×
You've used up your 3 free articles for this month. Subscribe today.
Tenth Circuit, Joining Sister Circuits, Announces ‘Personal-Use’ Drug Quantity Doesn’t Constitute ‘Relevant Conduct’ Under Guidelines § 1B1.3(a) and Sets Forth Framework for Burden of Proof Analysis
Loaded on Feb. 15, 2022
by Douglas Ankney
published in Criminal Legal News
March, 2022, page 37
Filed under:
Drug Quantity,
Simple Possession/Personal Use versus Distribution,
Relevant Conduct.
Location:
Colorado.
by Douglas Ankney
In a case of first impression, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit adopted the burden-shifting framework of United States v. Asch, 207 F.3d 1238 (10th Cir. 2000), in announcing that (1) personal-use drug quantity doesn’t constitute “relevant conduct” under Guidelines § …
Full article and associated cases available to subscribers.
As a digital subscriber to Criminal Legal News, you can access full text and downloads for this and other premium content.
Already a subscriber? Login
More from this issue:
- Acquitted Conduct Sentencing, by Douglas Ankney
- Mental Health Response Teams Proved Effective in New York City, by Casey Bastian
- ‘Planning for Losing’: A Lesson on Justice Reform from Afghanistan, by Marc Levin
- Texas Court of Criminal Appeals: Defendant Satisfied Requirements of Confession and Avoidance, ‘Unintentional Self-Defense’ Jury Instruction Allowed Against Charge of Intentional Offense, by Douglas Ankney
- Fourth Circuit: State’s Failure to Plead Procedural Default Results in De Novo Review on Merits; Prosecutor’s Comments to Jury to Send ‘Societal Message’ Denied Defendant Fair Trial, Habeas Relief Warranted, by Dale Chappell
- Mental Illness and False Confessions: A Wakeup Call to Investigators, by Joseph Buckley
- Georgia Supreme Court Declares ‘Relevance’ Not Legal Standard for Suppression Determination Where Items Seized Outside Scope of Warrant, Clarifies Plain View Doctrine Proper Standard, and Overrules McBee, Walsh Line of Cases, by Anthony Accurso
- Michigan Supreme Court Announces 2011 SORA May Not Be Retroactively Applied to Registrants Whose Offenses Predated Its Enactment Because Doing So Violates Prohibition on Ex Post Facto Laws, by Douglas Ankney
- California Now Able to Decertify Bad Cops, by Edward Lyon
- Texas Court of Criminal Appeals: Trial Court Abused Discretion by Refusing to Allow Withdrawal of Jury-Trial Waiver for Defendant Who Ultimately Rejected Plea Deal, by David Reutter
- Texas Court of Criminal Appeals: Although Subsequent Indictment Recites Same Language as Original Indictment, SOL Isn’t Tolled Where Subsequent Indictment Fails to Charge Same Conduct, Act, or Transaction, by Douglas Ankney
- Idaho Supreme Court Rejects ‘Instinctive Entry Rule’ as Not Implicating Fourth Amendment Where Drug-Sniffing Dog Breaches Interior of Vehicle During Exterior Search and Suppresses Evidence, by Douglas Ankney
- SCOTUS Announces Pursuit of a Misdemeanant Does Not Categorically Constitute an Exigent Circumstance Authorizing a Warrantless Home Entry, by Douglas Ankney
- Pennsylvania Supreme Court Announces New Framework for Enforcing Right to Effective Counsel in Post-Conviction Relief Act Proceeding, by Douglas Ankney
- Connecticut Supreme Court Overrules Aquino, Holding Appeal Not Moot Where Defendant Deported During Pendency but Unclear Whether Appealed Conviction Sole Basis for Deportation, by Douglas Ankney
- California Court of Appeal: Peremptory Challenge to Judge in Habeas Case Subject to 10-Day Filing Period, Not 60 Days, Under § 170.6(a)(1), by Dale Chappell
- Nevada Supreme Court: Prisoner’s Claim He Is Now Actually Innocent of Death Penalty Sufficient to Overcome Proce-dural Bars to Habeas Relief, by Douglas Ankney
- SCOTUS: Rehaif Error Doesn’t Automatically Require Reversal of Conviction, Plain-Error Test Must Be Satisfied for Re-lief, by Dale Chappell
- Oregon Supreme Court Announces Abandonment of Per Se Exigency Rule in Automobile Exception and Holds Warrantless Seizure or Search Must Be Based on Actual Exigent Circumstances, by Jacob Barrett
- Tenth Circuit, Joining Sister Circuits, Announces ‘Personal-Use’ Drug Quantity Doesn’t Constitute ‘Relevant Conduct’ Under Guidelines § 1B1.3(a) and Sets Forth Framework for Burden of Proof Analysis, by Douglas Ankney
- Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Announces Bodycam Video Subsequently Reviewed in Unrelated Investigation Constitutes Unconstitutional Warrantless Search, by Anthony Accurso
- Concealed Videos Expose Pattern of Abuse by Louisiana State Police, by Jayson Hawkins
- Vermont Supreme Court Announces Proper Legal Standard for Warrantless Search of Home’s Curtilage, by Anthony Accurso
- Eighth Circuit: Inadmissible Hearsay Improperly Used to Revoke Supervised Release, by Matthew Clarke
- Facial Recognition Run-Down, by Anthony Accurso
- Rutgers University Pioneers New Jersey Innocence Project, by Casey Bastian
- Sixth Circuit: Michigan’s Ordinarily ‘Adequate’ Contemporaneous-Objection Rule, in Unique Circumstances, May Not Procedurally Bar Federal Habeas Review, by Dale Chappell
- Massachusetts Remains a Civil Forfeiture Outlier, by Jayson Hawkins
- Non-Prosecution Policies Seem to Work in Baltimore, by Jayson Hawkins
- Florida’s Catch-22 for the Innocent Defendant (and Others Wishing to Protect Their Right Against Self-Incrimination), by M. Eve Hanan
- DEA Continues to Seize Money Without Proof of Criminality, by Casey Bastian
- Big Tech Using Third Parties to Sell Surveillance Tools to ICE and Border Patrol, by Anthony Accurso
- Pegasus Software: State-sponsored Spyware Usage Likely Infecting Billions of Phones, by Casey Bastian
- Armed Police Drones Are Coming, by Anthony Accurso
- News in Brief
More from Douglas Ankney:
- Seventh Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment Dismissal in Case Where Prisoner Failed to Provide Verifying Medical Evidence, Nov. 1, 2026
- Federal District Court Adopts Magistrate’s Report Certifying Class in Suit Alleging Faulty Plumbing at Washington Jail, Nov. 1, 2026
- Study Reveals that Average Earnings of Former California Prisoners Before and After Incarnation Are Below Poverty Threshold, Nov. 1, 2026
- Washington DOC Fails to Implement Changes to Correct the Abuses of Solitary Confinement, Nov. 1, 2026
- Surprise Inspection of USP Canaan Reveals Severe Medical Deficiencies, Abusive Use of Restraints and Racist Images in Staff Areas, Nov. 1, 2026
- Fifty Percent Reduction in Women’s Prison Sentences in Illinois and North Carolina Would Yield Tremendous Cost Savings with Only a Negligible Increase in Violent Crime, Nov. 1, 2026
- New Study from The Sentencing Project Looks at the Trends of Mass Incarceration, Nov. 1, 2026
- Report from the National Academies Reveals that System for Reporting In-Custody Deaths Is Underfunded and Unreliable, Nov. 1, 2026
- One Out of Every 61 People Nationwide is Under Some Form of Correctional Control, Nov. 1, 2026
- The Dramatic Increase in the Elderly Prison Population Is Fiscally and Morally Irresponsible, Oct. 1, 2026
More from these topics:
- Relevant Conduct: How Federal Sentencing Law Punishes More Than the Crime of Conviction, Aug. 1, 2026. U.S. Sentencing Guidelines, Prior Conviction/Sentence/Incarceration, Plain Error, Acquitted Conduct/Uncharged Crimes/Dismissed Counts, Relevant Conduct.
- Second Circuit Clarifies Limits on Sentencing Court’s Use of Unrelated Co-Defendant Conduct as § 3553(a) “Context”, June 1, 2026. Statement of Reasons, Plain Error, Factors To Be Considered, Acquitted Conduct/Uncharged Crimes/Dismissed Counts, Relevant Conduct.
- U.S. Sentencing Commission: 2026 Amendments to the Federal Sentencing Guidelines, June 1, 2026. U.S. Sentencing Guidelines, Alternative Sentencing, Sentence Enhancements/Departures, Multiple/Multiplicious Counts, Drug Quantity.
- First Circuit Vacates Drug Courier’s Sentence, Holding District Court Erred by Failing to Conduct Proper Comparative Culpability Analysis Under § 3B1.2 When It Excluded Other Participants in Drug Shipment From Universe of Comparators, May 1, 2026. U.S. Sentencing Guidelines, Mitigating Role/Circumstances/Evidence, Appellate Jurisdiction/Review, Sentencing Findings, Relevant Conduct.
- Two Texas Women Charged for Using Plastic Crows in Smuggling Scheme, April 1, 2026. Cell Phone Access, Conspiracies, Attempts, Solicitations, Bureau of Prisons (BOP), Methamphetamine, Simple Possession/Personal Use versus Distribution.
- Fourth Circuit: Government Breached Plea Agreement by Successfully Arguing for Sentencing Enhancement Based on “Total Relevant Conduct” Not Stipulated to in Plea Agreement, Oct. 15, 2025. Breach of Plea/Coop./Immunity Agreements, In Connection With Another Felony Offense, Plea Bargaining, Acquitted Conduct/Uncharged Crimes/Dismissed Counts, Relevant Conduct.
- Houston Police Fire Former Jail Guard Filmed Brutalizing Detainees, Charges Against Three Other Guards Dropped, March 1, 2025. Videotaping, Guard Brutality/Beatings, Relevant Conduct.
- Colorado Legislature’s New Jail Oversight Committee Not Weighted in Detainees’ Favor, Jan. 15, 2025. Government Misconduct, Committee Reports, Relevant Conduct.
- Arizona Governor Creates Independent Prison Oversight Commission, Nov. 15, 2023. Conditions of Confinement, Relevant Conduct.
- New York Succeeds in Firing Fewer Than 10% of Guards Accused of Prisoner Abuse, Nov. 15, 2023. Guard Misconduct, Relevant Conduct.





