New Montana Law Bans Warrantless Facial Recognition Surveillance
Loaded on Sept. 1, 2023
by Jordan Arizmendi
published in Criminal Legal News
September, 2023, page 49
Filed under:
Warrantless Searches,
Authentication/Identification,
EP2P Software,
Eyewitness Identification.
Location:
Montana.
by Jordan Arizmendi
At the end of June 2023, Montana Governor Greg Gianforte signed a bill, Senate Bill 397 (“SB397”) that will ban warrantless facial recognition surveillance, generally. According to the law, the exceptions that would permit a law enforcement agency to perform a facial recognition search include: if probable cause exists that an unknown individual in an image has committed a crime, is a victim of a crime, or is a witness to a serious crime; might be a local missing person; or if law enforcement needs to identify a corpse.
SB397 bans “the monitoring of public places or third-party image sets using facial recognition technology for facial identification to match faces with a prepopulated list of face images. The term includes but is not limited to scanning stored video footage to identify faces in the stored data, real-time scanning of video surveillance to identify passing by the cameras, and passively monitoring video footage using facial recognition technology for general surveillance purposes without a particularized suspicion of a specific target.”
As a result of SB397, law enforcement will need to get a warrant, before requesting a facial recognition search in the investigation of a serious crime. The lone exception to this requirement is if there is an imminent threat posed to an individual.
Sources: tenthamendmentcenter.org
More from this issue:
- Geofence Warrants: Little-Known Search Makes Innocent People Suspects Simply for Having a Phone Near a Crime Scene, by Douglas Ankney
- What’s ‘Sufficient’ Rehabilitation for Compassionate Release?, by James Lockhart, Luke Sommer
- Interrogating a Suspect With an Intellectual Disability Using the Reid Technique: Recipe for a False Confession, by Jo Ellen Nott
- Forensic Benefits of a Body Farm Facility, by Jordan Arizmendi
- Surveilling AI’s Big Moment, by Michael Thompson
- Police Can Get More From Your Phone Than You May Believe, by Michael Thompson
- Wyoming Supreme Court Reverses ‘Contempt of Cop’ Conviction Because Police Were Not Lawfully Performing Their Official Duties, by Richard Resch
- Sixth Circuit Suppresses Evidence Obtained as a Result of Warrant That Lacked Probable Cause of Criminal Activity in Arson Investigation, by Anthony Accurso
- Arizona Blowfly Database Develops Empirical Support for Time of Death Estimation, by Anthony Accurso
- California Court of Appeal Reverses Felony Murder Conviction Because Evidence Insufficient to Support Underlying Predicate Felony of Attempted Robbery, by Douglas Ankney
- Probation Sentences Capped in Minnesota, by Jordan Arizmendi
- Biased Algorithms Are Still a Problem, by Michael Thompson
- The Two Faces of the FBI and DOD Facial Recognition Program, by Carlo Difundo
- No Discipline for NYPD Officers Who Deface License Plates in Apparent Attempt to Evade Tickets, by Douglas Ankney
- New York Court of Appeals: Constitutional Prohibition Against Restraining Defendant Without Explanation Remains in Force During Announcement of Verdict and Polling of Jurors, by Douglas Ankney
- New York City’s DNA Gun Crimes Unit Reduces Turnaround Times for Gun Crimes by Half, by Jordan Arizmendi
- Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Casts Nearly 30,000 DUI Convictions in Doubt Due to ‘Egregious Government Misconduct’, by Jordan Arizmendi
- The Serious Threat of Cell-Site Simulators, by Michael Thompson
- Second Circuit Vacates § 924 Convictions Predicated on Attempted Hobbs Act Robbery, by Douglas Ankney
- Law Enforcement Using Technology That Accesses Live Video From Any Camera Connected to the Internet, by Jordan Arizmendi
- New Study Proposes Biological Reasons May Cause Sudden Infant Death Syndrome, by Jordan Arizmendi
- Mississippi Ends ‘Dead Zone’, by Jordan Arizmendi
- New Service Highlights Cellphone Privacy Issues, by Michael Thompson
- ‘Lab in a Box’ Provides DNA Results in Minutes, by Jordan Arizmendi
- Report Finds Older Prisoners in Maryland Are Less Likely to Be Paroled, by Jordan Arizmendi
- New Robotic Cops Patrolling in NYC, by Jordan Arizmendi
- Supreme Court of California: After Amendments to Three Strikes Law, Courts Retain Concurrent Sentencing Discretion for Qualifying Offenses Committed on Same Occasion or Arising From Same Operative Facts, by Douglas Ankney
- New York Court of Appeals: Call Intercepted on Wiretap Not Exempt From Statutory Notice Requirements Simply Because Same Call Captured on Separate, Consensual Recording by Jail, by Anthony Accurso
- Fourth Circuit Denies Defendant Faced ‘Classic Penalty Situation’ During Polygraph Questioning While on Supervised Release, by Anthony Accurso
- Seventh Circuit: Whether Right to Counsel ‘Attaches’ Is Not Dependent on Defendant’s Appearance at Probable Cause Hearing, by Anthony Accurso
- Sixth Circuit Holds Bump Stocks Not Regulated Under Machinegun Statute, by Anthony Accurso
- New Jersey Supreme Court: Third-Party’s Apparent Authority to Consent to Search Premises Does Not Extend to Defendant’s Personal Property Located on Premises, by Anthony Accurso
- Travis County, Texas, Efforts to Keep Mentally Ill Individuals Out of Jail Face Funding, Infrastructure, and Information Management Challenges, by Jo Ellen Nott
- Third Circuit: Pennsylvania Second-Degree Aggravated Assault of a Protected Individual Not a ‘Violent Felony’ Under ACCA, Court Acknowledges ‘Bizarre Result’, by Anthony Accurso
- From the Sad but True Files: Police Oppose Laws Prohibiting Cops From Lying to Juveniles During Interrogations, by Douglas Ankney
- Colorado Supreme Court Clarifies There Is No Per Se Rule Excluding Self-Serving Hearsay, by Matthew Clarke
- Collaborative Project Between Innocence Project and National Registry of Exonerations Produces Interim Report Reconciling Data Coding Discrepancies, by Casey Bastian
- New Montana Law Bans Warrantless Facial Recognition Surveillance, by Jordan Arizmendi
- ‘Silos’ Can Keep Police Departments From Knowledge of Extent of Police Abuse and Consequences of That Abuse, by Matthew Clarke
- News in Brief
More from Jordan Arizmendi:
- Minnesota Becomes Third State to Restrict ‘Excited Delirium’, July 15, 2024
- After Stripping Crucial Jail Services, NYC Splurges on $90,000 in Submachine Guns for Rikers Island Guards, April 26, 2024
- Disgraced NYC Council Candidate Gets Slap-on-the-Wrist Sentence, April 26, 2024
- Colorado Becomes Seventh State to Prohibit Jailing Immigrants for ICE, April 26, 2024
- After Ohio Becomes 24th State to Legalize Recreational Marijuana, What Next?, Feb. 15, 2024
- Jesse Johnson: 194th Person Exonerated While on Death Row, Jan. 15, 2024
- Chicago Cop Lied So Many Times Under Oath That Prosecutors Are Dismissing Cases That Relied on His Testimony, Dec. 15, 2023
- Report Finds Effective Text Message Reminders Can Reduce Community Supervision Violations, Dec. 15, 2023
- New York Court Rules Police Allowed to Use Familial DNA Searches, Dec. 15, 2023
- New Jersey Takes First Steps in Eliminating Public Defender Fees, Nov. 1, 2023
More from these topics:
- Buried in Plain Sight: How Digital Discovery Turns Disclosure Itself Into Concealment, Aug. 15, 2026. Videotaping, Suppression of Identity Evidence, Eyewitness Identification, Withholding of Exculpatory Evidence.
- Detroit Pays $5.8 Million to Former State Prisoner Exonerated of Murder After 15 Years, Aug. 1, 2026. Wrongful Conviction, Qualified Immunity, 42 U.S. Code § 1983, civil action for deprivation of rights, Eyewitness Identification, Evidence - Failure to Disclose.
- Seventh Circuit Announces Courts May Examine Individual Officer’s Subjective Purpose When Assessing Whether Warrantless Administrative Inspection Was Pretextual, Holding Suppression Required Where Trooper’s Sole Motive for Stop Was Criminal Investigati, Aug. 1, 2026. Warrantless Searches, Exception to Warrant Requirement, Pretextual Stops, Searches - Administrative, Suppression.
- New Mexico Supreme Court Announces Article II, Section 10 Exclusionary Rule Governs Admissibility of Evidence Seized Outside State by Non-New Mexico Officers, Aug. 1, 2026. Warrantless Searches, Conflict of Laws/Decisions, State Constitutional Claims, Suppression, Exclusionary Rule.
- Conviction Tossed for Former Alabama Prisoner Paroled After 42 Years, July 1, 2026. Sex Offender Registration, Wrongful Conviction, Forensic Sciences, Eyewitness Identification, Brady Rule violations.
- Hawai’i Supreme Court Holds Trial Court Failed to Consider HAWJIC 3.19A Factors and “Effect of Suggestiveness on Reliability” When Evaluating Field Show-Up Identifications, July 1, 2026. witness misidentification, Motions To Suppress, Evidence - Integrity/Reliability of, Suppression of Identity Evidence, Eyewitness Identification.
- California Court of Appeal: Vehicle Impoundment Solely to Prevent Further Unlicensed Driving Does Not Satisfy Fourth Amendment’s Community Caretaking Exception; Statutory Authorization Alone Insufficient to Establish Constitutional Reasonableness, June 1, 2026. Warrantless Searches, Motions To Suppress, Searches - Inventory, Community Caretaking Exception/Doctrine, Seizure.
- The Constitution for Sale: FBI Confirms Resumption of Data Broker Dragnets, June 1, 2026. Fourth Amendment, rights, Warrantless Searches, Cell-Phone Location/Tracking Data, Electronic Surveillance, Privacy Act/Rights.
- Fourth Circuit Announces Defendant Has Standing to Appeal Based Solely on Rogers–Singletary Claim of a “Material Discrepancy Between” Written and Orally Articulated Judgment at Sentencing, May 1, 2026. Failure to Object, Appealable Issues/Orders, Warrantless Searches, Reasonable Suspicion, Special Conditions.
- Guilty Until Proven Innocent: The Due Process Risks of Automated Traffic Enforcement, May 1, 2026. Fourteenth Amendment, rights, Electronic Surveillance, Privacy Act/Rights, Authentication/Identification, Evidence - Integrity/Reliability of.
