The Arrival of REAL ID: National ID Cards and Internal Passports in America
A common trope in science fiction involves a dystopian future where every trip to the airport, government office, and other routine errands of daily life requires residents to show a standardized ID, their every move tracked through a web of mass surveillance. That fictional dystopian future came one step closer to reality on May 7, 2025, with the full rollout of the REAL ID Act. What was once a patchwork of state driver’s licenses has become a de facto national ID, mandatory for domestic flights and federal building access. Although not designated as such, REAL ID is essentially an internal passport.
For years, federal officials insisted a national ID card would never be part of America’s fabric. Nevertheless, as of May 7, 2025, the REAL ID Act has quietly made that a reality. State-issued driver’s licenses have morphed into standardized IDs, which are now required for domestic air travel and entry to federal facilities.
Enacted in 2005 as a response to 9/11 security concerns, the REAL ID Act established federal standards for state-issued IDs, mandating features like a star or flag to show compliance. The goal was to create fraud-resistant identification, but critics see it as a national ID card in all but name. After nearly two decades of delays—driven by state pushback, privacy concerns, and logistical challenges—the law is now fully enforced. As of May 2025, you need a REAL ID-compliant license, a passport, or another approved ID to board domestic flights or access certain federal buildings.
Opponents argue this shift chips away at personal freedom. Jim Harper from the Cato Institute warns that national ID systems erode “practical obscurity,” the natural shield that comes from decentralized records. With REAL ID, states share data through interconnected databases, creating a centralized pool of personal information ripe for hacking or abuse. Alexis Hancock of the Electronic Frontier Foundation notes that the U.S. functioned just fine without REAL ID for years, casting doubt on its necessity for security.
The rollout has been rocky. While exact compliance rates vary, some states report significant numbers of residents still without REAL IDs, forcing many to rely on passports or face delays at TSA checkpoints. The Transportation Security Administration accepts alternatives like Global Entry cards or military IDs, but those without compliant ID risk extra screening or being turned away. “I’d rather carry my passport than give the government more of my data” is a sentiment shared by many wary of ever-increasing mass surveillance.
Supporters insist REAL ID strengthens security by making IDs harder to forge. “It ensures people are who they say they are,” says security expert Michael O’Rourke. But skeptics argue that determined criminals can still bypass these measures, leaving ordinary Americans to bear the burden of carrying their “papers” for everyday tasks.
The broader concern is what REAL ID signals: a move toward routine identity checks. It is not difficult to envision a future where these IDs are required for banking, voting, or even shopping. Other nations, like Russia with its internal passports or China with its hukou system—internal passport and identity management apparatus—show how such tools can evolve into instruments of government control over the domestic movements and activities of the population.
For critics of the REAL ID mandate, it feels like a “show me your papers” moment in disguise. REAL ID is here, but that does not mean we must embrace it or pretend it is anything other than a national ID system by another name. As we navigate this new reality, we must remain vigilant, questioning not just the convenience of a standardized ID but the cost to our privacy and autonomy.
Benjamin Franklin’s famous admonition penned more than two centuries ago seems especially appropriate for the current debate: “Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.”
Sources: reason.com, Electronic Frontier Foundation
As a digital subscriber to Criminal Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
