Department-of J~stic.e Inspec~o.r General Questi,onnaire Re9..;;fr.din~ Detain~es;
D.OJ,-:OlG INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONNAIRE
FORJtEVIEWAND USE dNLY BYINDIVIDUAL FBI ItE'SPONI>ENTS
. "
QP NOT FP~WA~O OR Dt$EMI~ATE
. ,

QUESTIONNAIRE 10: test-O.O_0019'3$'
As of ~l1e la~Uime this·qu~.~j'oiln~ire.was sa~~dr s~me r~quire.d (ields: hav,e n9t ~e~n c9mpletel;1.
Please review'your resp'oris_¢s.

~m.~',
".

<

-

~

'.

'~',

. '

•

;,

P.lease provide the following information ~
1. F-it:st liam¢:

4. Enter..e'd bh DotY Date' (EOD):

,~&,7(; PERAC?REEIYlf=tJT
Ii & 7C PER AGREEMENT
6 & 1.C PERAGREEMENT
6. & 7C

':J; Cur.r.ent 'Olyislcmlffeld Office:

~ ~.7C

:2.

MI<;lgle !nlt!~r:

3': Last name:,

'

A~sist?lnt Direc~9.~
6. & rc.PERAGREEMENT.

6! Curret:lt job ti.t1e:

-7. Direct,dial office "telephone nU'mber:
8" .FBI ,<:~Ii 'phqne ,hlJmb~r: .
9. f'~.t p<;lger nutnber:'
19.· r:3e?~ cqntact nur:nber for you:.:

~ iI.. 76 fER.AGRJ;EMENT
f; "($.,70 PE.RAGf(E.EMEN,T,
'6 & TC PER AGREEMENT

B·o B'ackground of Specific D,e-ployn'iehts Or Assigtmtents
11. At any tiri)e a'fte"rlSep'tember ill 20.01, aid you s'!=fVe as a member of the u.s. Military r. or as an
e;mployee or c:::ontractor of the fBI,or.any dtherg.overnment agencYr at Guantanamo Bav.".ClJba; Iraqi
:
Afghi;l.ni.stCln; 'or irrareCls;'qmtrolled Q'f the W:S:. M.ilitqlY qr a V.S. i!1!!=II!ge,Il~~; 5~r~tce !rrC~,nr:r~c~i0IJwith)he:

'gI9ba! V){~r on t!=rrol?

@

Yes 0 No

~;2. E'nr!=r the ,number bf tir'n.e,s, you, W,~r.e.,d~pJQy.~d or:cjs$i,g n'ed t6'l;lach' -Of theJoJloWing lo:l;;aU,olis
.(Guantanaino Bay, 'Cuba~lraq>;,Af9hanistan; or in -any areas controlled b{the.U..s. Military ·01' a US.
intelligence seriic.e~~1.
.
.
For.each deployment ofassifjnl11ent .complE!te'the followiT!9 section.
lo.ca.t,io,n rsel~ct,' one)
, DeptoYm.~.nt,or a5signnierit'b!,!g~n ~i! or
De~liiiri1.ent$lr:a,s~ignment,en>dei! on.
(

'

..... ,

II~~9t

"

-

abo.o.t. '

,-

or abqu~,

.

11/13/20.03'
12a. W'ha't wa_s the gen:e(a:l.nat~,r~~n>d p:t,lrp'Q!i~Qf YQur'assiglilJlenJ ~hcta!=J:iv(ti~s?
FBI On ,SCene C6hilrrander/B~QhdadQperations C,enter
09/11/20'03'

lib. Please provide..the'names ,of the:specific,camps, bases/ or facilities where you worked.
T!1rpqghout \he Ira,qi Th~atre})T 6,peratio[Js but ml;1stly Baghd?l~ 'Wh~re Ol!r main poc;lywa.s establish~~L
Agent$ under ,my ',$Li p~rvi~i9il int~rView,t;i:I detarne~s ~J pet~ntion vefl~es, throug nb,ut '~r,aq ,b,ut roaQstly j'n
tl)¢' Ba:,ghdpd alid r"'I!J~uJ area?
"
<
12c. Nofe: If information about a;specifit camp" base, or facility is classified above SECRET,
please:check here 0~inClude in yaur-answer that you hci\te."additional information.c1assified above

OIGQ-005393

'SEtREJ,'" and, if you knc;>w, Identify the c1assificatiol) .fe"el, ticket! compartment, pn;mram,' or other
d,esignation thcit,appJie"$ to'theinformation. Do not inelupe the ad,d,itfonal cJ<1ssified information in,your
qliestionnaire resp.ons,es; DIG personoelwith the necessary ,clearance will contact you to receive it.
Nam'e,

Position
,Larl}' Mefford
AD em
;12e., Did you joihtly interview, or interrogate
detainee with non-FBI personnel?,\j
'
Oy"
t:\N
',es
~
0

'
----------------------------------------------------------------------.
.any
•
~,2f~ D1p~~ujgj~tly ~~~~i3~Y' ti~tSJ1n~~ i~t~Jitie~-'{;r"7i~i~~r~g;tio~ ~strate9Y: ;pj;rli~e;,
:FE~I per~nn~l?

I

I

""ar t;~i;;- ~ith '~~--~'
•

• ~ Ye?

Q No

';'Wi1:h ~h~t- kinds' of no~-'FBr per~,~';el' did Y9~ ~o~k j"'al,nfly,1'
: 0 CITF

,: gr 'Other LJ.~. MJlitary
;. 0' u.s. inteiligen·ce. agency

.: 0' Foreign military o'r iriteiligent~ ag~ncY

:: tJ Otoer
.

.

'

.:.. -

-

-

__ -

-

-

-

-

-

__ -

__ -

- -

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

_'_ -

-

-

-

-

-

__ -

-

-

-

-

-

-

_,_ -

-

0_,- _,

,_,

,

_

.12g. Were,y:ou ever otherWise ihvolved in det2iinee.Jnterviews,or interrogations with nbn-:FBI personnel? ~.

~.

- -'- -- - - - - .... - -.--.-.- -.- - - - - -

~'---

B~
- -Ofu
- - - - - - -.-..-.-- -.-.- - - - - -- - - - - - - -. - - - - - - - - _...... - -- .
'.
" -;,f'."

';..

"

lA-. Train'jng' Prior to 'Oversea's D_eplpyment ()r Assignment

n. Did you receive any,training, instruction, 'or:guidanee specifically, in preparation for any of your
'9versea.s d~ploymel")tQ qr,assjgnme,ntsy'

0Y~s
ON'Q
ODq r~ot RecaJJ
ljq. Who: provic;I.~c! 'tQjs ~f?lif.lingr iJ:lstrudion;:or g,uid~T'!c~ralJ,cllJVn!='red,ip Y9,I,I 'c~q~ive i~1
S.C Frank Battle"and Unit.Chiei
FOordinated .a :day of briefings at:Q.uantico
13b. O'e'sGribelhe s'ubjem on which 'you reeelVed this·tr:ainin9,. iristructiQh .or gliidance.
mls,!1iQo _d~,scrip.ti6ri·" Cult!1.ra] i.$};ues, k~ing ~9Mj~.iQllS, h¢a.lth .<fild ~f.¢W"I~5Lie$,
pl'oc.!edu res:'and lYrotbebls.

.0Ves·

.

.

ONo

b6
b7C

'.

'0Do Not Recall

15. In t>r.eparcilion' Jor any 6fYQurovers~~s.d,epJoyments.pr .pSsigl:lIti~hrsrdid :you ieceivea.ny training,
, irisfrlIction,.or 'guidance .concerning the' st1mdard 5, Of condild a'pp Ikable to'lhe treatment,
interview, or fnterrog.ationof detainees by non-FBI personnel?

O¥es

€INo

:009 Not. R.~ca\1

OIGQ-005394

16. In preparation-for any of your over!3eas deployments or assignments! did you receive any training,
instruq:lon, or'guTdan~ concerning wha~ you were suppo~ to de;> If'YPl.,1,ob~rv~d 'or heardabo~t
-the treatment, 'interview, or in'\-errQgatjonof:detain"ees by FBI personnel" whi~h YQU b:eJiev~ JQ
lfe Inapproprrale~, UIip'rdfes~ioli~I" c,oer.¢lve! abO'slve, or urllaiNful.?-

'OYes

eNo

"000 NofRec'ali

1Z,1n: prepa~tlql1 fqr <rny bf.yourove:r~ea's deployments or,asslgnme'nts, did you recelVe:any tr;3ln!n~r
in·str.uctil:inr.9r-9W id'cmce ~onceming What ypu were sLJPPQ'sed to do if YQU 'obserye~d :or h~a(d ~ab]J,ut
tl)etr:eatnient, 'intervieWr or interrogation of detainees bY hoil~FBI pe'rsonhel, whie;h yow peli~ved
to. be. ina pproJJriate( unprIDfessiDnal~ coemivB, Clbusive~, or unlawful?'

.0.00 Not,Recall

B. Training, O'uring Over,seas. Deployments or Assignments
18'. Duri'ng :any :of yoiJr.overseas de'ployments or assig nments r d iCl you receive any training, instruction,'
Or9uidance:-C;:0fl~~milJgtN~ standar~ts 9f'~QI}~4ct appltGa.ble t~the tr~~I11~~t, !nte~i~i oJ
intern~Qatipn ,of dei:aint=.e's by FBI- ~r:~pnnei1

X!lY~
'QNo
00<;>. i'.'Jqt~e~aJl
is,a, W~h9 provld~d thi~ tr?iO)ng;-lnstruGtlpn; 9.f'.guid.a.m::e1
~nneit recall but.someone in OGC was, CDnsult~d re"use. of adviEe of rignts'form for
ov,ers~s,q,-!stg~i.alrnt~rViewsilJ ca5~?,~hStt hap ,the PQ~sibliity of th,e tar,get being
~ubJect~ tQ us pn::ls.e.clJtlpn.
'
,
lal:>, i3ri~Y'd !=!SGfiQ~ the sli,bstanc~ Qf th~',trai(iing, Jnstruc~i(;>n, or gliid~ncf=: P.fovi~ed to. Y9lh
,VVs: were adv(ser) tGrcon,sider'tlstng C:ln ~rater..fitorial advlce~'of ,rights fQ!JTI.
18c. Was any 0.fthe,"trainin9.( instruction! 'of gUid'ance provided in"w'riting1

OYes

'eND,

'Q rilo' N~t R~c;:~11

19~ Dliringany :of your o.verseas, deployments or assig nmeiits, did you receive any trainiJlg , rnstruC:tiori~"

oTYl!i~ance cOflcerllilJg tlJe'stand,qf~s of condu.~.':appli~ab!e t~ the trecjtrnentj int~rvlew; qr
in!errqgation or detai.ne.e~ by non-Fal' p~~onri~l?

'

-ayes
'20. During any ,of-y0unwerseas deployments or assignments, ditl you receive any'training" instruction,
'g['g~i!=lan~econ<,;ernin,9wh~t ypu were'~JH~PQs_ed ,tod.o if ,you obs~rved'Qr /1e~rd ,a~Q.u~:th~·
'
tr~a~mentr jn~erJii=wi or Interro.g~tign'9.f ~et.aln~es by FBI per~nn¢I, whic,h Y9l,! ~~lie.V~d 'tq ,be,
in'approp[iat~f/ unpJ"ofessional" c6.erciv~,. abusjV.~f' or ufllaWt'u[J

OYes

~No:

'

Qop Not Recall

..i L p\JrJng 'pny -or YQtl.r overseas, g~p'IQYrnent~ or a?s.ignment~7,d'ip yQl! rec~lve ~.ny t.rqining i, in.sffl.lctIQn/
,orguid,pnc,e con~~rriing What Y9U Were~s\1i)p.oS~ ~¢ ,de if YQ.u obse,r\ieR 'Qrh$r.d ab~!Jt the:
treatment" intetview~ or interrogation' ,of.detainees by lion-FBI p~rsonnel, WhIch YoU beljeved to
be inappropriate, unprofessional; coercive; ,abusive); .or unlawful?

OIGQ-005395

OVes

bDo Not Rec9"

0No

IGo A:d~:quacy of Tr~ining
22. Iii' 'yQJ.lr opiniOli, ·dld· yoU (eceiv~ :adeQl,la~e

trcHnlrig,. in~~r.uctic)fiT or guid.anc.e r~Ta~'ing to s.ta.nd.ards
oJ CondUct by FBI:atfd non~FBr persdnnel relating to'treatmemtr interview1 or lrite'rrogatl6n of
detainees prior to your deployment or assignment? .

0yes
23/1.0 Y0uropinf<;m, did y'ou

0

No

rec~iveadequate training[ in.struqiorVDr .9l!idan~e rel~~ing.So staop'arqs

·0.f con.duct hy.. FBI'and non-FI;\I 'p'ersQnnel -relating to trea~men~r interview; or iriterrogfltion of
:qetqlre~sd.udng your dep1oymelit.dr.assignmE=nV

0·Y~

Q No

24-. In your op i nion( i:I id you rec;;eiv.e :ade'q l,.lat~ fra ining I iDstruGtiQn T' or guidanae .conc;;erni ilg what you
were supposed to .do if you ob'served 0'r Heard c:io6ut lhe treatrri.erit~ interview, or·ihlerr69,atiOri .of
~.etalneesr by: FBl-or I}o.n-FB~ per:sonnel, tbat you b~lIeyed was Inapproprlate.r uoprofesslonal;
;cQerciYe. ·abusIve, or unlawful?
.

~

... _ ........

..

·0 Yes '0 No .......

'" ... ,. ." __ '_.,> .. '.. . _ ... _ '" ....... -. . . _ ..... _ ..... ... .,., . . _ ...
~

.,

.... __ ...

,*

...

h

..

,..

""

.........

_

..

_

........

__

..

_

'

'was

.2i4a. Please describe the ways;ih which you believe lhe :hainin.g> instnlCtlon,or'gl1idarice
inadequate:
. . . .
I/w~;wa~jwer~ not. fami!iarizeo with .rnill~rY pr OGA p,ro,t.QcQls)parplJ1~ter-5; If! othefWQrds itW.otilc;l
hay¢; b~.n helpFUl to I{now tile' Qth:~r~gMCi~.5'rules:and pr9G~i:I9r~s,® W~ GQUld hay~ l:j~en: ~bje 10 .
identify'what conduct eroS-sea tbe.lltre, We khew our own proceC1ures:atld adhered to.th'em.atJd
assumed they were the sameas-the pmd.edures.we:wQuld use in the.US .. AS bsC I reminded the staff

_9f"~h)~~~p~t~!i~I!.~~ i!Jterxal~.: Y1..e.. ~i':9P'1Y ]\~fL:n~ !~a!T!e_ ~f.S~f~~~Eg~ !o!~<!lhe! .9!J~~c~~~.

:

25. (OptionaI1:In what ways can the FI3I Improve training on this subject for future deployments 'or
~ss.ignments?

Fat

A. fuJi 'pQd ~horqugh ses.sfqfl ~W Irferview pro~ocoi~ for the
persqm.lel ~l,lring Q.ver~~~ qepI0ymen~~r
and :additionaf trainirt:g ~on o,ther ~gency.protocois. Mo.re trainIng on.bl:!'eratintlVVith the :military in~a
.
.
rtliliti:li"y/war- zolie 'efivirbriment.

I..

100 .Commeot~
26. PI~se. provide9ny ad(Htf(;ma'llnform~tio.nq:>ncerning tGljning fQr o.ver~~~ p.E=pIQY\llerits~or
a$s:ig r'lm~ri~s' of F~l p¢rsbr\MI yqu h~li~ve is r~levailt,

~:~."'."
, ..••

. ":;'~fH~~@§'~~~:_'::'

,.~''" ',.'_~.' .~·'~·~,,~,l. ,.,',·<'<.';A'. .... /:::·.:.,.~~·,:,

or

.Il1fro.4uc.tjon to .part III; In: th'i~ s~tlon;; we .are:seel<ing. lrformatlon regarqing a wJ9~· range
int~iijreVl! :OJ interrb(iciJkin techniQu¢~ and other Wp~ of deta'inee tr.eatment :alleg.ed to hav..e occu rted.
You should .Mt ClS'surrl'er just b~use.weare .asking about a pi'lrticiIlar teclinique or practice, that we, have
·conclud.ed that it in ·fact occurred. We recog'liize that.some of these techniques.or practices meW at times

OIGQ-005396

b~ necessqry for safeW and. security In a·detention settfng. to' adc{"itioJ!r. .we re€ognize that some of these
lechnlqlJ.el?, ,q'~ pr;;iCtice?,: may' :haye be~n authprlzeP for u~e' I:>Y milit~r{ qr other government pers9nnel.,
-

..

"

.

'"

Witli respect to .eacn R1entified technique" practice"or. type ,of, conduct-described belo.W, we are seeking
information about its occurrence during or in connection'with the interview'or interrogation of a
detaineer.,or d4ring the ~ete!ltion:of'a'p~t~inee'b~Y9nd wh~t is,n'e,~d~d for s~f~ty anc;i se:c;:urity:
In' that ',C.Qrit~t, We. wiIJ I3sk you to tell !-IS wh~ther ojie or' mQr~ j:lfthe foll(jwin~ ;Statenteiit.~ are tn,le:

1. I personally observeD this ,contluct.
2~ I'observecf,detainee(s) in a condition that led'me to believe that ,this. conduct had 'occurred.

~.. Ell=t?lin~{$.) tqlq m~, that thls:'con~ucthCld 0,q::urr!=9.
4. Qthers'whb' observed; this condU'Gtdescribed it to me.
.5, r.'hav~ r~l~va:ni irtfPrtn~,tiPn dassiffed ~bove;I;$E.CRET";,
:6. I never obsewed this condUct nor Iieardabout 'it from someone:-wlio did.
.
.
--.
:2}; D¢privIOf]:p ,d~t~rr\~ bf'fqotl or wati=r

0 I perSonal!y obse'l'\Ied this ·cbnau.ct.
b. 0 I bbs,etv'ed .t1etCjJnee(s) In 'a.cond iti0hthat led lTie' to, belleVe thanhls conduct. had .occurrea.,
c. 0 Detai,l'lee(s) told me that this cond utt had 0'GCUtr.ed.

a.

d.
e.

f.

o.

Others, who oliserVed this cCindud described it to tne.,

.0 II- hav.e relevant information classified above, 'fSEtRET\
0 ['never'observed this 'conduct n<!r heard about'it from someone who did.

a. o ,I per.sol'1al!y' (jb~l'\I~d' this ~oii(luct.

I

.,

tb.

0 I observi='d,oetaii1e~(s). in'.a cqhditjon that led me to b~iil~ye J:hauhl$ cohQUl:t Md ·o¢curt~d.
Ie. 0 Detaln~(s)
told 'me that this' tond u'ct had ,occurred.
.. ...._...--.
...
.
..
... --.........--.'d. 0' Others wboobsefvedthis conduct aescribed it to: me:

-_

_

.---.~----------

e.

d r have relev'a'n't information Glassifiea above. ~lgECREf'!.

f.

~ 1. never observed' this '<!onduct nor heard 'about it from .someone who did.

''2.9. Deprrvi(lg~"detainee

of.sleeprJlr il]t~rrupting $J~.¢P b'}' frequ>~nt:celJ 'relocations or Qtb~r m~tn.ods

0 r persoriaJiy 6b.~rv~d niis ;cQriai.J.c~.
b. 0 r'ol:5sef'£~d detaine¢(s) in';:I ,cotid.itibn that led

a,

.-

me; to b~}j~ve ~hqt thiS condupt .hap 'o,ccurr~d.,

OIGQ-005397

,

c. D !Oetalnee(s) told me that this conduct had 'occurred.
d. 0!Others who observed this conduct described it to me~
e.

'f.

II' have relevant information ~I~ssifi~ agove "SEGR,E)I'"
o !I never ob~rve,d ttiis'Cof)~u~t,norheard about it frQm~~rnebne·wh().~id.
D

g. Please provid'¢ the ~pproxirn~te tim,e fraine guring wl)ich thfs cQridlj~~ o'q:;u'rreP.
Fmm 09/11/20.03 to 11/13120,03.
000 Not. Recall

h\1.he detclinee"(s-)

tr,eat~ In thi,S

WaY were Iq¢at¢~ at the tiiTl~:in:

1 Ll Guantanamo

20J~q

30 Afgfianistan
'4 0 Other Location
5,0 1;>0 Not Recall
I. Please Identify ttie,detaln.ee(s) b,y~narh'e.Clnd, number:
'general description of use of this technique. but not specific to an ind ividual detainee.
'j. 'Please identify the, p¢'rsqots) Wh'0 tr'eaj:ed, tf\l~.p,ej:a.inee(~) in thi~' rna,rYner, i1idudin'g thelr

name( s) a'nd ,goverririJenta{:iehcy(ies):
'GIAjMilitary:Intelligence

'"

~. Please identify' any' other FBI personnel ejr l1on-FBI personnel who observed deta'iriee(?) treated
in this manner, Including their name(s) and aQem:y'(ies):
'
unknQwri
'

'I, This;/:;qnQ\Jci: .oc<::urre¢l iiJt:;:~m.h~p:ibn w.itH:
':I, ,0 ·Ql1e <;fetain¢:e
20 Se;v¢r.al p~tairi~ (2-4)
3. 0 Many"detainees .(m'dte than 4J'
4 '0, Do Not Reca II
m. (Qpti,onaJ) Please:descr'lb.e the'releV8'nt c;:1r.cumstanc;:es In'mored~tall:,

In di?cu,ssing interv-ievi.'of:de~a:ine'¢S."ii1 gen~.rciI terms with both MI and, f;.IA persohnel the
technique of "sleep mari'ag.ement:' was meritlonea frequently, 'I"can't-retall specific IndlvidUals<dr
names.

30.. Beating a' ,detainee
a~

0 r

per.50nally observ~d ~hls cqnduct.,

b. 0
c. 0

I 'O~?eJVep deti;line~'(s) fn .a·cor(c@onth?lt!ed me t9 ~~ney~ th~t tbis c;on:quet ha,d ,ocqJrr~d ..

d. 0

Others: who observed thi,s. cj:md!)ct d~scribed it to me:

Qetainee(s}tqld m~.thpt,th!s condl,lct

Mp

I

occ;:~rr~.

I

OIGQ-005398

..

e.

f.

0 I have relevant Information classified above '!SECRET".
0 r never observed this:conduct nor heard about it from someone who' did.

·31- Using waterto
a.
b.

0 I

e..

p~rs6nalJy ob~rv.ed thist'ondu~t.

.

o !IolJselYetl defainee(s) in a,condition' t.hat led 'me'tO- believe thatlnis conauct bad occlirrea.

c'. 0
·d.

pr~v~nt breathing by a qe~ir:r~ or to create 'the s~nparion ,of-qrowning

0'
0

Detainee(s) told me that this. c6nd'utt had ,ocCurred.
Others- who observed this (;ond ilct described it to me.
1, have relevarit information classified -above: !~SECRET"'.

f. ~, I never'observed thls;conduct norheard alJOut it from 'someone.who did.

a'. 0
D,

c,

0

I:' pe(sonallY
o.liserved this conauc.t.
,
~

-~

r'oDserved ·detciinee(s)· hi'a cond ition that led

m,e to b.elieve tl:iafthis ~onduct had ,o(icurrefl.·

o ,Detalnee(s) .told me that tHIS- eond u.ct had :6ccu rred.

I

d. 0 OtherS' who :observed. tHis co'rid (Jct described it to me.
e.

o II have releVant ir:iformatibrr tlassified a'bove "SECRET'!.'.

f: I~r I never observed this-conduct nor heard about'it from 'someone Who did.

3,3'. ThreatenIng other aq:ion'to"cause: phYSIcal' pain;, injurY" .drsfigurement~ qrdeath,
.a. o II pgrsonaUy ab~r:ved this ,conduct.
b. o II bbserv.ed,detaihee{s) itLa cbnd'itibrHhat led me to oelieve thauhrs' conduct bad .occurred.
C'.

'

d.
.e.

f:

o
o
o

!Det~in~(s} told lne that .this Gorid'uc[

had :occurred.

!Othet'S' who 'observed to1s cond Uet descrlbetl it to. me.

haVe relevant i'nfofmation classified above. "SECREf".
o II never- observed this'conduct nor'heard :aoout it from som'eol'Je. who aid.
II

OIGQ-005399

34. Othe:rtJealment of a\:tibb causing significant physical pe:jjn or injury, ,6rcausing,dis.figurement or
:death

o

a,

b. 0 r observed detqin~e(s) in a cQ[1ditign ~hat led me to belieye thgt tl:1is ~onduct
c. 0 pet~inee(s) tqld fTIe that this c.onduct had qc<:urreq,
d. 0 Others who .observ~d this CPtlduct aescrlbed It ~o me.
t;. 0 I have relevant jn~drmatjoh'da!?"'Sified abov,e "SECRET".
f. IEf r; n~",-er 9b~,rve~ thj~ condu.¢t npr h~r<:\ 'abflu~:!t from ,sotn¢,l>.ne wnq' did.

'3~.

Rla,clng a detalnee'po

I p,ersonqlly o.bserved tl)is 'conduct.

b',
c.·

p

Det~.inee(s}to~d me that ttlisC9n9W;:,t ha,droc;curred.

{!;

0

Qthers Wbp, 9bsel'Yed thi$ GRn~Jlct d.e.s:tri~~d it ~l;>: m~.

I:ops~rv~d-de~9in~'ets) In ,a'<;:~n9Ition-1i.hap led m~ to' b~lIeve; tn~t tnls cOrJPuct had 'g~cL!rred.,

.. 0,

~'

D

f.

hadocqfrced"

a hot 'surfac~ or burolng ,a detainee'

0
0

a.

I

l~ perSCInallyobserv~d this cqnd'uct.

t h~\fe re:l~vant lQ.form~tlon 'd,C'i$sifled ClQoYe' "'S,ECRET

n
"

1: nev.er 6,bsen[ed this:conCi.uc,t npr h~r.d abQ.L!t, it from sqttreone: who' did.

.9.. pieasa pr:QVlde ,the a'pproxiinate time fram~ during WhIch ;thlsJ::ondutt,bccurred.
DpQ NQ~ Reca,ll
From 09/1.1/2:003 t6:U/13j2003<

The .detainee(~J tr~teci
1 0 '~LJatitanam6

,h.

io :this iN.ay wet~ Idtatea ,at tfi'e time 11):'

20' Iraq _

3D Afghanistan
0 .Othe'i location
.....

4

~

'.;

0

,

~

p~ N~t R~g311

i. Plea~e fd!=ntii'y the:det?lin~(s) QY n.alTl,~ ana n.um~er;' .
!J,n kn9W!1
j. ,Please identify :the \:>~'f~6ri{s)whb treated the detalnee(s) in this: man Het, illcluding their
name( s), and .government age'ncy{Ies.).:
'
. .
c1a~i!it.;d
.

. k. Please Identify, any:other· FBI personnel or non-FBI' personnel who. observed detaIAee(~) treated

'In .fhj~ (nClnner;, in(;luai.og fheir m;lm.e(s) and agen~y(ies);
UriktioWn

I. Thl&'cbhduct .occurred IIi ,connection with:,

:)., 0

-Orie detalhe~

OIGQ-005400

2

0. S,everal detain~ (2-4)

3 Q Many, d.etaine'es (more than 4)
4 0 DQ Not Recall
ill. (op.ii9n~i) Please,d~rib,e the rel,eyant,<:.in:l!mstances, in mqr,e tiet;;!!I:

Det~iriee'-Wa.s pla~ed 9,h:~ hq6~Of

a V~hlC;:,I\9' an9 ,tli?nspqrted,

engine. This info, was.relay,ed to me

H~

by a prior QS'C:and SA from

re1;¢lve:d .severe' blJ rns; frqm the
tne CTD fly tecfm.

~36, thing shqckl¢sor QtlJer r.estrCllnts in a prolonged tnanner
,

a: D r: personal.!y,obser:ved thls,cotJduct.
b, 0 I observeddetciinee(s.) in a ,contl.itio,h. fhat led me t6 believe thafthis conduct bad .occurred,
c.

D

0
e:. 0
f. 0

d.

Detainee(s),told me that this conduct had 'occurred.
Others who observed thIs cenduet descrfbed It to me,

r: ~av.e relevant fnf,Qrmation. c!assifjed a~ove "SECRET"',
r~~v.~r obs~rved:thj~'-<':<?(lqqc! !19r'h~,rd a.bout !tfrolT),sQrneon~'wno ~iQ.

2i7:. ReqlJirirt~:a ,detq'inee:tQ r::nainfCiiil, pr .re,stralriing a :detain,ee in,

a, D
b, 0
c. 0

~

persanaUy' obserVed

,shes~ful.Qr

p?llflful

pqSiHoO

this.'coridutt.

~. observed defaiiiee(s:} in ~~cond iOon that led' me tet belie'iie that' this eomlt..iCt had "occurred.
,

Detainee(s) told Jnethat thiS corid'i'cthad ,occurred.

d:,

q

e.

D ~ave relevant information classified a'bove '\$EtRET".

others who observed -this conduct described it to me.

f. 0. r Ilevero,bser\,(ed thIS cOl)d~G~

3'8,

<;I

Fotdng' ;(;l,det;:ilrie¢ to p-erfqrm

'

n9r h~rd,abo~t ,t{rom'sql11e~ll~'wbodjd.

c,Iemc,ll)dJng...2::..:.h:Lys:;,,:..!c.:..:a::.:,l-=ex:o..:.e.=(I-=c.:;:ls-=e

_

a. D fr pei:scinally' .obserVed this ,conduct.

0
e. 0

b..

'd.

Lobserv~d

de'tainee(s) In a cOl1d.1tlCiri that led m~ to believe t.hat,thls conduct had .Qccurrep.

I

Detaihee(s}fold me that this conduct nad occuri:erl.

o jOtherS wh6 ebserved 'thiS conauCt i1es-cribed if to me.

OIGQ-005401

.

- ..

.,

[1 [~f 11 never observed this conduct nor heard about' it from someone who did.

;

I
!

I

39·. llsing electric;:af shock.on·a de~ainee

.a. 0

I per.sonally observed this conduct.

0 I bbse'rV,e9 detair'u;~e(s) ifl a cond ition th'at led m¢' to beli~ve that this con.duet ha.d occurred.
c; 0 Detainee.(s) told -me that this conduct had ,occuYred.
,
.d. 0 OtbetS' who .observed this tbna ud described it to me.
I
e. 0 r have relevant information Classified aboVe '.'SECREf",
f: ~. I never observed this'conduct nor heard abQut. it 'from.someone who did.
b.

;

:4.0•. Thr.eatening to use electrica.! shock on a detqinee

,

a. 0 I" p:ersOfia.LI'l;ob$'erv~c;I this,:CQn.t1.uct.
b. 0 l' ohserv-ed a.etain·e.e(s)'. in :a '.cotid.ition that I~ ni~ to' beli¢ve that' this cpnduct had occurrett
......
-b. 0 Detainee(s) told .hie that this conduct had .ckcurred.
d,

0
.e. 0
f.

oth.ers' W.h.b observed thiS' tend uct d.esctibed It to

tn~

I have'h~levant infarniation dassifiea aboye '~S·ECRETi\ .

;

0. II never·o.bserved. this.condud nor heard 'a bout. it frbm.·sorrieone who did.

-41. i:nten~!Qn~JIYgelaylr!9 'or .de.nylngg!=tain.~e·rnecfi~a'i r;;:are

0 r p~rsOr'iaIlY·6Qserve,cr ~hj's con'du.ct.
b,: 0 I ol1s~rv.e:d. detalne.e(s): jn ia 'c'On_d ition that led me to believe that this conduct ~adoc(:urred.
c. 0 De.taihee(s) toid me th.at this. cond u'cJ; hadO~.ci.Jrr.ed.
d. 0 OJhern: who bb.sehteili ,this c6rid'ud d:es~riD¢d it to' me.
e. 0 [ have releva'r'tt Information 'Classified above· ·~.sECRET".
I neVer' observed'
this'conduct nor heard
it from sorneohe:who ._J"'_
did. ......... ,.... _.... -- ..
f. .......
_......... _....
....... ........
........... --aboi.Jt
.. -- 0' _. .......... ...- ..
a',

~~

._

_~

~--

--~----""',,"

_

......

"""'-'>6

.."."

42. H0.0ding or blindfQ'lding a.detainee other tha.n during traris~ortation

OIGQ-005402
._-

b.

0
0

·c.

o 'D~~ajnee(s) told me that thi~ condl,let ~ad 'occurn~;L

'a~

I

I personally'observed thls,conduct.
I observed detainee(s) in a condition that led me to believe thatthis conduct had occurred.

0 bih~rs: who 'observ~d this c.ond1!cr~escribec! It to me~
e. 0
have reievant information classified above "SECRET".
.
... __ .-:..-....... -._- -------------_.
- --- ,..-..:......_--_.
f. 0' T:never observed. thi~H:Qn.duct nor heard ab9~t it from sojrieone'wh9 pid.
~.

.L.

'

43, SUbjecting

-_

-~-

.

a d~tajn.ee toeKtrem~iy cold 'or hOt room temp.erature.s for extended Rerlads

a. 0 I personallY observed this conduct.

b. 0 I'observed'detainee(s) In'a condition that led me to belle.ve that this Gonduct hail.occurred, .

0 Det~i.!lee(s) ~olcj rn~·that this. ~ofldu~t h;3d 'occurred...
g! 0 9tIJer:? Wn9 -ot1~ef:'l~q t,his, c0rrc!qGtq~$.crib·e9 jt to roe.,;
e.. 0 ~ h;:lve :rel~varit I.lJfOTn:rc~:t19,n <;la~?Jfl~ 9~9ve ",~·EC~ET·! ..
f. 0 I n~ver·ob$erv;e.cr thi$'conou~t nor h~.rd 'abptlt it frorn. s9me9t1e'who did;
Eo'.

'a', ~ ~ personally observed lhis eoMiJd.

b. 0 I ·observed detainee(s) in a .condition that led me to believ.e thatthis conduct had ·occurred.
c,

0

Detainee(s) told me that thisconduct'had :occurred.

i:. o IOthers who oQserved this conduct-l:l.~ser!ped it ~o me.
e',

0 I have relev.ant !nrorm~~for

ql,?~sifl~~ 'above "-Si:dJ{ET":

f·lD I" n~yeroQserv~:9 this conc:iu~t 'nor ,hear!J 'a/;lgut it :fro!J1 ~omeol1e wt'Jo did.

PI~:<;lse pltjy·id~:the QpproXim:~t~ ~im~ {tame 'Quring W.hi~.h ttii~t c(m~!-n;:~ ~t~urred,
Fr:On1 .09/1112.003. to. 11/1312003
. DDo Nol Recall
h. The qetafn~e($) treqteQ in '~l)ls w.ay w,ere' Jqc~te9 ~t ~h.e tim~ in!
1 0' Guan~anC;)mp

g..

i0 Iraq
3. 0 IA~gnanista'n
4 0 'Other Location
5 0 Do Not R~call

OIGQ-005403

i. Please identify the detainee(s) by' name and number:
'
Unknown
P'I~~e fd~ntlfY' the person ($) 'who treated the detaine'e(s) in this manner, incluglng their
ndme(s) ana goverrim¢nt agencY(i~s):
,Unknown r"lilitary per-soMeL
k. ,PI¢a5e idehtify any other FEn persoiinel or non-FBI personnel wh.Q ob~rved detainee(s) treated'
in this manner, iiiClliding their nEmie{s) ,and agency(ies) ~
HRT person nel" a~sig ne~ to,the FBI MosuI Oper?ltions' Center in

J.

I

b6

I

Mb'~YJ.

b7C

r. Th-is'conduct Qccurred in connection with:

1,0 'One. detajne,e
2 0 :Several detainees (2~)
,3 ~0 Many detairiees
'4 b DO Not Recal[

m.

{Dptional}

(mere than 4)

Please' describe 'the,,relevant circumstances in mp're"(jefail;;

'During la.r.g~ rouhdup aPIO or'mote"suspected ilisurg,ehts, and fO,r.eign fighters ,tlie ~etainees Were
held ,placed' in:a ,larg:e holding :area and (o'ud rock. riliJsl<:i:was played 'thro~g HoUl the processing of

'ttt~:det9rl,lees~th~,musiD was flot ex~essJve since ali tbqse present ":V~re; subject~ t9' i,~, inducHng

FEU

p.~r.spl1,n~1.

'45. 'Su.bj~ting a

d~ta.inee

tq bright flashing Iig,hts ,onla~kn~ss

a; 0 t p~rsQnally opserved' ~his conduct.
b, 0 I ob'se,rved detainee(s) in Xl condition that led me to bem~ve thet this cO'riduct ha.d 'oc~urr~d.
c.

b

d.

o ~otherS' whb Qbsented 'this cond act desc[ibed it to me.

g.

0 I hc'jye relevant informatibn :Classified ab.ove '~SECREf".
0 I neVerobseived thls whdlict nor heard:pbo:utlt from someone,wtio did.

f.

I

De.t:ainee(s),told me that thiS. cond Qct had ,occurrei:l.

16. 'Isolating a detain~ To~,ari extended period'
a. 0, t p~r$ptl~IIy'-Glb,~~IIL~r:I' :this·l:9-.n.dlie,t.
0" D I:~,bser'Yed detalrie~(s). !h:a .cqnd it)Qn1;\1at I~ tTf¢ to b'elie'i.~ th~t tHh~ GqJi.quq: ,hal:! ,oc~urr~d,

0 Detaine~(5) 'told riie il:iat this' Good U:ct 'ha,d ~6tq.IJ:rf:il'.
d 0 Others' who 61J'served thj~ condLJct d,~crib~ it t9. rri,e<o
..
e. 0 I: ha'\ie relevarit i,ilformation Classified .aboVe "SECRE~I".
c.

OIGQ-005404

f. 0

I never observed this conduct nor heard about It from 'someone who did.

g, PI~Clse p.royid~ th~ apprQ}<im<;lte tfme frame dl,lrln9. vthiC;11 this'c(;m9l1d:occurred,.
!1l1~riii63
Doo Not

.From' 09/11j200j to

h, The .deta.lne¢(sJ treated
1, [j Guantanamo

mtt)is way were: IQcated at the time in:

R"""Ji

.

;; 0 rreq

.

3. 0

~f9hanis~9.n

11- 0
50

Other Location
00 Not Recall

I. PI~.se;iCle}ltliyttw!,~d¢taii1~(~"). b;¥ nam~ 'cl'nd, nu I'D b~r;'
This was i:lisCllssed in geoeral. temis by ~fA a'rid
iiersonoel, On iiidividuall--,major Ansar.Islam leader refated·to FBI SAs that he was subjected to, Isofati&ii:

m

.

16
17<

..JF

'j, .PI¢ase. idenJ;ify the p,ers6r'f(s)"wh"Q' .treated' tfll::UI

ncin'te(s)·and government ai;J'e'ocy(les):
ClAfMiIi"tary Inlell!genre

. Ie. Please identIfY· ar'iy'6t~r. FBl persbnnel or bon:'FBI persorilJ'el :wh6,.obSetved detaflJeers)

tr~'ted

in this maMer:, includin~ their name{s) anti agen
I
li:l"n(i.~n IA frqm .eTD ,sent sp.ecificall.y1~~J~~ In in~erv;ewhi9 .thls ~¢t.~jhe~ after he
was m",de- avail.abl~ by ~he. c.IA.

I. Tllis,.c6nduct occurred in toime¢tiiin with:
1,0 One detairi~
2 0. 'SeVeral detainees. (2.~J
:3'0 Many detainees (more than 414 Q po ~9t ~~11

16
17<

ril. to:p.-il6nal) p[ease·descnOe t1ie'f.!alevarit drcUITistantes in more detail:

~e (Jeseribel:l isblatiOI"l·.arid sleep,dep'rivatloh tiy his previolls

Ourhig FBriiJteFViews:Wjt~
.hamCilers,
47~U.slngrli.iGt

D
~', D
<. D
d, D
e. D
a:

f.

b6

b7<

tape to resttcUn"gag, o'r punish a .detainee

[per~r:taUY ~lJs~rve~ ~hj~ c;~ndud.
I. o.b$e:rveq d.el~ine.~~{s) In a'€9Mitlonthat led me t9' t;lellev~ th~t·tbJs con9uct t)~'oc:qJrre'~.,
Oetailiee:(sj told. m'e thqt .thls cooP !Jet ha.d ·,occurred.
tptners' WI.1Q dQserv~ '~his'. C9nd~~t desp-l bed It to m~.
I have -relevant lnformatlorr ~asslfl¢d ,aIr"'

1<'1 I

,

,

,

n~er ~bsery,ej:f thIs :O:Hid!Jd npr h~rd abpO.t,itfrom sprrt~(me. Wh9. dl.d.
.. ,.

,

OIGQ-OOS40S

-45. Using rapid respo.nse teil'ms.and/or Fori;ed .cell extractions·

a, 0 r. persenally observed this .cqnduct.
b. 0 r""Ob~{ved. detClinee{s) in a'cond'itiQn that iecl me to bel.ieve that thi.s <;:ond,!JQ: n~
c, 0 D~taInee{sJ tolP m~ that this conduct hap oc;etJrretJ.
4. 0 Others who obseWed thl~, ¢pnpuct descrll:ied It 19" me:..
e 0 .have relevant InformatlotfclasSlfled ·~lbov.e. "S.E.CRET".
f. 0' n'ev,er ob.s¢'rv.E(d' this. cOnduct npr h~rd. abol,i,t it frpm .59mepn~,.wh9' Q.rd.

O<lcurred.

49. ,Using" 'a.-military worklng.dOg:on or neat a d.etalnee·;otber than (luring detainee transpbitation

a. 0 I

p~~.so.!1~I.Jy"@p~~c;1 U,lls:COflduct.

b. 0

I.:o.bsel:V~ QeJ~lil'}~e{s). in a'c.o~ ilion ~hat led Tp~..t9· b~liev~ thqlt t,l1is C;:9nPUq: .!lad 'QCi:ameq"

0
4. 0

Deta,i.nee.(s) tQl~ 'rne thqt t-ttis t9bc!.uct h~~ 'Ot;:CUfrfii.

C,

OtherS W~'9 "Qbsery~ thi~ €pn~uc;:!.d#crl~ it .to

me,.

e. D. J. ha~e releVan.t. ilJ(orm~Jion dassirred :above ".s:ECJ~ET''''
I. Il'! t neY¢r 6bsente'd this tQntlul=t flo.r h.ea'fd :.about it frQm.SQmeon.e wnQ oW,.

sa. TI:'Ireaterfrng to use rflllltalJ (\totklng dog's:on or liear a detaln~
a, 0

I Rer:;enally."o:~serve~ ~his "C;qnl~uc::t.

b. 0
c: (j

Lob~rve-q.de~'lnEj!'e:(s) In ~'cOndltIQI11ha.t

Qet<;lineets)' tql~ JTI~ ~,hat .this, cot)d.uct Ila.d Oq:ufI:e;i,

g. 0

qth~rs whp 9P$e~ ,~t1is, qm.~Mct.d~criQeq ~.

e. O.

[htl~e relevant IlJformat!on <;;1~sSlfled 'abq'Je "'SECREl'.

I. Il'!

i n~~r o,b~erved'thi.s·CCi_nduc;t n:or h~rd <;lOO,U.t. it' frbrrl"SQmeon!a whd did.

le;d me" to" believe tj:lat. ~hls condu.et h,?d

occurred~.

t<r me;

,$1. Using "Spiders, sti:5rjifQns', .snakes, or o.tner animals on br near a C1etaiilee,

'gD]r personalty observed this·conduct.

OIGQ-005406

b.
c.

o II·observed detalnee(s) In a cand itlon that led me to believe that.thls conduct had "Occurred.
o 'Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occurred.

0 O~hers who observed t~is c9n~uct'descriqed it: to m~,
e', 0 I hav~ relevant Ihfdrmatiof\ classified Clb"oVE;. "$E~RET" .
f. 0" I nev.er observed ~his 'cqnquGtnQr:: h~rp ·abqu.t it from someone. who did.

d.

52. Tht¢atenih~ to use·spi.de.rs, .scoq:Jions, :snakes, cir·oth!'!( animals' on a deta'ine~:
a.

0

I pers6nally, observed thisJ:ondud.

b. q Iiobserved detainee(s} in a'cond ition that led me to believe that this conduct had ·:occurred.
0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.
-q . . D. Others.' wh9 observ~d t~j.s c;:omj uct ~escribed It t9 m~;
e. 0 I. hav.eJel~vantrn~ormation~Ias.~ifJe.g a~ove '''S~CR~''.
'f. 0 I !1~ver <,?b~~rv~.C\ th(s ',(;0!1~uc,t ngr ,hea 1'9 ;apo!J.J It ,fn?m :~ITl~qfJe.. who ~ Id,.

·,c.

,53. Qisrespectful starem~nts, hp nd'ling, ,Cir':actiQl')s·jrtvolving the [{bran

a.

0 , r persohally' observed. this .conduet.

b. o
c, 0
d.
e.

f.

54..

'I.obserVed detainee'(s} in ,a'condition that led me to: Delieve that ,t'his €0hdtid had occurred.
Detainee(s) told me that this· conduct- had ·occurred.·

0 Others, who observed this conduct described It to me.
0 r: hav.e relevant;, !nfQrmati()n c1assifi.~d qbove '\S-ECRET'''.
0 J;"n~,!er o,bserveq this 'COndyc~n9r h~rd ab.p~t it .fromsomeol)~:wh~oeM.

Shav.ing

c"d¢tainee's f!:icial pr other bair tQ. emqarfa,5~'or

humlliate' a .d~i:.('linee;

a. 0 r. persOnally oll.served, this.con·duct.

0
0

Detaiilee(s) foUf me that this condbet haa.ocGurr.ed'.

d.

o Imhers who observed ,this conduct descrfbed it to me.

t::

D.

I, hqv.e r~levant intormati()n dassifi~c;I aIJove "SECRET"',

f.

0

I, n~v.efo,bs~rved thi;; wndu~t'nor !leard crbqut- it fron:)' someone who diq,

b:.

e:

Lobseived detaiilee(s) in a eDna ition that led me'to, believe that this c00dilct had .occurred.

OIGQ-005407

55'..Placing a WQnia.n's:.cIothing oil a·detainee
a.
b.
c.

4,

0 [ personany observed ~his t:qnduct.
0 r obsem~d de!qinee(s) in a'cQnd i\:iqn that led .me to be!1~ye that thi~ condl,Jc;t \'l.ad ,oc<;urred.
0 D~taine~{s) tol~ m¢ that this· condu~t hap .occurrl;!d.

o 'Others' whQ observed this ~pnpuct described It to' me.

e. 0 I' have relevalit Iliformatioh' dassifieJ:labov.e. "SECRET".
f. ~ r ne~er bb.5~rved· thi!? conduct fJpr-'hf=a'r~ :abdll.t it frPm sorilebn~ whq

56. Toucning 'c3 detainee: or aCting :toward a'detaitlee

in-~ s~ual

~fd.

manner

~:.

th!.s:conduc::t.
0 I personClJ!Y"oJ?setved
'.
.
D t.oQserveet det~'in~'e(s} in .cn;on9 itJon·that leq lTJe t9 ~~lieYe th~It'thi~ cOfJdl1<;:~ .!lad ·oe<;:urr~p ..

c:·

D.

.~',

D Others whQ 9b.setY~d t.his eAne;! Llc.t .d:es·~db~d .it t~. ro~r
D f h~.ve rele'@nt 1t:t(orl1Jiition '(;Ias~ifi~d :c,~o~e'"'SECJ¢T'\

.a'!

~.

Oet,aJnee.(s) t9J~ ·me ~/1at thi? j:qnd:uc.t hqd :o.c;.<;un:tiI.

f. ~ ( nev~r;6pserV,ed thiscc6.nduct J''(Qr'h~rd .abb.ut it lrotn's~rTreQneWI:fQ ella..

5:7 •.H61d Ing

detainee(~)'

~:

0

or reg Istered as such b'y'the. a-ge-ricy
' .
.

Who ,were nQt officially acknowleclg ed

:detarning the· person.
I. p~r;sonallY' op.?E=tv.ed. ~his.:conQuc,t.

o 11' obse(Ved .detain·~~(s)- in a;C.bndfiiQn that led me to believ,e that this: conduct had occulTed.
D.
jpetairiee(s) tbld in¢ that thj~' c.9rid.uc~ 1]13'~ .occl,lrre{i ~
¢~
d. 0' Others: Who observed thj~ con.dut:;t,des:cr:lb-e.a It ~O. r.n 8',
b"

e, tl r hav.e teie;.v~nt
f;

0

iilformatipn:tlassified.:abo'ie: "SECRET".
I heverob~~'rve.d thi~"d)hauct nQr heari:! alrout it'fr:om someone.. who did.

.g. Please provide .the approximate time frame durillg. which this. c011dl1etoccu·rred.
From 09/11/100~ to. 1'1(1'3/20'03:
DD.o .NOt R~cal!
h. Tl:ie detaH:iee{s) treateCl ill this way Were Jodltea at the time iii:

OIGQ-005408

1

P ·Guantanamo.

2:

0' IRlq

:3 [j Afghanistan
'4 D 'Other Location
5 0 QO ~ot p.eeall
i. Please identify the. detainee(s) by nam'e 'and nurrtber:
l:Ink.nowl)

.j. ,PI~se: i.i:f'entify th~ pei;;on(s). whQ .tr¢"ated the detainee!(~). in this· nian~rf iiidu'ding their:'
name(s). and gov~r.l1merit aQ'enp,y{ies):
'
unknown

,K:. Please id,efllify'any'other: FBl'persormel -Or non-FBI 'p·~t'sorJrfel'wh0'.observ.eddetainee(s) ;treatea
In thIs manner:, fneludlng theIr name(s) and il.9.ency(ies):,

'

UilKno-Wn

t

This concfuct occu.rred' in ~,onn~ctl(;>n w~h:

10 ,One det~rrt.ee .

z a 'Several detainees ~2'-4).

:3 0 Mi:my..de'tairiees (mete-than 4.)
:4. 0 00' Not lSee;a1l
iii. (O'pti6ital) Please' 'describe the,relevant cifaurl'lstantes ih mo.&e;d.etail:·

,a.
b.
c.
d'.

D ~ pers::lIia\ly~obse'i'ved thfs,contluct.
D' ~,\obs'er·ved ,i:letainee(s} in ,a ,-cenci ition that led me. to belle:ve ttiat:this <::onduct had 0.cc'u·rrel:l'.
D Detalnee(s) told me that this ,conduct had occurred.
D btl:rer,;'who oqserved t.his cl:ll1.dl,lGtd~.s~ril:re~ jt to, me.

e.. . 0

r have r~levall.t rnform9tion c.l~ss_iJ(ep ?ib9Ve' l\qECRET~I .•

ll~ I,

nev~r Q'b~€'rv~d: t.!,!is'c<:>l)du~t.ro.r h~r~ qbqut It from som~ol']~wh.o did.

,SQ. T.hJ:eat~ning to ~nd a detain'ee to
a.

q r perSon-ally observed. this conduct.

D
'c. 0
_r .....
b.

another country for detention PI' more ag'gre:s~ive:·ihl~rrogatiolJ

I.bl:iserved detaJnee(s) in a'cond ition that led

'me to. believe that 'this Gm-nduct. had .00;curred.

Detainee(s)'told me that this conduct had occurred.
... -

,

.

-'.-

,-

- .

. ...

-,

,

..

OIGQ-005409

d.
e.
f.

I

0 Others who observed this conduct descrrbed It to me.
0 I have relevant information classified -above "SECRET".

o !t" never obs~rv~d this'conduct nor heard ~bout it from someon.~ wht? ~'id..

60, Threatening 19 take act!Q.\l ~gainst d detaine!3's family

0 I perS0nalJY obserVed this,conClLict.
b. 0 I observed detainee(s) iii a ,cond ition that led me' tb believe that this cbru:juCt. had ·occurred.
c, o Detainee(s) tbld me that this conduct had :occurred.

:a.

d"
e.

o lOthers who observed :this cond uet described it to' me.

0 I have relevant Information classified above !~S.ECRET"·.
f, 0 T, nev.er ob~el'\(e'cj this :colJdu~~ nor,h~~d 'aboyt it from :some~ne·wIJ9 diQ.

&LOtnertreqtr:]1ent or !=!(;tiPI1' cau~ID9 ~v~re, emotI9n.q'19r P~Yt:119Io9rCiII'ha ,

-

a. 0
b..

o

c. 0
,

-

I p'etsol1i=llly.observed this ,conduct.
!1.0bsi:rVed, deta[nee~s) Iii :a'cond Itloh that led me to belieVe that this condUct had occurr.etl.1
Detainee(s) told

me that this-conduct had

oceuri:ed.

,d.

o !Otllers who ohserved :this eoridud aescr'lb,ed it to me.

e.

0 I

If.

0

have relevant information' classified above "SECRET".

I, never observed this conduct nor heard about it frorn-'someone who' did.

',6,2, 9lh~r r~!igh>L!s' Q'r>5(:!;J:(!Jqr.h~[i;l~SlJle:nt or hqmi(@tiOJl·O(p OE:ltp:ineEj.
~a,

o II persOnally obserVed tilIs,conduct.

,e;

o iI bbserVea delainee"(s). iii a COr1pjtil;')h'matled me.t0 believe,tl:iat'this conduct haC! ·6.<ttlJftea.
o '0etalnee(s) tdld me thatthis: COr1cf'u.ct had .o.ccurr.ed:
o lathers who -observed this cohduct described it to' me,
o ir have'relevant information' classified aooye ..SECRET....

f.

0

b.
O.
d.

[' never observed thls:conduot nor heard about it 'from someone who. did.

OIGQ-00541 0

63", Oth~r treatment of a: detaine"e that In yo.ur pplnlon was unprpfes?ion~J, undUly harsh or aggressive,
:cbetciv;e, 'abusive, ,orUrilciwful

'a:
b,

0
0

I personally'observed this condu.ct.

Lobserved detainee(s) ina'condition that led me to believe that this c0nduct had ,occurred.

~,

o 'De,tainee(s) told rn~ that this- ce>!lduct had ·occurred.

~.
e,

0 Others wpo opserved t"hls cond u~t de~cr'I~ed ~t to'l)1e.
0 I have relevant inforrnati9'n .classified ab:ove "'SECRET'l,

f: [tl' I n~ver ol:!sE;!rved this 'tqn9l\et ndr h~rd 'agout itfrom:,s.o,niebJle whp' die!.

_1jlfYM:~@j~~
,.>:"f,
',:--:: .. :
,.' ~:
.64.. DiCl ,:Y.,o,u ,observe a'ny imp.etspriatT9n of FBl personn~1 by' aiiyon¢,duri'rig :<;i,n lnteNi¢W or 'interrO'g'9tloJi 'of
~a,det;;llnee7'

'

:0 Yes,

,(!j No

;65. Old. ~n.y·d,etalne~,or 6th~r ,~rsori ;tell you 'that 'hE~ or sh:e had witnessed ,the Imlle,r,50natlon of FBI,
:persomi'el In Gon'nectlon' wjth ~a: det-ain¢e intervjew til.lnterrogatio'ri?
.

,

..

,66'" :Are you. awc¥re

'0 Yes

0 N~

,

of 'arw "sh;;llJl:' or "s~ag~,"'(fet~1n~~ !nt,ervi,~W?"9~.Interrog'~ti.Q'r::!§~,()fid\let~ f9f .M~!TI bers,

J;lfthe'U;S,;',Co:ng i'\:lss- 9rt,heir s t a f f ? '

o Yes'

,

'0'Nti

~7:, To, your knpwle9g e~" Qid'a ny rril.lita ry. or int~lllgens::e personn~1 ~veJ ,qenv' or'gelay :F.Bi 'acc~~s, to,'a.
.
:detcllr.i¢e ,th~ FBI wanteq t~ q:!Je5,tlon Jjecgu~e the de~.~lne·e,haCi su.$tqlned InJUrle's after he wa.s tap,tur,e:d?

OYes'

0No

a.Yes

0

.

NQ

,6~, W¢re YaY <?yer tQId th"aJ ariW1!=f FBl :empJoY~~ end~ hi~ or her parti<;ipa~iprt iri

oJ pb'serva,tion bf~ a
defalriee interview or friterr.6gation lJetaose rifthe.:interview'orinterrogafi6b methods Being used?:
,
QYes
0 No,

7Q~ During'a,ny of YQ.ur p'Verse.1;'l? ~epJoym.en~s. pr assigriment~,. pid ,y~u r~p,Qrt <my' COricern~ reg~rding
'cfny;detainee int.ervieW·,or interrogation p_ractice~, or other-ty.pes,6f detaihee: tr~tnie.ntr
an' FBI,

to.

OIGQ-005411

supervisor?

DVes, 0 No
71. During _anY 'of your o:v~t$e~s,'d~ploYri1~ntsor a:ssig~nri1!2nts~ pid 'loll n:port ,any' con~er.l1,S regard irig
any,deta'inee interview _or interrogation practices or other ty"pes'of!Ietailiee treatment-yQu
observed or heard about, to a non-FBI supervisor or other non-FBI perso.nnel?
.
o:y~s
(V-No'
T1.~ ii'av~:'Y~u \~\ier Q'een ~rOElre9 qf tlii:ected t;lQ.t'to reRort, 'oqfisqj_4r~ed in. ~ny W<iY fg)rtl rep'orting r
QD~rV~tion,s or~IJ~[,fatibns related, fo a.etain~·e treatment or il1tel"li¢w' or interrogation :ac,tior'l.s' or'
-..

-;:;l

p.ra~tlces.

,

•

o

Yes
@'N'O
7:;", i-1 gve:yol:l ~periE:~nc~ .?fny actUgL or threaten~d retaliaU9n: fr;>r re'por:ting pt,Js~rv.:l~ic:m5:oralleg?tic;ms
9f·,d~ta.:jn~~, tr~<ll:fn~,rjt :!=ir J.rtt,ervievv. Qr !fit~.r.rQgati9n ·,a.c;tigf1,~ fir pr~:lt!i!;,esl

o Yes'
..

0 No
'

'

74. (9.P~!91"!~1~ PJe,~~; p-rbvide ,C!r!Yad,qt~iQJ1a.t <;;<?mment.~'J:egc;lrdrng .t~~ r~PQrtJrm :pf ~qri~!2rns: r~!qted t9'
j.r.it~tYi~V>( 9r iotet-rpgi3tiqrJ: t¢~h~liqu~sr ae;eritJoii pr.;(e:.tk~, r;>pPt\'fet t1¢fci'lrre¢ W~.c1tment. .
.

..

:~

0. '_

....

i

, 75. W¢t;eyou. de,[)rief¢d r.. other''than :the ~tahtfard d~bri~fjn FD-n.2, ~o~~r.ning you r '6V¢.r~a~
assl~nment(s) or .dep.loymei'it(s.) afteryoucomplefed the deployment(s) or,ass!g'riment(s)7

0'YesO No:
75a,., who debriefed you!
S~ 'Ffi"fnk BaUle.'ano 6thei's
7.5b.. When- and' whe're:dld th~f.ieb.ti~fjng{s)'.Qi:X:!Jr.?
~ppr~)},{ ~,mQntb ,after when Jwas'?~ke~_ tq p.r9yide InsighJs:'tQJ'fu~ur.egepI.9yrnelJts
],5 Were you as~ed about detainee..detention or interview or interrogation' practices.during the
.' c, (!.ebrr~fil1g(sn
'
'

bYes

@Nb

75d., Wh'at ,other Su.,bjects.Were cov,ereCl du r.inSLYour' debriefiiig ~s).?
mission de,strip~,on/prqp.o:s:e~ J:han.g$ W mlssio,ni:ass~S'siTiel'lt of n)'!s.~ion·success/b~tpractjt¢S.
7:pe. Was <ilny ~oclJfTl~nt p'repar~d tq me_mQrla'llz~~tb'e"liebrl§fl,ng.1.
'
,
0 ~eS 0 N:6 ODo NOt' Know'
i~,; Ac;lditiqhal
'tion'e

CQmm€nts'.quct R!=!;Qrnmeodadpns:
Thank-you 'for your::cdoperatiort .in

tomplet'ih,g this, tjUestion'naire,

OIGQ-005412