Skip navigation
The Habeas Citebook Ineffective Counsel - Header

Aclu v Dod Doj Questionnaire Regarding Detainees 00001714

Download original document:
Brief thumbnail
This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. Check the original document to verify accuracy.
Department-of J".~tice Inspector- Gener'al-Ques~icmnaireRe~a'r,din'~ Detain:ee's
D,OJ.-OI~ INVEST,IGATIVE

QUESTIONNAIRE

FO~

REVIEW AN{j USE ONL¥ BYIN{jIV1DUAL FBI ItESPONDENTS
'"
,
1:1'(1 NOT FORWARD PR: Dl~EMI~ATE '

,

qUEsTIONNAIREID:tes~QQO~17~4

,As 'oJ ~I'.t~ I~sttime thjs:q!J~~i(mnaire. w~~ sa~~di ~ome re:quire,d fields:",av~ nQ~ ~een C9~pl~~ed.
PJ~cis'~ r:evi~wytJlJr' responses.

~}J&~:'_~
:jA:P;rsoO~I'I~fPrmaj:ion
Please,pr.ovide' thefollowi.ntl information:
1. Fir;st namia'
"i,'Mldgle InWaf:
3: Last name:
4. E,riter.ed on .IJ.u:ty Date (EOD):
::5:, Currei:\t D,j~isfQnlField, Office:
6., 9ummt Job Jitle:
.7., Direct:dial bffice,tel,ephmie number:

6 '!J.7¢PERAC?REEJ)I1!=.NT
'6 & 'lCPERAGREEMENT
(5 &, 7.C PER AGREEMENT

,6 &- 7C
~ ~ '7e

SpeCLq.! Ag,ent
,6:&7CPERAGREEMENT

,~_

8, fBI t~1I phone' ,nUri'loet:
FB.i p.i:;rger nLllnb:er~

'6~ t-9PE.RAGREEMfENT

~ &/1(; PER,~GRi;Ef¥1.ENT

10.. Be~t C:;Qptact /Jumper for'you~

'6 &

TC PER,AGREEMENt

11.. At any time a'ft:6f'lSep"temoer 1':1'1 2.001f did you serve as ,a memJ:)er of the U.S. Military, or as an,
empI6y:~e 'or contractor ot the FBI,orany other government agency, ,at Guantanamo Bay~ 'Cuba; Iraq;
Afg\1?l.ni,stcU1; or'ip areqs' controll~ by the ~.
MiIi~ry or a l),$. int:elligeoc:e 5~lVj~e irn:qnne<;:{f0'J:\'witli the

rs.

',9190al W?lron t~trot1

12. En~er the number :of time.s,ypuw~[e,d~pi9y.ed or:as$ign~d to E1ach ofthe.follOWitig [ogat(ons
KGiJantanamo Bay, Cuba;, lraq'~~Afghanistan;or in any areas controlled by'the_U:S. 'lYJilita'rY ,or a U.S~.
in~~lIig.en\S~ s~.rVt~ej';l.
'
For~each deployment or 'assignment ;complE!te the following seCtion.
Location 'select one)
..
~ep,l~ym~.nt Qf'lis,siimrilent ~eg1ln' q'iJ 01' DeplpY,Jl1MJ: 9rusignmei;lt e.'tded. on
, " " ,"

.'

,

,/,

~G'Ga'n't~:i'najj]:Q,BaY:
- . . . . . .~~ •• >..

\, • •'

'.-',;

.

aboll,t,

Dr about

08/2003

10/200:3'

~2~. Whp·t ~?stJie :gen'~(c~1 natO r'~ ~ hi=! p,u tp'q~~ qf'yQur assi~ rim_~I)'.t ~:Ihct -aj:tivitie.s]
IntervieW· of detainees at ,Gua'ntanamo, Bay
12b. Please provide,the', names of the"spedficvcamps, bases{ or facilities where you:worked.
Camp Del~a- Gu~ntan~m9' Bay'
12c. N'9~:' if IhfPrmi9Jion' ,a.b.Qu,t a ~p.e.cffic C'9mp, base" or'facill!:y' rs,C1a'sslfled :ab9,v~ SECRET,
plea~"th'eck here-Dr include in your:answer that yOll ha~e HadditJQoal'inf<:mnatioo t1assified-aJ~QVe
'SECREf/l' and, if you know, ia.entify·the.c1assification, level, ticket, ,co-rnpaifment~ programJ or,other'
desi9'1~ti0.n th~t appUes t9 t~e,informafiqn, .Qo not includ.e theC!ddit!onal classified fnf9rrnatrQn In:your

, OIGQ-004960

perso'nnel with the neces.sary clearance will cgntact you to rec~,ive it.

DIG

qI.Je'stic;mnaire re$ponse$.
~ame

P~sition,

,Giqnt Mendenhall
~12~. Did YQ\.l jointly' iht¢tyi,eW
_'_.----

_'_'

'

, Witb:what kinds cif

: 0 CITF

'

ASAC
pt inte.rrogate any det.airie_e w~th hOn-F~t per$otmej?,
, 0 '{e,s
0 lill=!
'

".

A

._">- _-_\_.

,..

,

_

:.
.;

IJOn-Far personnel di~ you wo,rkjoint!y?·

..

;:. b Other U.S. Military
; D 0.:5. inj:eliigeil'c~

,; 'Dl'idfelg:n -rilliitary
;~

D. O.tber

Qg.efiC;Y

or Inteillgence,agelicy
. '

'

:;::,: :.:-:: ':.:.:~:.:.::::: ::: :::::::: :.::: :.::":': :::~::: ::: ::::::: ::':::: :::.::.:::.:::~:
'ji2L Did you jointly plan any. detainee iriter.view Qr iriterro,gatlon strategy,. objectives,. or tactics w·(th' non-;F~I perso.lll1el'?·
,
~I

0~
'
.

,

O~
..

rwith wh~tki~ds-;t~~~~FBip'~r;;;n~1 did:-Yb~ ~o;kjoirrtiy? --.- -': -,-'- ~ -:- - ~'- ~ --",-'-- -----'- ---:0

CITF

'! 0' ,-Other u.s. Military

~ O'u,Pj intelligen!='e agency
: DFor~lgn mJIIJ,ary Qr INelllgenc~ qgenc;y

': D Other
1

'i

J,...

, __

"or.-

_

"f'

-:-

_.<-

,.. _,

.!- - - - - - - -,- - -t- - - -. - - - - - - -

-

"':" _ _ .... _ .- ... _ _

,~

_

....

-e _ _ -

_

-

.- _. -

_

-

,-

-

-

-

~

-

-

..... -

.-. ....., -

-

-

-A- -'~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - -.- - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - - - - - '- ---",

,12g . .wet~',you ever Pth~lse Involved In detalnee,lriterviews o.rlnterrogations ~Ith non'-fBI pe:rsonn¢l?- '.

-'
_.... -,... --,

--,~

.

-

- - -,... -- - - - - - -'-

"-'-'-

--

-,...,

b~
t··

'.

-

e~'

-

-

- - - - - - -'- -'- - -'- - -'- - - - - ....."\>

\

\'~

•

-.

_:..

- - - -- - -- - - -"-- -- _.,.... - .

"'"

. ;.. ..

,'.:.

A,. Tra~l;1in.g Pripr 'tp 'Qv~.r~ea$ ~eployment or A$$.ignm~nt

B. Did you

rMeiye anV training, insttilctioor. ,o'r ,gu'idanGe sp!=difiCally in 'pteparati6h for a'ny;6f your

overseas d'epldyments or assignments?
.bYes

14. Iii pr:eparatiol1 for, a'riy

eNo

e Do Not Recall

of ¥our 'oVers.eas deploYments .or ,assignments,·iI id you- receive any traihir;lQ,

in'struCtibn,,-or ,gu idanre ,cOncerning tne, sta nda'r<:1 s: of condiict a'pplicable to 'the.treatment;

,

interview,- or interrog,atio'n'ofdetainees by FBI personnel?

~NO

OIGQ-004961

15. In preparation-for any of your overseas deployments'or assignments, did you receive any' training,
In~ructlon, or guldao~ ~ncemlllg'the,.stand.arg~9fc0nd!Jc~applfc;~Q.Je to ~he tre,atm~rJt;

Intervi~W, or iriterrdg.atlQn of.detainees by' non-FBI p!,!rs.onn¢l?

'OYes,.

0N6

ODD NQt Recall

preparatio.n Tor any·of your overs~~~ep'lqYrnent$or q~sJgrHn~nts, dId you' rece,ve·~~w ~rajn!DQJ'
Instruction, or:gt,lId.C!nt.e con~emlng ~/hat '1.04 we~~,sup'P.95e~.t0 do {fYo~ 'opse'ryed or'h'e<!r~ a~.oQl

iii In

tlte treatrti.er'lt, 'interview,. Qr in.terrogatibn.of i:letaine.e~ bY FBI p~i'S(mli'!'!I, Which YQu fj'eli¢yed to
b-e Trlappr'~pr.ia·tef i.rnpr6.f~ssibnal, coer-tiv,e,:f3buSilie( ot'linlaWful?
..

.aYes

ONe>

,000 NotRecall

n. In. p'reparaJ:ip)'lJoJ ~nY~~(Yol,lr Ov.ets,e:as. !:feploym'eJ1~s or 'assJg!iinent~, ,Cltd V~I.) ri:!ceive any :trai,hin'g,

instruction,.. or 'gaida'nee COrle,em irig What You, Vy,er.e' ~u pp,os:ed :to do if you 0 bserved :or heard ~ bO.ut ,
the'treat"merif, interviewi: or ii1terrQgation',Df detainees. by non-FBI personn'el,. which you 'believed:
'to be.ll1apPfOpriaf~,unp.r0fe~~i.on!3l,:cqerciXie, ,abu2,iye,. <=!f unlC!lA!fuft

'Is. Tr:airiing Durin'g 'Ov,erseas Depldynmnts or AS$i~nmenlS

I

18. During any.of your .over:seas· deployments or assig nmen'ts, did you. receive a,ny·training .. instructioni'
~r €)l,Iid,a!1<:ie 'con~rnir1g th,~,!?t~nd,?r~~ of ,CQrJ'CIu_q.~ppli~p~11=~d,the tr-eat.ffi'~,nt'J intervIew; or

intert09i;ltlon oJ l:let~lne~s"y

F~[ ~rsoon€!17

l~'Y.es
QNti,
18:a, Whd P~9V!P'e(( ~h~ tr~ir'llng" In's.tru~tlqnf ,qr gUlclance~
TQY $sA,!lt <$,ua~tan~l']lQ- ~ay

QoP. N0t Re.cair

19b. Briefly describe the substan<::e of the 'trainiI"'!9(, instructlon r or gUidance· provided' to:you.
ACIvisea tliat FBI stahtfard's' for' interviews"apjjlied .at .GJMQ·
'lS.c:. WC\$::aby 0f th~ 'trai'niti"9, "jri:structJQr}, qr gl)idat:lt~' p'(qyide'd in' wrlttng?
,
, , :aVes "ONo, :0 Do, Not ReGaIl

19. D\J~jn~'~nr Pf-Y?U~ ?:y,~rs~~'s',d~pJ,~Y!TI~nts or ~~siqm~~rltS,

'did yo~. re~~~.e ,af1~,tr:al~!~,~, in.stnJc.tion',
,or;gUldance,c,oncernlr'ig tlie standar.Qs of c,onduct applicable to,th:e treatment, mtenilewror
'
Interrqgatlon of detainees by. non-FBI pe~onnel?

. .oy.~
. .,

0No

,20. Ourihl:j i3ny of your bv.erseas,deployments or a:;s.ig"nm.ents, did you reteiv6 any. tra,inirig, instructio"n,
·or:qliiaance, concerning what "yo.li" w~'re' sa pposed to de 'if you :obserVea .ofheard .alJouHhe
t~tf!l~n~J.lntervlewi,'Or In~~rrQgatll?!l'of d~,nees,
FBJ personn~l, Whlc,h Y9lf b~lleve9 ,to be
in;:!PP'r!=lPJi9.t~,·ll,rtpr9f!,!?sfon~li"c~eraiV~i ?b~~ive, Qf lJf:ilaWf1,lr?

"v

'0 Yes

OIGQ-004962

21. During any of your,oversea's deployments or assignments, did you receive any. training; instruction"
·or'gufda.nce concernll1g wh?~ you were',suppos'ed to ~o·lf you obse~~d ,or'J:l~r~ ·aRout the:
-treatment! interview,. or int¢r:rogatiOh',of ,Qe~inees by n9h-FBI pers()nn~I, Which yo.u b"elieved to
D.e inapproprrate~ unpYoles.$IOrial, ~o€!tti,rera.~QsiY~, or urtlaWf1H?,

OYes

'QDo Not'Recall

·eNo.

Ie. Adequacy of Training.

I

:2.2.)0' ·your.·opinion, ·d)d, YOlJ r~ejv.e ad~quate:traJni.n.g,. ins~ruction,· or.gul~a.Qqe rela~jng. t.o·$ta.ndards
M ~nJ:iuct by ,FBI ,and rlQn-FBI persQnnE;i1 r~lating to treatment} .ihterview; qr interrogation of
deta,inees. p.rlpr

to. yout' deployment .Qr as.siq nment?

o Yes 0 Nq
--2,2<;1.,
--- Please
-'- - --- --'- -- -- _.- .... - --.., -_ ........ --- -'' ' ' _ ... - -- - ----- -- -_.- --- --'- - .... _- - ---,
~esc~ib~ th~ 'y.r~Y$ 'in 'lfhich :yGU belie'l.e t/:l~ trail1ing, iJ:lstructiofl orguic!an~ was
-~

_..:..

-"-

ih.;ldequCjfe:.

,

,

_"p~i9·Ct_b~dj~:p~Jj:i.tJ9 !~f_~~a!1~_ti~!!J9J3jlY!:.1_ ~~g~t!~~!I!~'e!vJ'l~L ~!~YJ~~i!J9.
23..'Ifj your:opinip[I"
, ;pf conduet

~

,

di~ yo!-! r~~jy.e;p'd~quate tratniIJ9, ifl5tr:uct!on, or'gt;.lIdcm'cereli;ltjng to.s:t:Qrtdq,rc;ls:

PV FBI'and

n~n-FEn pJ~I~tinel relcjt/rig t(>'trea~mE;!nt, interJi.ew,. pr in~er(9.gati9nqf

A.etalhe~s,curing' your deployment;bf~assl.gnmeritT

0Y~

nNa

14.1n 'your opinion, did 'lOU receiv.e'adeQuate training., InstruCtion,'or guidanee co-hcerning -What you
lJ.{ere SUPP9Se4 t9 d'o' ifYo~. o,bserv~s:J :<ilr he~rd ab9ut. the treatf!leni,. in,t~rv!ew, or; In~errogation :of
getail;l~esl by FBLof'n~n':FB,I p,etS9nrel, t!iat ¥ou pelieve<l wC\sinapRrQp-riale, ,unprofessional,
t'6.e'rdve~ ab~sIVe~ pr un'lawful?

.25. (Optional)'In what ways; can the 'FBJ improve. training
'assignments?
'

on this;slibj~ctfdr

future.· deployments at
.

lo•.comments
2'&.

I

---,-----:-------,----,---------,-------

P.le,a·se provi~e.~:my ,?ldditipnal i.nformatio.n <;~n'c~.mlri.g trafnir:i9 .for Qvers~a~ deplqym~ritsor
~s~i9:rlments of FBI p:ersonnel yb.u b.eli$.ve isreleval)t•

.In~",p,d!JcUbn ,tQ Par~IU~ rrf~~iS :sec,ti<m', W,e -ar~ :~le!=Ring infgrnjation :r~!'!tplng :a vliire' rang,e 9f
int.ervleyv :Qf int~rrbgaJ(Qn'.t.ec;linique?:

'9n:d

o.tli~r Wpes, of:det;aine.e tr.~atht~t ;alle~r~(r tb h<;l'y'~ QP;:.ufreJ:t

You should n6tass\.lme, jlist because we'are,askinq ab,out a particular techhiq'ue or practice) tnatwe, have
conduded that it In 'faet oCUlrred. We recog nize that :some

of these techniques or practices may at times

OIGQ-004963

be ne!=eSSClI)' for safewand security. In acIetefl~ion settibg. Ilf adcfitloJYr ,Yl/e re<:;ognize that, ~OV1e oftnese
techn IqQeq 9.T pr9c~lc~ ma~ .haye be~n authqrlzeg for u~e: I:>Y mllit~lIY qr ot.her~ ql,iemment pers(;mrtel.
With respect to ',each .identified technTque( pradicer.0r type of €onduct:aeScrlbed below, we ate seeking
information ,about its occurrence during or in connection' with the interview or interrogation- of a
de~aineei·or ~uring th~'~elE!ntlo.n .of a get~in~ b~ygnd wh~t is.l1e~d¢d fQr s~fe~ ang se~urity.
In' that ',~ont~t)' we. will Fisk you to te.!.! ps Jf!h!=~her 90r=.or mQre, Of.1h:e folI!:lWi,n~ ;srateriteht~ ~te: tr!Je:

1. Ipefsbnally' ooserved this conduct.

·1,. r observed ,detainee(s} in a conditfon tnat led' me to believe' that 'this-conduct had 'OCCUfrea.
3 .. ~et~Jn~{~l.t<?ld IT\~ th~t, thl.s:<;ondl-!ct; "Cl~ oq:urr!=~.
.
Other:~wh~ obse:rved, Jill? l:,onctt,l¢t de~j:riJj,ed jt to me.
5,. I, nave. releva)U. information C1asslfieq above, "SECRET"';
'6. I never .observed this conduct nor heard about it fromsomec:me:who: did.

4,

a. D r per.Sonally· obserVed this 'cbnduc.t.
b. 0 Iobs,erv.ed detaifiee(s).lil,:a',cond itioh that led me' to b.ellelle thanhls Conduct had ,(jc'cllrred.,
c. D Detainee (5). t'gld ,me that this corid tict had ,occuh:ed.
d. D Others who observed ,this cond uct described it to me.
e.

D

f.

g

r nave relevant information classified abov.e !'SECRETll:.

-

cl,~~

1 never'observed this:conduct nOf heard aboutit from someone who did.

·i8. ,q~priying

<3, 'dt;tain~

~-'.~.-

!::if-clo'thing

a. o II pet.sonany,o'b§enied' this ,conduct
b. D iI bb'serv.ed' detain~e(s} in.a lZ.ohditRm that led me. to b~IJ~ve Jhat thi~ co.hdtit:t ttad "occurr~d.
c. D 1Detalnei=(s) told 'me that this: cond u'et had ,occurred.
··_'·E_M__' _.- ---.-.----,,,--.-,,.---.,--..-",---.---.,-..-,, -,---.-----.

to. me.

'd.

q

e.

o II have h~levant inform'ation Glassified above·"-5ECRET'I.

f.

lathers who Observed this co'nduet describ.ed it

o II. never observed' thrs:conduct nor heard 'about it from someone'wh@ did.

I

:2.9,. Depriying;:\, detainee ofsleep, \)r ioterr:upting ·s.l~p h'Y frequ¢nt·c~1i Jelo(;ations'or'otber mettlQds
a,

b'.

D I persbnally dh,ser:v:ea this cOni:rut.t.
hl'~~orid.ition ~nat l¢d
0.. r 6bseryed"detaine~(s):
.
..
'

,

.

me, to b~ljeye thqt:this conduct haQ oq;t.irr~tl.,
..
.' ..

OIGQ-004964

·

.,

,

c.

0

d.

0

0
f: 0

e.

Detalnee(s) told me that this conduct had ;occurred.
o.thers who observed this conduct described it to me.

r

~ave releva!1t Informqt!on c1a?slfl~ q~ove: I\SJ=CR,ET"',

I nevE?( 0 05erve:~ tnis,<conc;j lmt ,nor hecJrd

a bpll.t it frpm" ~meC?ne' Who d ld.

'g'; Pleas,~ provrd'~ the qppt6xim~t~tim.~ framec;lurlhg which

thjs' c~'ridljet .Qq;:.urre(:{.
000 Not Recall

From .08/2003 to. Hl/2003
'
h.; The.ctetalnt;ielS') treated. in thi.s wCly.were located at the time In:
i'0 GI,J<;lntan,arrio
.
.
2, 01~:q

3'0 Afghanistan
4 0 otber Locatkm

~

0

00 NotRec:alJ

I. Please Id,entlfy',theidetalnee('S) bYJ1ame and number:'
unknown·
,j. Pleas¢, id~ntifY t'he:'j:j¢rsan:(:s:}. wh~,treaj:¢d, the,.de~aJnee(i) iJ) t.h'i~ manner" in¢Li.!Oin'g ~n¢ir'
riame(5)' arid .gov.errimentagencYCies}:
Nev.er observed or ·wa's spedflcciUy' told abolit aiiy.detaiitee: being ,oepriv.ed of sleep'. However was,
?,Wpre Qf pr9gr~r.n the Army 'callet! th~:"fr~L!,el1! fly~r Pfo9rqlT.l:" Oet~lJ!ee~,wer~ !T1oved Jr<;>!T1. e~lI.
t9 cell'very'freq~ently. Do no~ know h9yV many times ln ~,glven time perlop they were a~tlJ,al!Y

moted. NeYer)iersanally- btisei?J.ed'thiS.
Pl.~~$¢ !<l~n,tify 'f1:J-Y}.'lther FBI persp,ii,neJ 9r npri-F~I 'pers,o'nliel
In thiS; manner, i1iCludjng their'lJal'n.~Cs) ,and ,agency'(ies);

1<.

Possibly, FBI "SAl

I

..

wt:!Q· 6,p,serve(1

c;I~talne,ets)

ttePted

b6
b7C

-,

I. 'Thls'conduct 'occurred rn connectl'0'n with;.
" , ' , , ' ..,
'

10 -One detaln'ee"

2 'Os'ev~ral detainee~ (2-4-) ,
Many geta i nee:>: (more: fhan 41
Do NQ,t Recall
'

30
4 '0

m. (.bptfppal) Rleasedes<;rjbe'th!='rel~vant dn::umstanc~~ in mQre'dett;lil::

b6
b7C

:3'0. Seating a, detainee

0 r per$bnaJly ob_~r-v:ed tliis.cqnduG.t.
b. 0 ~ obs'ervetl,deti~inee.(s)·, ili:~ ,condition that I¢d

8,

me. to believe that'this'Clin!:lucit lia,d Qccuireti.

OIGQ-004965

..

,.

..

,

.,

.

d.

0
D

'e.

o irhave re1eva)1t informCltion d,?S5jff~ Cl90ve "S,ECR~r'·.

l

0

3:1.

U~i.ng,w.at~r .t9 p-reYentQre~tbin,g

c.

.

,

"

,

.

Detalnee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.
Others: who observed this cond uct described it to' me,
I nev~r' op~erve:d thisJtQncjud·nor heard apqUt'it trom ~JT1ebi1~who,dI4.

.

by a ,detalnE!e,dr tQ.·¢recit¢ the ~en~tiQn pfdroWr1,ing

0 I personallY ob'ser.ved this"conduct.
b. 0 Lohserveddetalne,e(s) ina condition that leet me to belieye thatthis conduct
'Co D Detainee(s} toM me that this conduct had :0ccurred.
d', D Others whID observed this EDnduct described It to me.
e. D. I, ~ave ,relevant inforrn~~jl?~. c1as~m~ above: "S,EGRET"'.
a,

f. 0 t. !.l~v.er o.bs~rveq

fiad .occllrted.

t~i~ 'CQJ:\d(J~~ nor l:J~xd abqut-!t fl"9!11'~lrreoD~ who d,i9,
:

,

'32:: ljgln~ hpods,
rpp~,_
dnanything
or $tra~g'i~ a detP'ine¢"
'f''''''',';
_ _. ,else, tcrchoke
, ....

~~~.

,a. 0 I, personally oDse(\!ed this ~on·duct.
b. D, I 'obserVed. deta',neets:) irribEond ttiah fhat lea me to, believe lhat:'this c0ndu:d:' had .occiJ~red.
c. 0 Detainee(.s)-toJd rile thcitlhiscondi.td: had,o,cc::urred.
d. D Others who obsellfed this conductdescribed it to me.
e. 0 I have releyant information classified abo:v:e "SECRET",.
f.

0 r never ob?erye~ thi,s 'colJd\lct nor heqrd qb,!:lut i~ from: someon~ whO' qid.

'3,3. ThJea~entng nth,eraPlkm to'caus,~,p,hy~lccd Wl'i(l, rnjury,:d!stig"JremeHt" Qr depth

,a. D I persOnallY ooseiVea this,;cdhduet.
b..

D

[observed detalliee(sJ hi a,cond iUo'n that 1M me to. belIeve thanhls- conauct hadoGcurred.

~,

0

Detaiilee(s}told me that this' conduct had occurred.

d. -0
e; D
f, 0

Others: who ol:isetVed this tond,Lid d'escribetJ if

to hie..

r have relevant Information: classified ilbove !!S,ECRET",.

:

r,r:tev,erobserve-q th"s'condu~t,nor heqrd about-it from somepn~w:~o di~,

OIGQ-004966

34. 'O.th~r treatril.ent or C!i;:tl~m' causing j;igriifi,cant p'hysical pain Dr injury" or cam~ing t1isf!guremE:!l'I! Qr
death'
.

0 I personall.Y observed this.conduct.
b: 0 I observed ·deta'~lJ.~~(s) in ·a~cQnclitio.(lt~a~ led me to beUev~ thi;tt t.his cc:mdu,q: had occurred.,
<;. D. O~JS!in~(s) tol~ rn~t.n9.t this. C.9"g.uC~ h~d '9.ccurre<;l.
.
'cj • 0 ., Other;>: ~l1q ob'seryeq tf:iis cqndl(<;t d.e$<;dped It to. me.,
e. 0 I h~l.'.~e rele.va.n~ iDformatiori dcjssified "ql;JoVe·'(SEtRi:T"'.

'a:

,

f.

ItT r' ne\;(er qQ$erved this c9J.1.dq¢t nor he?ird 'abQut it 'fram. $Qhi~9ne'Wh9 diq.

:.35. Pla~lng a detahiee .pn a htlt $urfac~ or Burning

0
.b: 0
E;~
D
a.

a de~lnee.

.

I personally observed this'conduct.
Lobserved detaIl'.lee(s) In :a'con<;litI0[l tha,t led Jll~' to believe that.~hl~ cond,l!ct hac!9~<;urred .
De~ainee.(sJ to/.d me that t,hi.s cQnduct ~,aq occurr~.

o lQthers who observecj this. cqndl1ct described it to me.
e.. o jr. h~ve rel.evant inform~tlon f:la~s'ined abov~: "SE¢R.ET"'.
~,

_

.....

~~

f: 0' ~ never o.bs·erv:e~ this cQndlJ-d lior heard ,aoo.uUt fram.s.Cirhebne:wbb' did.

:3.6. Using shad<les or"oth~r .restraints, in
a:

h..
c.

a prolcing~d

manner

d II personallY'0bserved this,'condue:t.

o Ir'observ,ed detainee(s) In a-·condition that led me to' believe thatthis conduct had ;ocGurred.
o !D~~ainee(s) toldf.T:le that t~is. c0n~l.uct. h.ad ,000:;~u~.reQ ..

<;L 1010thers who o~ser:ved t~i$ ~lJd.L!ct;desql~ed it t9

e.
f.

me,

o lr. have relevant information dassjfiE~d above "SECRET'''
o II never obs'~rved thi~.C90~h~ct nqrl1e,ar~ ·apou.t it fr9rh'Sqrn~pn~VJhQ'dip.
.

I

I '

.

.

'

\

.....

'"

•

~;...

•

•

g. Pleaqg provid~ tne. \3pproximate time.frarne'dL!rrrrg whiG.h ~i1'js con'd,uctQ~clJrred.
Frdni 08/20'03 to 10/2003'
.
Not Recall

Dno

h, 'Th'e:d~~arn'e~($) .tre~ted
1 0 <;:i~antan.amo

'in thiS' way w¢re IQ.!:'at$.:i at the tjiTre in:
.

OIGQ-004967

20 Iraq
0 Afg hanistan
if 0 Other Location
5 0 Dl:> Not Recall
;3.

I. Pl¢ase· Identify the. detaln~(s) by name :and. hLim ber:

Unknown

.

j, 'Pie~se identity- the p.e[son (5) 'who. treate.d th¢ detalnee(s) jr'! .this rhanne'r, in'e1udlng their
natners) <;InQ .gov~rnri1enta:e'ncy;~).:
.'
.Lbelieve on..one :bf,sAl~hterviewsr the-Army guards inadvertently left a detainee in
shackles for an extenderl period a "time. Not sure how lon,g (an afternoon perhaps)

k. PJea5e< Identify any.ottie'''' FBI. p.er-sOhnel or nGn-FBf personnel·Who,observed detall'1ee(s) .treated
in this manner including their name(s) and agency (ies) :.
' '

rs~

sAl

ICO

I.. ThisJ:ond:uct occurred in :Co'ME~"ctiohWith:

O'n¢. d.l~tajnee
Severa'l d.etafn~s (~-4")
30 Many detainees (l'n6i'e than 4}
4 q Do ~0t Re~n

1. 0
2; 0

m. ·(.op:tional) Ple<ise desGriDe·the·relevaht circumstahces..in more:detailr

.a. D
b,
c:
d',

I pe;rsonally oDseJVed thIs ~onduc.t.

0 I.obs.er.v.ed detciinee(s) 16 Cl'coriditf0l'i toat led -me to believe that this' c<mduct bad·occu'rred.

o IDetal.ne.e~s) told me that .ttiis l':bntlu.ct had ·Qceurrei:f..
0'

e, D

E ci

Others who ol:i.served thjs conduct described

it- to me.

I have relevant fl'lfotma"tion dassifTed aboVe· '~S·ECREP.

}; never observed this ~GOnduct nor heard about It from someone who d"ICi.

9.. PI~~s,e provjd~ t.he approx!m9~e tirn:e :rrafTTe qu~lllg whi~.h .thls;cqndYGt .oc<?u(r~d.
From' 'Q~iiQ03 to io/i6(t~·
DD,t) .Not Recci1i
h~ T~e detaine~:(s.} treated !n ~f1!S way· wen~ located ~t the time In:
J, It] C?u;slntanqmo
~ D'I~q
3 0 ,Afg han·15t.~n
4 0 Other LoCation

OIGQ-004968

b6
b7C

sO Do Not Re<::;:'lll
,. Please id.entify the detaineer~} by. name all.d number:

Unkri9Wn

.

J. 'Pleas.e idehtity the'persoft(s)"whp treated the·detalnee(s) in tbis manner, Indudlng their.
name(s) and government,agenCY(ie!i.Y:
·Assumed.Army

k. Please identify ·any' other FBI perSonnel or non.:.FBI 'personnel who observed detainee(s,) treated
io ~h~ m.~I'ln¢rrrn:~,I~dl~gt~~rr ng!T1~(s} fl'nd:qg~ncy(~~):
.
Do riot res:all

I. This·coni:lllCt :ecCurr.ed In :cO"onedl.on

1.
t

a 'One detainee
a

wlth~

'

Several detainees (2..-4.)

Many .de~~ne~ .(l!lor~ than 41
40 Ij>o Not ReG3I!
j

0

m. fbpiional) Please describe the' relevant ciroumstances in more-detail:

[,belieVe I recall hearing ruinorS of a :techniqiJe'.tne mintary used .whicnVias to keep,a'detaine.e
r~t,rail!~ i~ j3n un,oom"fo$~Ie-l?t?Sitio.~'c;fuFlng il)t~,l'\!!ew$, I90 not:have any fjr.St h.and knqwl~g~
pfthl!;:.
138. Fon::!ng a 9~t~lnee. t:..q'per1~HlT,I.demancflng Rtjysjc~1 e,x:erclse

a. 0
b. 0
c. 0
d.

I perSplially 9~"Sj§rved thts qmc;fue,t.
I 9b.>e:rved detaln~(s). ind,CQ[id1tipn' tJ1at led me to b't!:lieve thqUhiS conJ:!utt h~ oCq,Irrec{.
Detainee(s) told 'me .tiiat this. cond uct had ,ocCurred,.

o ptl:lerS who Qliser\led this oonduct·descrlbed

It to. ttla

.e.

o I[ have releVant loroiTriatlOn dasslfied .abOve '~SECRET",

f.

0"

II heYer.observed this coOdi....c t nor neard,abOlitIt from.sOmeone wlio.dld.

'39, Using elettrlc::::al shG¢k.on a detainee

a. D II personally 6bs:e~ed t"tiis~c6ndu~t.
b'.'
If6~serv-W p~~all1e"e(:sJ In.a CQndltIOh'~hat t~ me.to beliey~ .,thl,(t ~tS"~n-quct had :oq~lIrr¢!:i.
c.
1i;Jetaine,e(s) told .me tnat thiS:f;Qoo!iq: had ottUrfeP.

o

o
.d. o 'ottle"rs whb o~Se:rved this.l;ond.uct·d.ese·rib.ed it .tp, ril~
e. o ~ hav.e relevant InfOrmatIon I:las.slfied ab'o1Je "S'ECRfT·.
-

OIGQ-004969

~L ne~er observed thl;. condu~t no~ heard about It from some0n~. W·hO. did.

-40. Thre1'ltenlng to :usee(~cfrical sho'ck'ol1 a Qetainee:

0 perso nally obsE!rved this celid oct:.
6. 0 [,ops~rv:¢d detain~e.(s) iii a cohd ition th~t led. me. to believe that this- ~oh.du~t Iia~ :occurretl.

a.
G.

o

"D¢tai nee(s) ford

.me that tn.iS' conti uct had ,o.ccurred.

d.

0

e>tbets: who .obseliled this cOild uct destribed it to me.

e.

0

[ have relevant information dassified above "SECRET~!.

f:

~

L nev.er observed this:conduct nor'heard about it from.someonewho

did.

~.Ljntentfonally delaying 'or~denying detainee rriedk:al care

a. 0 ~. lferSQtlally,' ob~rve9 ~hls . :cQo.d.u~t.
d.etaineeCs)'
ill:a .cblidition that ied me fef believ.e that. this c.6nduct had .ocGurr:eCi.
b.. :0- ~. obsel"Ved
.......
.
c'. 0 Detain~(5)-told me' th~t this .coOOu(;:.t had .occurred.
d. 0 e>ttl~rs: who obseliled thIs corid'uct d~scr'lbed It to me;
."

._~.

·.e.

"f.

0 r have releyatit iofrilrmation c;[assiried .a Do)i.e '~SECREr".
0 I never observed. this 'con(J"uct n.i?r'lieard·a o"o"ut it frOm· someone who did;

a. 0 r: p~r,s6r'ialiy·.6p'serv'e~r
fro

o

c. o

this c'orlilu¢t.

!I obse-Ned detalnee("s)" In .:a·condltlon' th.at led me' to: b~II~.e that,thls: tonduct h'ad .occurred.
IDetainee~s) tdld me lhat this- c.onduct had :o.ccurred.

0 Othe~ who ob~rvel:l :this- coMatt des:crib¢·t! it to' me:.
e: 0 I ha\le'relev~:lnt Information Classified -abOVe "SECRET".

d.

If. J0' H neVer' ebserved thiscoiiduct nor'heard about it from someone:Whb dId.
"'

••• ,

J._ ......_

_

_"_". _ .• _.___ .. __ . _ , . . . . __.•_ _ _ . • • . • _

~

________•• __

~_-

_ _ ... _

.__

-

~--'~ -~.

43. Sllpjec,ting a d'etainee to extreme.ly cold or hot rG9m temperatures f(H e~ended perJ,ods

OIGQ-004970

-----a; D

,

,.

I personally observed thls,conduct.

b. [1 I observed detainee(s) in a'conditionthat led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.
c. D petainee(s) told me that thiscondl,lct haq:Qccurre9.
d. D !Oth~l? Who 'ob~eryed this c9ndL!ctQ~s~rfbed It to IT)e:
e.

0

I have rerevan~ i[lTOrmati?..:n_dassi~e9 pb'ove, ",SfC,R~~~ ___

f.

Itf

rnever~b'serv.edthis cl?npu...d n,qr h~rd'abol!t it fromSOl11eone:who did.

'--

44. Subjec:tlrlg a detaln,ee to loud musl.e

a. D I personally observed this 'conduct.

0 r 'observed detalnee(s) In'a cond Ition that led me to belieYe that this eonduct had occurred.
c; 0. Det?linee(s'j. told l"fl~ that this conduc;t h~d ~CCUlJe;d,~
q} 0 Otl1erp whp'O_bserye,d this l,:on<!u~t'des?rilJ~d it t~ me:,
e.;, 0 I hf.lve r~l~varit l.lJforma:tI~,n c1a,s~Jfl,e9 i::!PQv~ ":~'EC'RET'·!.
f. 0 r neVer o.~~eN~d this'conduGt not he:ard"abqu~ it from:'$orn~~"n~=whodi~.
b,

,

,

-I

9.. PI!aa~a provid~ the ~pprQ~imat~time fr'a'me ,durln'g wtijt,b this, cqnduct QCCurred.
from ,08/2:003' to, 19)20,03,:
, ODo Not Recall

h. 'rhe:ctetaiile,e(s) tte,a.fed in 'this yVpV Were la,cate!=! at th~ tiril¢ 'in:
1 0 'GUailtaiTc!rr19

20 Iraq
3D 'Afghanistan
4 0 ,Other Location
5

0 DC) Not Recall

i. 'Please.'identify,tbe,detainee(s) by' name and' number:
Q9' not tt~ve fir~t ,h?!lq kf1qY'!~9g,e
j. PI~ase id¢'ntify' th~ p~r~6nfs) 'Who treated' ~he detain'e~'(.s)
rlClme( 5) "~lid ~o.vernh1ent a'~fehcy(les)':
'
Assumed to be military

in thi~, manner; jl'idllding ~h.eir'
.,

p~rSbnhel or n6n~FB-I personnel Who on-served detairie'e(~) treated
in this,manner:" includ'ing their name(s) and agency'(ies),
r b~lievethis'Wa5"talked ab,Out the'fIrst'dayJ;' i3rriv¢a:at G.TMQ'

k. Please identify an'tother- FBI

L Thls,conduct :occt,trred in' connectl~n with:
One de~)n'ee
2
S(;i,v~ral d~ta'iri~'s (Z-4);3 '0 Many defaineesTt"riore
4)

1"0

a

tlian

OIGQ-004971 ,

4

0

Do Not Req311

111. (bptfqnal) Please ctesqrib'e,the:relevant ~Jrcumstances

fn more"defaH:

I do not reca II bei ng advised 'of 'any: partiGu far' event..I believe.orr the first day 'of our arriva I the

TE>Y· SSP; mention~!:I the military playing loyd music tluring in~ervi~Ws'
·-45. SUbjecting a detainee to bright, flashingJ!.g:.-h_ts_o_.r_d_a_r_l<n_e_s_s

_

a. D I pe(?Qnally:observed tliis ~nduct.
r9b~~rv:ed,detainee(?)

in .cfcqhditiQn'th~t

me to b'elieve that t!ii~ c<>.n'duct hap 'ot~l,fr:r¢d,

l),',

0

t.

o ~tre.tain¢e($)·tolq Iil~e .tha:t .thi~ G~rfdJ,ltt I)~~ DCC!Jrt:ea.

tL 0
~. 0
f. 0

Jed

0th.e'rS' who 'obser'Yed this tond utt d,escfiBed it to me.
(have rdevant iriformation' ¢Iassified 'a~o,ve "S,ECREf".
I: rieVer observed. thIs ;conti utt'nor ~h'ea rd abtiutlt from 'sOm~prie'W,ho did.

';g.

Please provide :the approximate time frame during which this.conduct,ocrcurred.
00:0 Nqt R,ec;:all
From 08/2Q03 to i,Ol:W(J~:

h. Th'e detainee(s) treated lnithis
1 r~l-Guatitanamo

2

way .Wer,e located at the time in:

o 'Iraq

.gO ,P,\fgh;:m,lstan

40
5

0

:Otb¢r LocatIon
[)o Not Recali

t. ,P1~se:i.clentlfY the det?l,nee(~) by nam,s= anp n.vmber;,
Unknown

j. Please' identify the person(s): who treated the detainee(s) in this manne~r 'induding their

!19m~($J gl1d g9yernrt1el1t;:.agel)c~(ie~I:
·As$um!=d military

.

'~; PJ~a$e' igentifY'?lIW other- F,BI p~rS9nllel or n~'>n-FBt personneJ 'Wh9"Qb~rve_q lietai,neg(s) 't,rE¥'!teq
rn this manner, inclupiny):t1eir n'a!TI~Xs) ,?ntl ;C!-g-ency('ies):
I believe thiswas:ta'lked about first day.at- Gr'MO. '

,I. This"conduct 'occurred fn connection with:

1,d One detainee
:2 QS~vera I c;let9'inee.s l?-4)
.3 0 Many 'deta'ihee~ .(more than' 4),
4 0 OQ. Not R-eG:! II
~. (()ptlonal) Plea~ destrlbe, th~, r~levant clrcum!;fai:'!ces

In more detail;

OIGQ-004972

AspartoHhe briefing upon arrlyal, I .believe the TDYSSA tpld us oflplJd music and str9b'e .lights-.
b-~ing u~ect .bY the iTllllt,ciiy.
4,6, IS9I13~ing

a qetaine~ fon~n exten(ied

p.~rJ9d.

a. 0 I persOnallY' obs~rY.ed this;conauct.
b, 0 I,observed detainee(S) In .a,l::ond Itlon that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

0 Detainee(s) told inethclt this conduct.had.oc'cur'red.
d. 0 Others who observed this cond uet described it to me.
e. 0 1. have relevant Information dassffied abov.e '!S.ECREf'l.
f: IB I, £1e~,er obs:'r;'ed ~!S 'G0nd~o\E. ~cmf ,Cl_~p_ut it f~~i~ll1~o.!.1e.wf}o d icl.
<:;;.

-----

47.. Using. duct tape to r~str'Cjin, g~,or E[;,.;~;;.;h.::..is;;.:'h.:..a;:;...;;;d...~t,;;;'a;,;,;ln;;;.;,e;..:e;...·.

-

_

.'

·a. 0 r persatially observ:ed this ',conduct.
b. 0 I observed t1etainee(s) in a condition that led me to belleVe that this cQ'nduct hadoc::clirretl.

0 D.etaihee(s)·told me that this conduCt had .oc€urred.
d. 0 Others who obSerVed this conduct described it to me.
C.

e.

[I

I. have rele~ant information classified above !!SECRET":.

f.

0'

I nev.er observed this,conduct nor heard about It from someone who did.

I
!

4S. Using, rapid .responqe te9ms anglor: fon:ed: c~1l ~x;tractii;ms,
:a.. '~

II' p~rSdnal.i.y dbserved 'i'his tbJidu.I;£

b. 0, r b,bservep det,airiee(s) iii fa ' c:ond ition'that led

c.
d.

I

o !Detainee(s) tbld me tliat this con'dtJ.ct had 6,ccurred.
o !Others who otisehred this cl:lndilct described it tb me..

-e. 0,
f.

me to belieVe that. tbis cO'nduct had ·.o<i,curred.

0

r. hav.e relevant information classified above "SECRET'l.
I never observed this.·cond'uct nor heard about it from someone who did.

'g", Please provid~ the apprOXimate time fraIT)e ~urfng which this'con~uct 'Occurred.
.From 08/2003 to 10/20Q3' .
OD:o Not Re~ii

OIGQ-004973

h. The detainee(s) t(eated in this way were Jocatea cit the .time in:
1 R1 GllantCmamo

20 Iraq
3D Af,ghanlstan
4 '0 9tl;ler Locati9n
.5. 0 Qp',NC!tR~1I

!\ ,~lease identify the det,a,in~(s) by nam.e an~ number:'
I,)nknowo

j. Please identitY the pe'rson(s)'whb ,treated ,the
'name(s) ,and .flovernment.agency{l~):
,A~~.um~ ,AnDY

del~liriee(s) in

' .

this, ma,nn¢r:, lricluding'tHeir
.

k Plea'se Identify any. 'other FBI personnel or non:.FBI personnel who:observed detaiAee(s.) treated
to 1:hjs-lTIaonerr inGluqing .th~ir D;:lme(s) '~mdqgencY(ie~)':

Unkno.vln

I. T.l1ls':cpndu:et occur're:d In .conn,eetloh wlth~

:( 0

One: detainee

:l '0 S'ever'ci'l detainees r?i-:4)
~ p Mq,ny ,qet~inees Irqore:ttJ?lrJ. 4)'
'4

q

DQ Not Re~lI

m. (Optional) Please describe, the relevant circumstances in more;detail:

During Ibui:! d1sturba'nres inside tamp Delta I obserVed' 'a team br.I'i1g' a restraIned detainee ,alit .on
a f1af :b.oard or s~fetcher.,r ~ssume ~~e leam ha~ extracted h'irrr tram the' cell. I'd id, not witn~!1
,~nything: insi~e th¢',camp.

'4!:l.

Using a

military workJng,~ on Of

near a det;:llnee'other than .during tletaln~~~rt~·a.'-'.tl~o;..;.n _ _

II'

0 p~r;:;~~~~serve:d {his,·qj.n~·uct.
p, 0 I ()!:5set\fed '.detalnee.(s) IWa tond itlon that led me to bell~-v.e :that' ,this con.duct had :6c~utreti.
c. 0 [)i;itaiilee(s). taid rri'e ~hat this conduct i'ia'd 'o~turred,
d. 0 Others: whO ,ob.$erved :Uris (;:obdact pe'scribea if to' m.e:

,ff.

I

-------....,.......---------------1

e.

--~--:.---------------------I

0 II haVe relel7a'lit lnformat 6,ii t1a'ssified a.c.ove ".sECRET".

------------------------1

f: 011 nev'er' 0bserved this:conduat nor'tleard'abbul it from S0ineohe'whb did.

SO. Threatening to use military working dogs:on or near a detainee,

~0

II p"erSQnaiiy ohrerved. thrs_.;..;.cQ_.n_d_u....;cl_.

--,...

--,-_ _....,.....1

OIGQ-004974

-

0 L observed detalnee(s) In a ,cond ftlon that led me to believe that this conduct had 'occurred.
c. 0 Detalnee(s) told me that this conduct had ,occurred.
d. 0 qther"?' who observed t~is col1d uct descriqed it to m~.
e. 0 I have releyant Information classified Abov~, "SECRET'!,
f. 0 r neverob~rveJ! thfs'q:mQUGt,n9r ,hear9 'abo.ut it from someOne. who d.id.
b.

a.

0

I pers9nally o.bserved this 'conduct.

b' "

q

I observed detainee(s) In a'condifio.n'that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

,c.

0

Detalnee.(s.) told me that this conduct had :occurred.

cL

o lothers who ob~erye.c! '~,I:!is c0nductde$crl~eCl it to fIle.

eo.

0
f: 0'

a.

I, ha-v:~ releva~rjt Information' c1as~ifiec1 ab.oy~ "S~~ET''''
I n~y~r qps,~rve:c!, th~s 'coDfluct ngr ,h~r.d :al?o.!-l,t It :trorn,~rn~on~'who dtd.

o II p,sr30hally'ebserved, tliis.condlkt.

b. 0 I,obserVed deiainee(s)' in :a-cohdition that led me to' believe that this conduct had :cccurred.
, c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :o'ccurred.

~

0
I·e. 0
If. 0
I

Others who observed this conduct described it to me:
I have relevant informati.on classified i;lbove; "SECRET'''.
I never9P~erv~(.qhis,co.nd,=,ct noriJ~rd.a.p.P\ltfit from someone:who qid 7

•

)

53.. DJsrespectful,sjatem$rtts, handling r 'QI' ,actions. involvi ng the

K9ta n:

0 per.sonally-Ob.served this condutt.
~ 0 I 'observed detainee(s): in a condition that led me to. believe that this conduct, had .occu'rred.
0 Detaihee(s)tola me theit {his conduct haa"oCGurtect.
d, 0, ,Others who observed .this conduct described it to me.
'e: 0 ~,hqv.e relevant !nform~.tion. dassifie.rJ C3bove I~S~CRl:r"· ..
f. 0 t Dever o.bse,rved, this ''90 ndl,Ict nor heqr.d ·abou~ i~ from,sorrreo,ne 'o/no di<!.

la.

Ie;

OIGQ-004975

.~. Ple'ase, provide th,e approximate time frame .during which this cpndu.ct :occyrr:,e:d.

DDo,Not R.~calr-

From .08/2003' to' 10/2003,

h. The .detainee(s) treated in

tflr~

way, were located at the time in i

10 Gl1ahtanamo
L 0 Iraq
a 0 Afghanistan

d :0th~r Locat19n
50 Pc?: N'qt ReGlII

,4

r.

please (dentlfy'the det~)n~{$) ~y nalJ1e ~nd nU,rnber:
nam~'or nu.mb~ ...S~U9i

unknoWn

j ..P.lease identify the petson(s}"whb treated the detaiilee(s) in ttiisrhanner,. including their
name(s) and ,government :agency(ies):
'
.
<:l:S,sume9 Ar,my

k. 'Plea'se, iaenfify.any 'other FBI personnel or non'-FBI personnel who~observed detaiAee(~J. treated

in t~I~' m~nt")err,lncludlQg

thek n~lTJ~(~J:and ag'el1cy(l~s):
D'o liot recall who was; in iJiteNiew 'rbom whe'ri detainee relayed h'earsay info

I. This conduct occui"red iii ,connection with.:'
1, '@ 'One' detainee

2.0 Sev.eral detainees (2-4). ,
,3 0 ~any detaillees (more; than
,4 0 09 Npt R!,!call

4)

m. (Optional) Please describethe relevant circumstances' in mor.e detail:

young'Szuldi detci inee was angry, d yrihg 'intervieW because he, had heard that· a guard had
, dlsr~spect~ th:e, Kor?!!
.

54. 'Shavl~g a' detainee'S' facial 'or other'halrto embarrass;:or humiliate: a detainee,

r;.\o.lr persona(lyobserved this ...tonduc::t.
..
,

,

R; ,0 II pb~lV!=:.d ~etal~ee(i): ilT ia~cpnd itioli th~t led me to peUe~e tnanhiS: C;OIT.P!Jct hac:! :occutrep.
c;

0.

P'etalnee($} told me ~hat ,this. CQridul:t haQ ,oc~urt:ed.

d.

[1

Others. Wh'Q Qbserv,eq ttIi$: cQiid,utt j:fescr'ibed it .to, ro~.

$.

0 I h;we re,le,vC\nt Informatlqri cias.slfled ~bov~ ·;$:E~REf".

f:

o II never'observed this,c6nduct,norliear.d aboul it from 'sorneone wJi'O:did.

g'.

Please proVide the app'r6xlmate time frarh~ during w.hlch thrs conduct:0ccurred.

OIGQ-004976

00-0 Not Recall

From 08/2003 to 1O/-200s

h. The petaln~e($) treated in t.hls w.ay ~ere IQ.~ate9 at th¢ time tn:
1
.~.uantal)amo
2,0 lra~
3,D,Afghanistan
4 0 Other Location
~.D De ~ot ~e<;all

!tJ

i. Please 'identitY the detalnee(s} by flame and number:
t:;an no~ recalL.:.w0uld remem~r detai!1e~:Dame"if pr!?lT1pted
j, PI~!3se i~en.tify- the persolJ(s)' whQ Jreated the ~E;!,t,ainee(s) iii thi~ rTJ~nhl:l~, intlljding th'eir
name('5),and goverrimeiifagency.(ies)::
.
.
Army
-.
,
k. Please identify'anY other: FBlpefsonnel or' hOI'l-FBIJjersol1nel wlio:obselVed detainee(s) W:~ated
.!n this manner. Ihcludlng thelr name~sl and agency(les):
, P-'o:S$iJj)yl
~9r'1

I

: L Tlii,s Co.riolrGt .oG!:;J..Irted, iii ~pnJi,etli.o:n With:
'1-0. :Qrie. de,taJn~
2 .0 .severai detainees (2-4)
3 d Many' detafnees '(.inore than 4;):
:4 b. Do N0t Reca'lI
'til. (Opti6.nal) Please' describe

the'rel~\I.ant

circumstances iii Inore,'aetail:

D~tciinee's :h~a~ w'Q$' sli;;\ve,cf...D.et,a,in'e¢ s.aid hi,S head was; ~naVed 'b¢Ca,use he.th'rp\l9h:s,oiTie~hin~r
,on one ofthe:gliards.(pesslbly water)
,
,
--,--------~--_._--------

0
D'. 0
c. 0

1. personally observed this:conduct

a.

<,I.
e.

o
0

~: observed; detqrnt?'~.c s} In 'a,:cond1t1O'n th~t led ~~ to' believe t~at: ~his cond uct had occurred.

O-etaIDee.(s) t,qld rn~ that this condu~t hl:lq ·oc:cl,!rred.
,

Others who observed this conduct- d,escribed it to' me.
. . . ~,

•

~

•

-

•

,"

........

•

."

' •• ~

-

•

•

.... ,

,

I

_

~'"

•

.._

I ~~ve rele;va,nt l.nfprll)atlon c1a~sifl,ed ~b'o'J~' "SECRI;P'.

~

f. ~ I n~'i!er obserJ~ct this Cl;induct norheal'd abp,utiUrom's0rIJeonewt)b di~.

56. Touching 'Cl d'elainee. or a-ttlh'g toward

a d.eta,ll:I~ In 'a 5e),tual :niailh.er

.0Q11 personallY observ~d this condu~t.

OIGQ-004977

b6
b7C

"

D iI observed detalnee(s) In a ,condition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

b.

c. o rOetainee(s) told me that this conduct had 'occurred.
d. 0' O~hers' who observed t~i$ conduct described it to m~.
e. 0 I haVE;! relevant Inf9rmation <;Iassif!ed ClbovE;!, "$ ECRET" •
f: 0, I nev.er:ob$~rv.ep thls'c~:md,uGt.nor hearp 'abqu,t it .fralT) $omeolle:whp did.

Piea~e. p"t6vf~e 'th~ ~pptb,~imCite time rr~rile durfng, whi~.h t.hTs cotlOJJ.tt dC,¢lJrred.
Frpm .08J2,OO,~ to 10j20Q3'
'000 Not ReCall

g.

11. The ,petainE;!e'(~) t,rt=qted )n ~l1iS 'tJay were )qcCltep, at .the time im
1, [if Guantariarno
20 'Iraq'
3D,Afghanistan

4 0 Other location

?0

Do. N9t R,eq'lll

i:. Pleaseddentlfy the"detainee(s) by name and. nim'lbe'r::
Qnknqwn

j. 'PI~as¢ iden~ify the, p~'rsQrt(s) wfiQ trgate'd" the. ~etain~~(s)"
and g6vernment ag,~i1cy(les}:
assumed Army
-

'name(s)

in thi$ mCmn~rT in<;luding th:~ir
' .

k. Please. id.entify':any oXher· FBl per5t>hr'iel 0t' non-fBI w~rsonnel:who;,observed detalnee(~) treated
in this manner, induding their name(s} and ag,ency(ies):
PQ,sslqJY r'PY' ~SA,

i. Tnis',:c;ql'lduct :bccJJrr~d in cQnneo:lbo ,with:

i0
2: 0
3
:4

a
0

.Qn¢ de,t9ir(e,~
SevE:jral d~tajli¢'e~, (4-4)
Many' detainees {rr\ore'than 4}
Do Not Recall

.rfi. (DPtional) Please deSttib'e the::rl::ilevant circumstances in 'more~detail:

I.h~lIev.e we w.ete .tala df ro:m6t~ 'dfstrlp,rQ'utlnes; li.e-rtdtrried In fhont 'of d:et~in~~s' as part -of our'
first bn':ef. We-Were told not.to have' any inv61vemeritwlth it.
57-. Hold-ing'detaine-efs) Who
,detaihjhg the perSon,'
,
'<;I;

0

were not officialty"ackno,wl~t1ged ,or registered as such by·the,agen'cy
.-

.

I p~rS0naI.lY qp~~rved tbis ,<!Ol'!qu!=~.

I?:, 0 I ob~rveq.d~t~inee(s) ina cpnditi-on that le~ me to believe that this,conduct
c. D Detain,e~(s) told me that this. conduc,t \lad occurred.

b~ occurred.

OIGQ-004978

.

I

D Others. who observed thIs conduct described It to me.
e. D I have rele)/ant information classified Clbo)/e "SEtREf".

d.

f.

0

(n~ver,Ob5€lrv~d this'conduct nor heard about it from.some0m~,wh~.did..

58,. ~~n~:fing a cfetail'1~ tP. a.o't;ltber coun~ry fo~ more~ggn:~ssl've interwgation
..

.'

.a. D I personally..6bse.rved this 'cohduiZt.
D I observed detainee(s) in 'a·.c'ond ition that led me tb believe tnat'this cOnduct hi3dbccurreo.
e. 0 D,etainee(s) told me that this conduct had o.ccln'red.

b.

d.

q

e.

0 I have rerevarit Information classified abov.e \!SECREf'l.

f.

0'

others who. 0bserved this conduct described it to me..

I, l.'leven:>b~el'Yed this :cond.4<;,~ nor ,hecml abc;mt it ·from 'Sorneomn~ho e!!d.
:

,~9. ThreC'!tt=nlr9 W s.~nq '? ~et<il!n!=.e ~o' another cb!-ln~ry for det~lJ.tI9.n,or:l1Jor~·agg res~l\(e: int~r(.6gati9n

D II persat'l?\t1yobserved this ,conduct.
-a,b. -g-ji::~bserveti
detainee(s) I~ a:cond Ition that led me to believe 'thanhis cO.liduct had ,occurred.
e~

d.
e.

0, !D.etaihee(s) teilo me that this conduct had ,dccurb::rl.

D ;athers who'obserVed :this conduct described ino me.
D II have relevant Information' classified above: I!SECREf".

f: Itt' iI, never'observed this;conduet nor'heard aboutit from 'someone who did.

;6,Q; Thre?,t~tring to t9~~ ~:n:;~iqn 9~fl'inst: C! .d~t~in~'e!5 f<il'rni\Y

a. 0 I persOnally oDserV.ed this :tbn(\uc.t.
b.. 0 TODserY~d detairie~cs) in 'a q5r\d itipnthat led me to Qelieve th~ntiis' conduct had 6ctthrteCl,
c; D tDetal nee(s) told me that this cof1d Ll.tt had .o,ccu fred.

D lathers- who observed this GofidiJct described it to me.
E 0 r naV'Errelevarit informa'tionclassified aOOye "SECRET'!.
f. 0 1 never observed thls:conduet nor heard about It from someone who did.

,d'.

,

.
OIGQ-004979

61. Othe'r treatment or action qcmslng severe ~mt;>tiona[ or psychQlogl~al trauma ~o a detainee

a. 0

r. personally obserVea tliis :condutt.
Lbbserv'ed:detalriee(sJ In a,c;:ond itioh that led me'to b,elJeve that this Coridu,ct had ,octUrred.

0..

0

,-t.

o 'Detainee(s)
ford me that this condUct had ,occurred.
-'-:-f
-'--~'-, -~,,~-,- --,~~~- ...,,-,
-------'-~.~._-.--~-'-.,.-

d.

o

Others. who observed this cc:mduct described it to me;

_

e. [j I have relevant I'nformatlon classified ,abov.e !!SECRET'\

t 0

I never observed this, ,conduct nor heard a.bput it from someone w~o did.

B2. 'Other religio,us~or sexual h9ras§m.eot Qr humifiatiqrfof $ d~tainel?:

b:.

0 I perSonally obserVed thiS.conduct.
0 ~,,:oosei'vetl.~etainee(sJ In ~,~e,6:nd1ti6n'that lea ,me to. Belieye thaUt:iis conduct had6,Gcur'r~a.

c~

d, IDetalnee(s) 'fold

·a.

'd.

0

ille tlicit this ~ondui::t Odd .occur-reel.

OtherS, who'obser'vea this co,ndu¢t described it to me.

e. 0 I hav.e relevant information' classified abov.e
f.

0

~'SECRET""

1. nev.er observed' this ,conduct nor heard about It'fromsomebne who, did.

6':$:. O~tJertre~tme.nt 6f'a d~tqihe'e t\1.aE'in'yolJ,roplnion w?l's.,unpr9(~~sJ.blJpl, \:lnd.uly npr~h <;>r agg,(es,siye,

:coel'ciV~,.ab.uslv~,

<ir unlaWfuf

a: 0' I personally' observed this conduct.
..
b. 0 I observed E1etalnee{s) In a'Gonditlonthat led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.
c. 0 Detainee(s) told me thatthis conduct had ,occurred.
d .. 0 Q-thers wIT0 obseryed this (;;qlJ<:Il!ct'qesCfi~eq it; t9 !'De,:
e'! 0 I have relevant fnrormatlon classified .above ·'SEem·...
f. 0 I never ob~rved thts·c9n.qlJGf'r19r.hea~d'a,bOlJ~ it :frQm~arneqn~ who did.
,

._

•

•

••

•

,......

~.

f

'

.. " ,

,

,

_rf\0,~~'@j'~'~.:'~::"':;

6~. bid you .o:bserv~ anylmp'~rsol1atI9n 'of F~I per~(jl1nel by ~nypne ouring an Intervl~iN pr'lhtermgG)t1on
'q,d¢taine~?

o Yes.

!l

'9f

<:> No

OIGQ-004980

65. Did ~tiy df:@inee. or bthf:~ person ,t~1I 'lOU t~at he or ~hf: had Wi~ne..s'~~ "t~~ irtlp~rsQliatiQr) of FBI
persoflriel'(n connection with detainee IntervIew or' Interrogation?,
.
. QYes' ~ No,
6S. Are ;you a~are'of any II,s~am" ,or :1'staged lo 'd.eta!nee. i.ntenti~s;Q.r ..iT)ter,:qgatio,,!s cOI1~octed 'f~r M,er:nb~T:S
Qf th,e'!,J..?; £Qngres? 9r their 5t.am
.
'0 y,e? '~. No.

a

b]. To yo~r knowledge, did any military or ilitellige[1c~ personnel 'ev~r d:eny: .or dE:llay F~I'C!Gce,ss to:a- ,
,qeti;lir.re~ the: FEH want~C1.td ,qu~iol'J because. ttle 9!=tpine~.Ii'cfd~S\lstairf~d Injl,l rie$ ,after' he ,was capt\.,lreq?'
.
9'(e,s' 0 No

dYes. '0 No;
69. Were YQ.!J E;V~rtQ.lcj itrq'~;,a-n9.,th~r. FBI :ero p,lqyee ~nd&ll)i~ or h¢f ~artl~lp~~IQrr In Ql' ~h,serjlpt't911 ~f;,~
,defainee interview. ,or fnte'rr.og:atio.'rl' rectl,use. of the: interv,iew ,dr interrogation :methods. b.ein,!l ,lised?'

Q.Yes' ,0 No

79. rlurjng ;:Joy of YRu,r'Qy'~r,s~a~d~p,19Yl'TJe,nts,qr ~s~Jg rlrnent~, di~ yql!
any 'd eta rnee.:iri t¢f'/iew Qr i'riterrogatiQn

,s,uperilis'or?

.

repgrt ~nr. c;onC!~.r(lsTeg?r~jfng
practices~ :Pf ,o,tber typ~s :Qfd'ef~ itl,~ .tre.a..troe,nt,i. t'q-arr ,FBI

Q:Y..es
0 NG:
71. P,u rl ng .any '<j?f 'Yo\W9ve~sei3,s' c;I~pJ9YlT!er.m~ qr Cl,SS[g11 men't~/ i:l id 'YPI,I 'r~p'prt any '<;on~~rn s· r~gprdlng
~fr'ty .detC!.!r1~ irit'erv'i.e~ Qr"int~rr(,igc;jti9,ti p,@<;;tic:e% Qt qthenYP:E!?:'9f'(:i¢rEiin~~rep~(ngh1'y.91,l
db.senfE:d or heard about, :to·a nori-FB,I supeivi~or or ot.h~:r rjon-FB,I.p:er.so)lriel?

,

7.,2,. HQ'\Ie,Y0l;! :~\{er bee!)' or~er:ed

Q,Yes

8r~VreGted 110t-to r~polt or,,~:Ii~courag~d

·o_bsery~tiQI1.S pr alr~g~~i9ri'~relat$(f

p.r,aq;ices?

~ No: .

,tA 'det9,jrie~J:r~i3tJ)1~nt

in ClfPl W,ay' fr~rrr rep,orti'ngr

~r intervfew. Pf int~r(O~Cl'tio'n 'ac;:tipfI"!i:,qr

n Y..¢~: ,0, No

'

73. Have. you iexperienced-any actual or threatened retaliation for reporting observations,br allegations
af .detaln.ee'tr.eatmen( Of In.tery)~w .ar Int,errogatlo,n, a.~ions or. prac~Ices?)
.0. Yes ~ No'

'74. (Optional) Please iw)y.lde any'addltlonaJ comments regardJng the reporting,.of concerns related tet
in.fervie\y-' or ihJeuog atiol) ~edinjq u,es; d~,~enf!<?'3 practi~es.l or ·,<?ther ~et~.ii:le~ tre~.tfTlelJt. Ba~.ed ,9'0.
my o~.s~rva~!(;m?'ahOob!?~,rvatIOI1$'9i ,o~hersr I 9Q not .b~ll4e\fe thal many of ~h~ ,nqry':FBI ag~n.c1e~

w¢re ~oncju(;:,thig very.:effe'qiye intervi~W?

NQLdJJeJQ'urie!hi~1 prijc,tic~ b,llt tp iri1:Omp.~tent

InterVjeWir\~ skills,

OIGQ-004981

IM~ ~~.

D'

JUO

. 7.5. WereYQu: debriefed, other than the,standat.d debrief in FD-772, c.oricernlng ,you'r oVersea-s
assig nment(s) ·or, dep lo:yment(s) after ·you. com pleted the.d ep loyment(s) or ,assig nment(s):?;

O'Yes

·0 No

76., Additional r;:omlTlent~.~,od R,eooJUmenQgti(;>n~:

OIGQ-004982

 

 

The Habeas Citebook Ineffective Counsel Side
Advertise here
BCI - 90 Day Campaign - 1 for 1 Match