqt d~~cr{ped It to JTIe:;
!nf<;>.rm~tI9n ~las~Jfl~ ~bQve II,SECRET"~

e'.

o petainee(s) told me that this conduct had ,occurr.ed.
o !Others who o~serve,d tnis candu~td.esci1be.9 it to me.,
o II. h~ve relevant jnform?ti(~>n c1asSi!ieg above ·\S~f:q~ET".

t:

0

c,
d,.

-

I

~, neverqqs,e[v~d this 'cQnpupt 'nor .he;:lrp'c;,l,bQut. it ;frQJTlsomeqn-e w.ho dJd,.

a. o II personally observed this:cotlduct.
b. o iI ,obset¥ed delainee{s) in .a·.conaitior1'that led me f6, believeJhat"tlifs conduct. had ")cc.urrea.
c. 0' !Detainee(s.) told me that this conduct had :occurred.
do'
~.

o Ib~het:5 who :obserye,d 't~is ~~I')dllc;t ge~cr.ib~ !t to m.e.
o II bav~ rel,evaht
IlJfQrmGltion c1assifieq a~o\i'~ '!s'/=:CRET'\
..
.

OIGQ-005067

f.

l~r

I never observed this conduct nor heard aboutlt from 'sor:neone who did.

-44. Subjecting a d~tainee;tQ loud mU5jlc

Ii'l per.soifal!y ci:bsefrved this Conduct.
0 I obse:t:v.ed .deJalne.e:Ui). ib a .cooo itlbn th;;it led me: t9 o~lie.ve that this con~uct had :occurred.
0 D¢tain~{s) told :me' that this'cohduct tia'd ·o.ccurre:l.
I
d. 0 otherS: who obseHted this cencI-ad describe(f It to me.
e. 0 I have relevaht Information dassified aboVe "SECRET".
I: 0 I. never observed thls:ronduct nor·heard aoout ft· trom someone' who did.
a.
D.
c.

. g.. P!ea~ prov.k:l,e the approximi=ltt; time ~rne:-d1,!.rrng.which 'hls:cql1d.t.Lct·OCCUH~.

From 98120(13. tp

DDP Not Re~ll

013/1003.

h~~e·detai!1E!eIs1. ~Mte9 to thjs way:.~ere !(jca~e9 ~t.t~e. t!!TIe !!l.:
llU;GiJantanamo
.
.

Z0 Ira.q
3 0 .Af~haiJ'istah
4 0 Other LocatIOn

sO Do Not Recall
. i. Pleaselctentif)rthe de.~ainf:fe:(:»
Ldo OO,t know..

b.Y· barhe ;:frld hlllTitigr:

j. .RJ~se l«entlty· the. R~?OIJ'(s)WhQ ~~eated ~he:qe~i!1.e.~(s)

In :t~Is-lJ1an~r-? Illcl:U_~ln.Q ~h~r

narhe.'(s:) and .g"Overnhlent.ag¢ncyne!il:
.
.
I dQ riJt knoW.
k· Please i~E!ntify any:~ther F,eJ p~r's9hn.el pr n9h~FBI pers!;lnne"l ;w.ho. o.b~l\I.ed. ·Q.et.alnee{s1lt~j:~

. Jil'ttlls rhm;lieri.lfjcrud.ih~.tli.el'r oame(s) and

~gency"(res);

~
I~·
I'. Thjs'eOI)9Ud; .~urred in eoQOI;c;\:ion w.iUl:
~ '0 One de~ainee
.
2:0 ~.•raJ deiainees r2'4J

'3 0
4 <0

.

b6

',e

Mar:wdetafn~.es.(m.bre·tlia"n 4]"
Do Ncit. Recall
.

m, toph~n~l} Plea,58 desc(H?e:the·~1~vant dr;cutT'istan'ces in morede1:9 11:

OIGQ-OOS068

4~. SObjt=d:ing a detalne~, to bright flashln9J!g.:.;ht.::'s;..:o::.;;r-:d:.:a:.:.;rk:.:;n.:..;e::.;;s.;;.s

_

0 1. p~rsdJ'lally obserVed this condud.
b. D L.b(jserved detarrtee(S) In a,condition that led m~ to, ,believe that this eolidu,ct had occurred.
c. D netainee(s) told me fhat this conduct had ,occurred.

a~

d.

--

~-"""'-~---

I

._._~_.~._---

[j Others. who observed this G0nductdescribed it to me.

D Lha)Je relevant Information classified abov.e !'SECRET'l,
thls~condud
nor
'from'someone:who
did.
f. D I never'observ~d
.
..
.heard
. .'about
. ,it.
. -, . .

e;

,;'

.'

',g. Ple~se' prqvid,e th~ ~pprp}{lr:nate t'jme fr~me £luring, ~hiG,h t!li& 'c6ndu~t 'o~c~rreq.
From O&f20Q3

t,o QS}20Q3

DOo Not ReGelIl

1:1, T~~, detain~e(~) tr~t~d In '~hi~ W~'if w~r~ Iqc;<;'!t~ ,?It 'the tim~ iT) i

i 0' GU<;lnt;;lnamo

? D:I@~:r
3 D .P,.fgflanista'J1
,~ 0 Otlier Location
50 Do Not Recall

i. Pleas¢:identifY the,~detaiJi,ee(s) by name arid n.umb~r:
, I.-do n0t knoW
'

;j. PJ¢a~e'ld~ntifY th'e-I5.er.sQnts) 'WhQ Jr~ated- ~he

d,et~irt~e(~) in thi~ rDcH:me(, iocllidjng their

'!icIlTle(s) ~tid ~e\lemrtrentagehcY(ies):~
Cdo 1J0,t Know
,
1<. P:I~ase id~iitif.Y any :9thel- Fal pe'tsonnel or nori:'FBI p¢tsonnei ~wh:O' bQ:ser-Ved detarri!i!~,'S) tr:eated
in tHis: rf1~fnher." iricludift~ their name(s) and ~g~ncy~k:is)~

-b6

SAl
I FBI
r. Thi~;CP!1dUci pG~~me,~ In' conn,er::tip:n VV.ltl1:
1:0 bfi~:d¢t?Jil1e~
2, '0 :S~veral a¢,t:ain:~s (,2-4;)
S Q Many d,etainees ,(more thElJ1 4:1
.4 0, OQ Not ReCall

b7C

rh. (Qj:JtiOrial~ pieq~ destrib.~, the relevant cir.cmniStaht;es in more'detai'l;

46. lsolSltjng ~ detal.ne~ fOf an'~xtended ,p~rlqd

I,

OIGQ-OOS069

..

--

o

b.
~r observed detalnee(s) In a cond itlon that led me to believe thatthls conduct had occurred.
c. D IDetainee(s) told me 'that this condu'ct had ·occurred.
Others whQ observed this co~duct descriqed it to me.

0

d.

e;. D I hpv~ reJ~'iant i.nformatlon c1assifi~d a.bov~ "SE~RET·'.
t 0" l n~v.er o6serv¢.c1 this 'conduct :nQr hear.d 'abqu.tinrom ,~om~one'who did .

lJ$i:n~ 'duct tap!=!' to r~5tralii'{ ·:g~.",-I_o_r....
pu.....n_i_sh~a-"p;,..;e;,..;ta",,"jn..;;.e_e

.47.

-,--

_

.

D I.personally observed this condlid.
b.· 0 I.:observed detainee(s} in a'condition that led -me to' believe that this conduct had :occurred.
c: D. Detalnee(s:) told me thatthls C0nduct had m::curred.
a.

o PtherswhQ obseryed 'Ws conc!uctpescribed it t~ me;·

'ej,

D I. ha.".~ ,relevant. fntormat!9 0' c1a~~ifJ~g a~9.v~ "S.l;C~"·.
¥: 0 i nrayer'Qb.~~rv.e:d t,h($:C9!1cfuqt nQr·.h~r.d ·a!?Q4J' I~ .fr9m.~meon~

e;

D
b. 0

·a.

who dld,.

I p.erSbnally.observed this.conduCt.

LobserVed aetainee(s} in .a'cond'itfon that led

me to'Delieve tnat·this eonduct had ·0ecurretl.

c,·

o petainee(s) told me that this conduct had :o'Ccurr.ed.,

d.

rtf ib.thers who observed this conduct·descrlbed

it to me:

D. II hav.e refevant jnform~tion c1 qssifi.eg 9.bQve' "S'EGR8J ....
f. D l~ never ~pserv~(tthlscop~!-:l~tnpr h~rd :~~Pl:'t it {rom someoqE2 wJ'!o qid.

e•.

< []':.

.

Please prQvide the approxiniate tIme frame:durl'tig ."Yh1c;h tl1fs'~(j'ri~oct :oq:;.urrect.
08/2003:.
000 Not Retail

Frbm ,08(200'3 to:

h..,Tpe QetainE?e'(~) ~r:eate9 in thi,s W,ClY w~r¢. Iqtafeg at the tithe In:

i 0' Gua.nt~namQ

.:a 0
:3 0
-4

~

0
0

.

lra"q
Af9nanistaii
Other Location
Dal'!ot Recall

i. Ph~as~:identify the'oetainee(s)

by ,name and

number·:

OIGQ-005070

I do not know

J. P'Iease.lqentlfy the. person(s) wh9 treated the de~lnee(s) In this ma,nner, inc!odlng their

nam~ts) a,nq goYernm~ntagenGy(ies),:
,.
LddhQt know
k.. Please i<fe,ntify any otber FEU personnel or Gpn-fel personn~1 Who Q.bserve~ detainee(s) Vc;ated
in -this, manner" ir:icludin'g their hame{s) and, ,agency (ies) ~
r~Q n<;>t rec~lr'
". '

I. This 'con~oct occurred in ,Colmectjon with:
i 0 One detainee
2: :Q '$everal d~tain.ees (~-4)
~ -0 Mi;lnY :d etainees {m'pre. ~han' 4}
4 @ D,D Not Re-cail

Tlrere; was: general ,knowled,ge-tt)a.t ~m Emergency Respcose forGe (tIexl-sted to'Gpotrol (fet.Cjinees'
.Wh9' w~i:~ ri9ting gr 'geql@ QU~ of ~9r\trbl. po M.t: have :~flY inf<i}rhia.tIQn· ~,s ,to how pften thi~
'team Was, used .or oriWhat detaihees.
'

.r

49. uSing. a' military wo:rki.ng,:Clog 66 .oJ near: a tf¢tainee Qther tha.n :dilrihg d¢tiilnee:tr.anspor,tation
a~

o

r

personally·.o.bserved thlscondlkt.

'

lb. o J,obserVed 'detainee(s} in a,eona ition that led me'to believe thatthis cond'utt heW ,ocdfrred.1
c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that this cond,,!ct had .occurred.
d., 0 Others who observed this conduct described It to me,
e. 0 I hC)ve,r~levpnt jnform?ltlon cJpssified above "SECRET'''.

'f: 0. I, n~ver Q~Qs~rveg, t~is c9l1qu~Lnor heard a~qlJ~ it from.$Q[T1e\>l1~wh.odid,.• '

50. l:h(eaiel)ing to use.mllltqry· ~9.rking dpgs,o.n .q'r'Jl!=~r

a. 0
b. 0
c. 0
d, 0
e'. 0,
f,

a peta.ilJ.ee

l per.sd'naJly·6bsei:¥.ed this .colldiict.

I observed detaihee~s} in a,conoiti0h'fhat led

me te. believe that.'this conduct had occurred.

Detainee(s) told me that this,conduct had 'occurred~
others. who observed .this condblct d'escri'bed it to me.

r. !1av,e r~levant InforlT1at!on: c1.asslfje,c;l ~p~>v~ "SECRET"'.

8 I never observed' thi?'-C9lJouct nor heard ab.out i.t from sQm~one who- q!d.

OIGQ~005071

a. 0 I personally observed. this.conduct.
b.

n

c- O

d.

r.obseiVed detalnee(s} In a .cond iHon that led ine. to, believe thanhls conduct had' occurred.

.

D"E~tainee(s)told me that this conduct had ·O"ccur'red.

o IOthers who observed this cond,uct d'escribed it to me.

D r: hav.~ relevan.t Inform~tlqn, classiffeq ·a ~ove ..-SECRET'.. ,.
f, ri:I. l.nevero.bserved this conduct norheard 'about it from someone who did.

e.,

),'

~,

."

.-".

'""

",

." •

.,',

•

<.

•

"

",

-'.,

"

.52._ ThteC)ten'ing ~o ~se 'spid.er$, ~c,orpions/-,sl)a~es, pr other animals on:;;1 c1~taine~
'a.

0

I personalltooseWed this:conduct.

b. 0 I-:observed detainee(s) iii a'condition that led me to,belieye that this cond.tict had .occurred.
c,

o IDetaihee(s)'told me that this conduct h-8d ,occurred'.

d.

G

'e.

0 r. "'qV~ releyant. illfo.f!ll~t!on, clq~'~ifie~qbov~ "SECRET"',

!--

Others who observed this conduct descrfbed it to me.

r. 0: it J.1ever o·bservE?c1 tills ·condlJc~ nor ,h~~d.abo~tIt frO!TI"soD1e9rt~w~o did.

5.3: Dis.r.espectful'statements, handling, Qr:aC1:ions lnvolving th~',~o'ran

Ia.,
b,

o II personal.ly-'obsehled this 'con·duct.
o t~obserVect, detciiriee(s} irlEl conditil!>h that led me to, believe' that this co'h:duct had ·Qc:curreO.
to'etaihee(s)'told m-e that this condiJCt had ,occurrecl',

c.

-D

Id.

d

e..
f,

:Others who 'observed .thls'conduct'descrlbed It to me.

o II. have relevant information c1asslfied' above I!SEtRET".
~ ¥' rev~r'oQs~rv~d thi~ lC9ndl.J~t n9r h~r.d Cl,bo,l,It; it 'from. S9rne<me' who,d id,

,54. $h<;iving a detaj'ne~·s. fC;lcial Qr other hqjrtq !=ITlbarrCj?S'or humiliate: a deti3,inee'

·a.
b.

D II. personally observ.l=o this ';CohClu¢t.
o It observed detilinee(s) h'la cone! itkin that led roe to

believe thafthis conauct haaoGturr.ed.
-

OIGQ-005072

..

c.
d.

.-.-

,

.

o IDetalnee(s) told me that thiS' conduct had 'occurred.
o lOt hers who observed this conduct described it to me;

r

0
t 0

e.

~~v.e relevant infQrmCltion c1assifieg q~ove lI:~ECREP".

I nev~r obs~rve:d ttlls,:COI1Qupt,nor heard?bpul it from',sqmebne:Who. did.

55. P!?li::irt9, q woman's c!pthing qn:a ,detCjinee,

e,

0
0
0
D
o

.1 ~av,e relevant inforrn~tiQn, c1assff[~ above: "sEdRET"~.

f.

0

r.f!~v.:~ro:l?~el\le<! tpfs.,<;ondl,lct nor n~rd.'about-it fF9m SGme0!1~ W~9 cji9.

a.

b'.
co
d.

a. 0
b. 0
c.
,d.,
.e.,

f.

I perSd'nal1y obset'v.ed this ,condiJCt.

Lobserved d~ta'jne.e(s) in a eond itio.11 that led me to believe thafthis conduct had ,occurred.
Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had ,occurred.
Others who obsel1led -this conduct-described It to me..

L personally ob'served this :C'o{idu,ct.

I.:obserVed cleta'i'nee(s) in -a.condition that led

'me: to, tielieve thatthis Gonducl: had .occurred.

o lD'etainee(s}fold me that ,this cond'ud had ,occurred'.
d

others; who observed this conduct describea it to, me.

o h, have rele.vant informatfon classified above "SECRET",.
o ii. never,qbserved thts"co(lduct nor heqrd '~b0Ut it 'from- sorneon~:who, eltd.

5-;7, J!9lding .de~ain~(s:> Whq w~re npt (l'ffJ,c,laIlY :ac~nowlegge~t Qf r!?glstereg ~rs such by -t,he;ag,enty
d¢t-alning th¢', person.
'

I

a. 0' !r perSonally obsehf.ed this conduct.

b. 0, Lobserved detainee(s) ,in 'a condition that led me to belieye that this conduct had ,occurred.
c. 0 Det~I[I,eefs) tqld me that t~is c;:ond u,ct had ~<;:C;:~,l'reg ~

4: 0

O~~'e~' who {)trsery~ t~is cond'Uct'de$cribed

e- O

. 'f: 0

Ii have r~l~vatit informa1:i9'n .dassJfj~

It to,llJe.

pb'<;>ve "$ECRET\

I nev~r"op'~erv:~d thf?·'conputt nqr h~rq ~bOlit, it from. ~.i:1me~n~ Whp did •
".

.

~

... _.

.

._-

..

......... _ .. ..

"

"

,

"

........

.

..

... .

..

.

_.

--

-- .....

..

,

.

,

.

..

OIGQ-005073

,58. Seh'ding

a 'detainee to another coiJntry for rTlQre:aggressive int.errog'atiQr)

a', 0

:I.

b. 0
c. U

I:obs~~~ed d,e!~ln'eets) in a'cqndjl:ion tho~

d.
e.

personally ob~rvec:l this :cqnd'uq.

l,eQ :me to b~n~v.et!ia,t this conduq: had oGl:;urred.

De,talne~(sj tl)lp m~ that thi.s, cPlJdu~t hap :occorr~.-

o lathers' Who bbserveq 'this: conduct descrlbea It tO'me:.,
D- r: haVe relevartt Information' i:lassiffe:d above, "S~E,CRETI/.

f. 0

r- n:ever ob~¢rVe~f ~fji~. cqnduct npr h~r'd :a bt;ili.t: it fr!)in scime!)ne: Who' dJd.

5.9. Threatening to :send. a detainee to another country' fOr detention bnnote'a,g'g ressitre intern::iga-tion

D. it p.er~n~IY O,Qserveq t~is condU/;:t.
b"
.' 0 r~'o,l?servec!>det.<;lineet~) in ,0 'c::pnqitiqrr ~hat, led rne tr;>

a~

'c",

0,

D !Detajl1~,(s.) t91~ 'me thCjt t,t'ris t,onc;lUC~~

be.1jeve thquhl? condU!;;t naq 'QG<;t,.!rrel:!.

hq¢f 'o§cur~eo,

o ;Others: w.hp 'Qb!;ety~q this, GQnductd.escrl,b~d

it,tt:>: m~,

0, f h~,!~ rele'Vant, ii:lfor0J9Jlon ~laSsifjed :gl1ov~' I~S:E¢REro\'.
f. 0 r riey~r6j)ser-\!ed thi~L'c6.nduc.t fl,Qr h!=a'fd _ab~tut.lt from S<iITreone'whQ ~:Ijd..

¢'.

"60. Threatening' to take actlon,agcllnst,a d.etalnee's famHy

q.,

b',

:c.

4.
e',

o if personally'o,bserve,d ~his':condu~t.
o lr.ob$erved__de~qrQl?e{s} In 'C::l;'co:nd'ltI9n'that led rue to bel'!eve .tha~thls co.n:d,U.Ct' h;:ld occurred.
o iQeJ~i.n~(s' tqJd ,m~ trat this: col)duc.t bad oq:urred,
o !()tbers who op$erye:q ,this co.n~uGt des,cril:!e9 iJ t~t r;ne.
I

'0

II' haVe tef~valit IlJfbrmati9n: ~I!=l,ssifl.ed 'a bj:i\ie' ":-sEC'RET".

f. 0' it, n~\ier,q,b,ser\(ed'

fhiS'CQ/idut,t npr h$r,d '~bb_gtit from '-SQrrie9rt~ WheY d itt.

51. Oth~r t~e·atrh.ei)t or 8'Gtron Gauslng !;evefe-emoti6ha( or p.§y~ital ~r:aur'nij to adetaihee,

EI 0 II

personaHy o?served this.conduct.

OIGQ-005074

·,

b. 0 I'observed detainee(s) In a condition that led me to bellev.e that this conduct had 'occurred.

0
0
e:. 0
. f. 0
c.

d.,

'62.
a.

Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occurred.
O~hers who observed this co!,!.duct descriqed

it to me.

I haVe reJ~yant Information !=ia~sjfied Clbov~. "SECRET" ~

I n~v,er obs~rved thi~ 'cQng~Gt .nor hearp 'C\bqut it "from ~qmeone:whp did .

O.ther'r~ligjo.\.is,or:s~u.ai. harC!ssment Dr hum.iliatioil gf a d~talnee

0 r. personally 0bserved

this conduct.

h" [) L:observed detainee(s} in a'coRd ition that led me to' believe that this conduct had ;occurred:
C' D. IDetainee(s.) told me that this c0nduct had occurr.ed.

0 O~hers. who "Obsery~d t~i.s c:onducq:le~crjbeQ itto m.e;
eJ 0 I, n.a.y.~ .rel~vant' Ihforr.:n:a't!c>n' c1assifJe,g ~ 1?9v~, ·~S.ECllEJ'\
'f; 0 I n~~f'·qb,~,erlJ.e<! thl,s:copduc,t nq.r hear.'! \~b.9l!.t It f~orn;~rne'ql1~

~.

who did,

:'63,. 'O,ther tr:eath'ient or Jj' deta ine¢ .tna,t fh YOllr o"p'iriiorr W(:lS, uiip.r:pfe.s~.ional, jJntluly harsh or 'a'ggr.:es:siye/
~¢~Iy'e, ~,~Eslv:e.l <?r. ~[l,I~w.fl;lL __ ,._ .. .._.

a.

b.

.

._ .~_ ..._.,._,." __ ,~.~__,, _.,'"_ .'_,_..., <_ _ , ' .

,_,

,

o !1 personally observed' this condud. ,
o 11 oi;>served det,a.!n~\=($) In cH:::~mdition tha~ led 11)~, to' b,el.leve,~hatthi~ eondu.~ had 'Qccurre~.,

,0 !befainee(s)tqld 'foe tp:qt 'this: ~ond.uct hat;!' occurf~f.
.d.
'~the'r? WhD 'ob~ery~c:1 ~th(s. t:~n9uc:t d,e~~Jtbed. it to m~,.
e. 0 I ha\le re(eya!'l~ Infonna~lon ~Iqssifl~~ ':ql?'o~e "S\=CRETi".
f: 0' l neV,er qbseN~d thi? <;6n~u.et nor lij:Xln:l 'p~qut it fr'ptn..-$Qnieqnewnp giq,
c~,

o

,_m,::~~@)@liOOlijtl!j.M_,'::':··'f:-:'

-'

..

"11

'64. ,Did you, obs~·rv.e ahY. impe(sonation :of FBI personnel by'.anyone ,durjng ah interview di' .interrogation of
,a.aetainee'?,
, "

O'Ye~
"65. Did ~ny,detainee

0

No

o'r otherp,ersbil ,teW}tou that he or she had witnessed. the Jrripe.r.sonati6b
personnel :in connection with 'a detainee interview or interrogation?
.0, Yes b N'o.

of FBI

OIGQ-OOS075
,

'a:.

Please provIde the,approximate time frame during which this cond.uCt btcurre.d.
From 08/2003' to ,08/20'03
0 Do Not Itecall

b:. Th~ detain~e(s} treate,d In this 'Way Vl!e[e, locat~d 'at the time: iii:

1 &1 'Guantan?lnio:
2 0 Iraq

.

.3: 0 Afg'hi,lhrStan

'10 .OJher lOGation
:~.

0 0.0 Not Recall

,c; Please identify the detalneeCsl by name·and number to; the best of your reoo/lection:
I dg hbt kn:qW

'd. Please identifY the. person(s) whO'tr¢,ated the:d¢tairi.ee($) in ,thislJ'natm~rl i((duding, if yo-u
recall, their name(s)a'nd gO)lernment:age'ncYOes)::
! dO' not re<:911 .
.

'.e.

The, names ,of. any other FBI personnel, ,and the mimes and gOvernment agency. of non-FBI
p~rsOJ,me!i w/1om I b~lieye s?Jw the.<;l~tafnee(~). treated [n thls"'~~l)n.er are.: . . .
I'dp' not tecaU

"t Thls,:cQnduet pccurr~d in :~(mrieetlon .Wlth:
.1 0' :ohed~taInee,
Z 0 :SeVeral detainees GZ-4)

'3:0 Many detainees' {mor.e:than 4)
'4- ~ 0.0 N.qt ~ecall
ig.

(dptional) 'please,describe the [elevanLdrcumstan<:;es·ih more aetalJ:

Ou,d~g ,:q, Y"~~kN Ff3I me~ting'i ~Qrt!~.9n~'-sa!q th~Y' h~ar~ ~h~' rpiU~ary '~O!1t,~cWr;~ ~ere W~~J,ng
J~Qya.I Robbln.s pant? an~ telling de~a Inee$ they-were With. th~: FBI. ldo: n'Qt 'h~ve, a,ny·.sp'e¢Ifl.c
I9iAW.I~~fg,t;i <jf W,hq ;did' thts ,gr wt:!Q,liiig h~' Mv.e.:wi):.he~seq tnis.

<>j$: ,Are;YOlJ ~W~~ pf.~y "slfarp;" l;5f'JJ~lag~Q'1 .~~ta1riee\inteniiews-9f'inten:.Qgw:~p_ifs,c'Qildu3~f~!:lf<?r 14ew1:>:ets 'of
.t1:].eU~~~. Cqngre~ll 0r1helf s~:
.
QYes .~ No·
:6.7"; W·your kn't?wledge,.dt~ i:lny lJJilitary. o~ JI')~~lI!g,eIlG~ p~r?o.nn~.1 :~ve:r ~e!1Y: 9r' del?,lY FBI a.c~es? fO"g, ..

:de~ii':i'ee.the F~I w.ailt~~ t9:ql,lES,tii;>rl' Jje.c~u~e:ttie,de@ine~ had 'sus.tairied, injuri~s after he jiva~. cap;tur~l;1?

Oy~~,

0Nq

.

•'~lI."P'-\fk.~~~~'_~~~,~·:,::',": :"'<'.:':-.:
~
··i~t.~~~~·@lF. .. ::.~,::~,~·,/·
!lg, ~',~i m~
~<~,:" :" :,: :";'~ -: -:' .:':';:.:: ',' t~;' :\,~,: "~:'."::-:,.' :":-::"':, ::~.:"

\'.:.' .:",-, :':'.' .

6:8. Did 'y:ou -ev.er end your participation in or obsefVation' Ora ,detainee interviewor interrogation
~~~aJJ~~ .(?f ~he' int~rvi~w gr' t!1t~rr9'ggtiQn m~t!1gg.s b~i1l9 4~~?

0: Yes; 0 No
$9.:Wer~ you ey~n(;M thaJ:a'n~oth~r Fj3I.¢mp:lbye~:ehp'e,d hi,s:Q'r I\~r p~'rtlcipati.Qn'in:on)l>~erya.~i.o'n Qf,.a
detainee interView dt interrogation b'ecause of the interview or inten'og'citi6n 'methods lreing used:?

OIGQ-005076

o.Yes

(ijNo

70.. puringj3:ny- .ofYbll'r'"Ov.er~s (:I~pj6Yri1e(its 9r a·s5.igm'n~nts, diO yOIJ T,::!port .any: cq~ns.regamin9.

any ,oetcHliee. intervieYli.oj" interrbg.ation p.icictices, 'or otfier types.of d.etainee .treatrrieriX" to 'an FBI

'Supervisor?
(rYes

(V'NQ"

on. any.:d.e.ta:inee
Dur:ln~';3ny :Qf YQ.ur ~rY~r~s tlepJoym:ents; or C!%s'I~ntn:e.tlt~-,.J;lI.d y~u r.eAArt ~riY c:o.l1C$"ns re-gardlng
i riterrpga,tiOn p
or' olher
of
lr.eatmerit Ypu
JntefYleWj~l:r
~bdu.t~

observed or heard

~ctices

:ty~'

.d~ta in~

to,a non-FBI supervisor' of other non-FBI p.er'sonnel1

Oves @ No"
7'i~ H.C!ve yp}) .~er Qee,IT Qr4ere:<! or gi~~ lJ9t'tO report, 'l;l"['d isc9:l:!r~ed In. <'!(ly"v«Wfrvrt:l fepj:>r:!:IOgl
6b""
"S· II~g,.
"XVgn,§.....
. "'!<l'ed 10 d .~.a.ng~
I I "" T"
I " !If.r IIl~
"Ii'{"IE':.'Qrl
W "hI"""
,,\'0
" Ct")9}}~9r
-" • "
,__ ~I'YA.,.!9(l._.Qr~
re~.JTl~!1~
erfQ~.
I n;a
> __ • •

'

."

p.taetices7.

"

0. Y¢!;: "0

NO

73'. tt~e:yo~ .«:;xp'e(~&;:e.d ,cUlt actual or ~h~t~~ re~"I,iatil?1Tfor reporting. Qb~rvatior.tS:.or :aJ!~~tio~
,p.f petain,ee U~lmen.t ~t iQt.~lVi~ .or int~'r.~Qg,atip.:n ,aqiqr1%:qr pral=tic.eSv
QY~' "~"~O
"

74~ (6p~J.o.~iJ Pl~?o.~ pr.<?yf~~ arw:addltlonal ~r:nln~nts (~~Fdi09'~ repJ)rtrl"!!l"f.?f 9',lJC~{ns: r~l<n~
jritl::rvieyt or fn.lerrqgatrj:1i'1 t~hl'ilgu¢S; Q¢1entiQn pr!Slt!:i~, 'or:othe;{ detaiii¢etr¢?ltment.

iij#\t~~_.

!9"

0 1

75, We.r:e.you .Q.ep:rie"fcii" 9!h!:!r·!hari. tbe·~tantlatd detiriefln' FD-772,. c;:or'iGerning' y.ou r -6:v.elPe"<;ls
·as$i9."nmeflf(s) ,ot,depbymeijt.cs:). after you tbthpreted the dep:loYrtle!rtts)" b'r;ass'iQ riinerit(s.)?"
0- Yf..S: @:N6
Zf5. 'Adoitkltial Comments arid 'RerommerKIatio,ns:

OIGQ-005077

 

 

The Habeas Citebook Ineffective Counsel Side
Advertise here
PLN Subscribe Now Ad